Genetic DNA Is It Over-Rated

[DR OSMAN]

I am still not convinced by genetic DNA becuz Tutsi are well known to originate from Ethiopia and were Nomadic but their Y DNA is the same as the Hutu.

Y-DNA (paternal lineages)
Modern-day genetic studies of the Y-chromosome generally indicate that the Tutsi, like the Hutu, are largely of Bantu extraction (60% E1b1a, 20% B, 4% E-P2(xE1b1a))

Please convince me about DNA and Language link, becuz Tutsi only converted by language. Is this 1 cushitic woke cries the same scenario.

 

[DR OSMAN]

The other problem I have with DNA is majority and minority clad. Did majority clad displace the true minority clad or did minority clad come to the pre-existing majority clad. The minority clad is aborigine here but large displacement happened to them by majority clad which is well documented. If we didn't know this by history, would we argue that majority clad is native and minority clad is non native.

This has significant consideration to all majority-minority clad in different region. I haven't heard of a large displacement to the scale of aborigines in history but I have heard of wiping out male lines due to war.

The mid-east is today majority J with a minority E clad. Either the majority clad is J and native and E is recent arrival or E is native but displaced by J Clad, it can't be both, it has to be one or the other. Either the true early israelites-arabs were E clad natives displaced by modern J or J were the early population of ancient israel and ancient arabia and E minority clads were converted to their cultures.

This tie between afro-asiatic languages is interesting, I think they just don't want to accept ancient egypt was a true native african civilization who said their land of ancestors and god was land of punt.

 

[Username]

I have seen many Tutsi get E-M293 which is E1B1B (even a few Somalis get that on 23andMe)

E-M293 YTree

www.yfull.com

 

[El Nino]

Tutsis are mainly E-M29,

The mid-east is today majority J with a minority E clad. Either the majority clad is J and native and E is recent arrival or E is native but displaced by J Clad, it can't be both, it has to be one or the other. Either the true early israelites-arabs were E clad natives displaced by modern J or J were the early population of ancient israel and ancient arabia and E minority clads were converted to their cultures.

This tie between afro-asiatic languages is interesting, I think they just don't want to accept ancient egypt was a true native african civilization who said their land of ancestors and god was land of punt.

Its a real theory that afro-asiatic language group is associated with haplogroup e1b1b, just look what haplogroup dominates cushites (ethio-semitic speakers included) and berbers / north africans. E1b1b as you said is present in large numbers in Middle East, unfortunately haven't found anything indicating the for chadic speakers / west africans. Seems only small minority have it there. Maybe the genetic crew here can help you better

 

[mahamdov]

I have seen many Tutsi get E-M293 which is E1B1B (even a few Somalis get that on 23andMe)

E-M293 YTree

www.yfull.com

Yes, it is spreading among the Somalis in Kenya and in MX and dagodi