Found a UN estimate that shows North Mudug is almost 5 times bigger in population than south mudug
- Thread starter Abdisomali
- Start date
- Status
That census is totally bs
How sxb
Exactly right.
Xamar alone must be 3.5 without idp.
Hargesia is about 1.5 without the rest of waqooyi galbeed.
Bosaso is about 1.1 mil.
Fake census
Ehh I’d say Mogadishu is 2.5 million bare minimum max id say 3
1.5 is bare minimum for hargeisa it’s probably closer to 2
Bosaso though is barely 800k in my opinion
I have been to both bosaso and hargeysa.
They are about the same. Bosasso is way more denser.
1.1 Bosaso
Hargeysa 1.5
Xamar you cant even count the idp let alone the population. Xamar is almost all the way to afgooye as they created so many cites near by it.
You’re mistaken bro , waaay less people live in Bosaso and it’s not close. It’s ar least a 400-500k difference .
Saalax Bidaar
Truthfulness so often goes with ruthlessness
W. Waqooyi is the second most populous province in Somalia after Banadir
I know but their numbers sre wrong. To say all of waqooyi galbeed is 1.3 mil is disrespectful
UNFPA is totally bullshit and was rejected by PL. Awdal the same Size as Bari? like come on niyahow, you can go into Awdal on google earth and see it yourself plus they are not camel herders eithers so everything u see in their settlement is all there is, same with the south all they have is settlements. PL is different, its 50% settlement then 50% nomads, it's the same as DDSI. We want the population that was used on DDSI approach used on PL.
Qardho alone the town is about 70k and then the villages around it another 70k. Then nomads who aren't settled need accounting for. That's just qardho district. Qardho vs Awdal dheh not bari. I would say qardho alone is 50k the town itself and then tuulos around it all added up 70k. But it's nomads which is another 100k. I can accept 200k for Qardho and it's nomadic population combined. 100K settled another 100k on camels.
I estimate osman mahmud is about 400k marki lays wada geeyo. Omar mahmud is triple.
Qardho alone the town is about 70k and then the villages around it another 70k. Then nomads who aren't settled need accounting for. That's just qardho district. Qardho vs Awdal dheh not bari. I would say qardho alone is 50k the town itself and then tuulos around it all added up 70k. But it's nomads which is another 100k. I can accept 200k for Qardho and it's nomadic population combined. 100K settled another 100k on camels.
I estimate osman mahmud is about 400k marki lays wada geeyo. Omar mahmud is triple.
Last edited:
GBTarmy
VIP
southern mudug is mostly small tuulos big land but low population density, north mudug is obviously more. Its its true after banadir waqooyi galbeed is second most populous region and lower shabelle third. I think Xamar is around 2million some people like to exaggerate it to 3 million.
Also this is the first time they separated mudug instead of making it 50/50 and staying PC, galgaduud also has low population you could argue most of them moved to xamar
Also this is the first time they separated mudug instead of making it 50/50 and staying PC, galgaduud also has low population you could argue most of them moved to xamar
Lower Shabelle has no camel herders, that's their population 100% represented what u see is what u get with them. Their not big at all. Osman mahmud alone is half mogadishu population. Omar mahmud could fill mogadishu by himself easily.
DDSI is the best gouge. 8 million and I don't see big settlements there. Big settlements dont mean shit.
GBTarmy
VIP
Lower shabelle has a big population density and a lot of big towns and farms. they have many districts as well.
But u never answered the logical premise, DDSI has no big town yet is close to the same population size of all Somalia. Just because u don't have a big town doesn't mean your not populous, it means u didn't settle yet only. Lower shabelle settled because of farming. Rahanwayn are tiny in comparison to other somalis.
The only way to see population properly is to get all the nomads to settle you will see 10 mogadishu and hargeisa tommorow just from harti alone. How can 40% of the economy be dominated by livestock if they don't have big population the nomads? wax macqul bala sheega niyahow. Kismayo is majority harti but it dont mean shit sxb because the cagdheere has 10 times the size population of kismaayo in camel herders right outside the region grazing.
Settlements are only 50% of the picture of somalia as a wholeeeeeeeeeee, and it's only 30% for puntland. I think only 30% have settled among harti in all reality. What u see in puntland 2 million is only 30% of puntland population. The reason I say that brother, they wouldn't own our economy by 60% haday niman yar yihin the nomads.
Last edited:
If the nomads left puntland today, our economy would drop to 30% because our population power would only be left in settlements. They are very significant to Puntland, not so much the south but in puntland very signficant. I study the nomad population more then settlements because settlements only produce 30% of our economy, their langaab thats why.
If you add up all puntland cities today and their economic contribution including bosaso, galkayo,garowe, the whole lot. It would only be 30% because 70% is livestock and that means NOMAD POPULATION. you have to use your brain.
I accept PL is about 2.5 million in settlements but u need to accept that is only 30% of our population and we are already large just with 30% settled. Allahu akbar. But if u add our nomads then u need another 70%, your looking around 7 million for harti alone. Harti iyo absame ayaa isu dhow population markan firiye. While southerners we will look at their GDP, you will notice 70% is from agriculture so 70% is settled. the rest are in cities. So all they have is 3 million in the south niyahow thats it.
8 million ogaden. 7 million harti. Sade forget. Hawiye/Isaaq/Dir/Rahanwayn marki laysu geeyo they are less from what I saw.
If you add up all puntland cities today and their economic contribution including bosaso, galkayo,garowe, the whole lot. It would only be 30% because 70% is livestock and that means NOMAD POPULATION. you have to use your brain.
I accept PL is about 2.5 million in settlements but u need to accept that is only 30% of our population and we are already large just with 30% settled. Allahu akbar. But if u add our nomads then u need another 70%, your looking around 7 million for harti alone. Harti iyo absame ayaa isu dhow population markan firiye. While southerners we will look at their GDP, you will notice 70% is from agriculture so 70% is settled. the rest are in cities. So all they have is 3 million in the south niyahow thats it.
8 million ogaden. 7 million harti. Sade forget. Hawiye/Isaaq/Dir/Rahanwayn marki laysu geeyo they are less from what I saw.
Last edited:
I realized this when looking qurbaha and the towns. It's always darod majority. Haday somali meel isu timaado weligeed darod is like ten times the size. I look at hawiye functions it's tiny niyahow markay iyagu isla yimadan lakin marki somalia iyo waxas la yimadan 70% of them sitting is darod.
- Status
Trending
-
-
Old thread i found on timojileec/arab Muslims talking about African women….- Started by caanoshaah
- Replies: 94
-
