Is treating foreigners in Somalia like this okay ethically and morally?

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

1.2M views · 13K reactions | ”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii | Macalin Heega

”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii.

www.facebook.com

 

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

I understand these people maybe foreigners from Ethiopia and elsewhere and I understand why they maybe getting expelled from the country. But is it necessary to abuse them and mistreat them in such a way.

Tommorow if a Somali is mistreated or abused in the Amhara region or Oromo region of Ethiopia or South Africa or Kenya we will all cry and calaacal about the mistreatment of Somalis. But when miskeen foreigners come to our land to seek refuge or economic opportunity we will treat them in these inhumane.

If Somalis wants to treat others like this, please dont calaacal when we get abused in Libya and treated like slaves. We are the exact same as those people.

 

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

If you look at the comments even ajnabis are shocked at how humans are being treated in this manner. Ceeb.

 

[Abu Hesi]

waraa mohamed ismail, adiga horta af hayeenka ajaanibta maatahay?

 

[Varriris]

1.2M views · 13K reactions | ”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii | Macalin Heega

”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii.

www.facebook.com

No.

It’s silly kids bullying other kids don’t make it more than what it is.

there are very few somalis who reside in amhara/tigray region, as for somalis in Oromo region they live on their OWN land that was incorporated into the oromo region, they are not guests. Despite that they are facing massacres and displacement by violent expansionist oromos.

you’re funny if you think they’d ever allow somalis to squat in their cities, begging, threatening and being a general nuisance to locals, shitting/peeing outside (due to not having access to toilets), building makeshift homes on privately owned land, joining terroristgroups that seek to kill and terrorize locals at alarming rates LOOL

 

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

waraa mohamed ismail, adiga horta af hayeenka ajaanibta maatahay?

Maya, afhahayeenka xaqqa iyo cadaalada baan ahay saaxib.

 

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

No.

It’s silly kids bullying other kids don’t make it more than what it is.

there are very few somalis who reside in amhara/tigray region, as for somalis in Oromo region they live on their OWN land that was incorporated into the oromo region, they are not guests. Despite that they are facing massacres and displacement by violent expansionist oromos.

you’re funny if you think they’d ever allow somalis to squat in their cities, begging, threatening and being a general nuisance to locals, shitting/peeing outside (due to not having access to toilets), build makeshift homes on privately owned land, joining terroristgroups that seek to kill and terrorize locals at alarming rates LOOL

What about Somalis in Kenya, south Africa, uganda, UK , USA , Australia and Canada. Do you support them being treated in this inhumane manner simply because they are foreign.

 

[Varriris]

What about Somalis in Kenya, south Africa, uganda, UK , USA , Australia and Canada. Do you support them being treated in this inhumane manner simply because they are foreign.

If the economic situation in these countries was similar to the one in Somalia, walaal we would have experienced a genocide by now

The somali state is too poor to absorb migrants. Stating that should never be controversial.

 

[Varriris]

What about Somalis in Kenya, south Africa, uganda, UK , USA , Australia and Canada. Do you support them being treated in this inhumane manner simply because they are foreign.

My personal theory is that you have zero concern for humanrights and civility, you are envious of the fact that PL enjoys relative peace and stability. Cuqdad and maseer is clouding your judgement, you cannot convince me that this one video of an ill-mannered child got you heated to this extent, im sorry

 

[therandomone]

As long as they are not overtly taking over, doing any crimes or such. I think it's fine for them to stay especially if they are Muslims.

 

[Kamaaludeen Al Reewin]

If the economic situation in these countries was similar to the one in Somalia, walaal we would have experienced a genocide by now

The somali state is too poor to absorb migrants. Stating that should never be controversial.

My personal theory is that you have zero concern for humanrights and civility, you are envious of the fact that PL enjoys relative peace and stability. Cuqdad and maseer is clouding your judgement, you cannot convince me that this one video of an ill-mannered child got you heated to this extent, im sorry

1.) Like I said earlier, if the Puntland government wants to deport these people, that's their choice. But at the very least do it in a manner that maintains the dignity of the foreigners and the Somali people.

2) This is not a matter of cuqdad and I didnt even mention a specific region in Somalia. Rather my point is anywhere in Somalia things like this shouldn't be cheered on.

 

[DivineMartial]

Man it's just kids being kids. Kids are natural bullies. Bring a video of an adult whipping them then we talk. The Oromo repatriation will continue. Wadankooda haku noqdaan

 

[Rayaale]

Somalis in Amhara region, never heard of that and the ones who live in Oromia region have assimilated into them @Step a side

 

[Riftvalley]

Stop comparing apples and oranges. The horrendous treatment Somalis received in some Arab and African countries in the past has never happened to any foreigners in Somalia. Those countries like Kenya and Ethiopia massacred Somalis who were citizens of those states.

In the late late 19th and early 20th century, Somalis traders in Aden were often cheated by Arabs in Yemen; meanwhile, studies on Somalis show that we conducted business with foreigners on our shores in a fair manner.

The video is wrong but stop comparing Somalis to countries like Ethiopia or Libya ( were ethnic cleansing and displacement is normal).

 

[Shangani]

Cawaans

 

[Removed]

1.2M views · 13K reactions | ”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii | Macalin Heega

”Cidii aan puntland u dhalan maanta xaalkeedu waa sidaan Goobtu waa Garoowe qofkii aan reer puntland ahayn oo lagu dhex arko waa dil Waa arin dhulka Somaaliyeed kucusub Xaqiiqdii.

www.facebook.com

-They should be shipped out
-They should be shipped out with no harassment or beatings as they are largely muslim
-There are few of any such cases so far from what it seems especially from government workers
-There is no persecution of Oromos in Ethiopia and there is no reason for them to be begging in Somalia. If they arent on Tahriib actively send them back.

My personal theory is that you have zero concern for humanrights and civility, you are envious of the fact that PL enjoys relative peace and stability. Cuqdad and maseer is clouding your judgement, you cannot convince me that this one video of an ill-mannered child got you heated to this extent, im sorry

Puntlander lady "Ajnabiga iyo Eelaayda Puntland ha laga saaro"

Seems like Puntland is heading down the same path as Somaliland and wants to kick out Reer kgs.

www.somalispot.com

This thread was a few days ago. More likely origin for concerns.

 

[Yusuf M]

I don't support any foreigners being harmed. But I fully support them being deported especially when they are a major security risk to the country. By the way, a few of them being roughed up ain't nothing and I mean nothing compared to what Oromos and others have done to Somalis.

 

[mudugnapalm]

Please keep this same energy when oromo militias massacre muslim civillians. I live in Garowe and no one is attacking these people, they're just reporting them to the police. A lot of these beggars aren't even muslim, if you ask them to recite surat al fatiha they can't recite it.

 

[ditto]

Man some somalis are beyond retarded why would he film that