Jolani insults the Islamic Republic of Afghanistan !

Donald Trump News GIF by IMPAULSIVE
 
It does come off as bad. But if we're being honest most of Afghanistan is a tribal society. Like only 25% of the pouplation lives in cities. The rest are in rural mountain areas.
 
It does come off as bad. But if we're being honest most of Afghanistan is a tribal society. Like only 25% of the pouplation lives in cities. The rest are in rural mountain areas.
Tribal doesn’t mean rural, it means a kinship based society, Somalia is a tribal society, whether you’re referring to settled city dwellers or nomadic pastoralists.
 

TekNiKo

Loyal To The One True Caliph (Hafidahullah)
VIP
It does come off as bad. But if we're being honest most of Afghanistan is a tribal society. Like only 25% of the pouplation lives in cities. The rest are in rural mountain areas.
Hes clearly panhandling to the West, Afghanistan is implementing sharicada Islaamka. He wont even take jizya from mushrikeen.
 
He already dropped the Islamic Kunya and is going by Ahmed Al Shara now😭
Syria sadly traded Assad for Assad 2 but ""Islamist"". And now Polish Palestine is encroaching on more syrian territory. SO much for the "Rules based order" That the west preaches. When american politicians say America first, it means America is above international law. If there was no UN veto there would be palestinean membership in the UN, food being a human right, etc. Imagine in 200 years in the future, this will be called the second dark age of islam wallahi. 50+ something islamic ""nations"", and non nations like Jordan, Kuwait, United Shaitan Emirates, Qatar, Bahrain, Suugo Arabia, irrelevant nations like Oman, and western lapdogs like egypt and even our homeland Somalia
 

Idilinaa

reduced activity
Tribal doesn’t mean rural, it means a kinship based society, Somalia is a tribal society, whether you’re referring to settled city dwellers or nomadic pastoralists.

Somalia is not a tribal society. We don't have seperate tribes that are disconnected & isolated from eachother and have their own seperate costums traditions and are rural based.

Somalia has family lineages that are loosely connected to urban trade networks.

@Midas is right , i don't think Jolani meant anything denigrating by it, he was accurately describing Afghanistan being a different cultural and geographical society from Syria and so their governing solutions will differ from eachother.

See this explaining how the diversity of Afghanistan they are split into multiple linguistic, ethnic and tribal groupings:


and this explaining it's geography and its challenges that has made Afghanistan largely rural and isolated:


Whereas Syria is society that separated by mainly sectarian religious lines and share the same Arab cultural identity and history. Syria has different challenges from Afghanistan and has to apply it's own governing solutions.
 

Idilinaa

reduced activity
“Family lineages”

You have got to be kidding me
A clan is a family lineage. That's what they are.

A tribe in most definitions are separated rural based ethnicities with seperate traditions, language and costums from eachother.

But watch those clips, i learned a lot more about afghan society by looking in to it.
 
A clan is a family lineage. That's what they are.

A tribe in most definitions are separated rural based ethnicities with seperate traditions, language and costums from eachother.

But watch those clips, i learned a lot more about afghan society by watching that.
What are costums? Customs or Costumes?
 
A clan is a family lineage. That's what they are.

A tribe in most definitions are separated rural based ethnicities with seperate traditions, language and costums from eachother.

But watch those clips, i learned a lot more about afghan society by watching that.
“Tribes are considered to be a political unit formed from an organisation of families (including clans and lineages)”

a clan isn’t something separate to a tribe, it’s a form of tribal kinship.
 

Idilinaa

reduced activity
“Tribes are considered to be a political unit formed from an organisation of families (including clans and lineages)”

a clan isn’t something separate to a tribe, it’s a form of tribal kinship.

Cambridge definition

''a group of people, often of related families, who live together, sharing the same language, culture, and history, especially those who do not live in towns or cities''

Thats what most mean when they use the term ''Tribe''.

What are costums? Customs or Costumes?

Costoms

You know:
''a way of behaving or a belief that has been established for a long time: a local/ancient custom, it is the custom for someone to do something.''

For example did you know that much of Taliban's laws and practices are influenced by mountainous tribal traditions? or a code of norms called Pashtunwali, That is not strictly just Sharia Law?

While the Taliban has roots in an extreme form of Islam, its beliefs and practices are also grounded in the less widely recognized traditional tribal conventions of the Pashtun and it is this customary tribal law that provides the clearest insight into Taliban behavior and ideology regarding gender roles and the position of women.
 
Cambridge definition

''a group of people, often of related families, who live together, sharing the same language, culture, and history, especially those who do not live in towns or cities''

Thats what most mean when they use the term ''Tribe''.



Costoms

You know:
''a way of behaving or a belief that has been established for a long time: a local/ancient custom, it is the custom for someone to do something.''

For example did you know that much of Taliban's laws and practices are influenced by mountainous tribal traditions? or a code of norms called Pashtunwali, That is not strictly just Sharia Law?

Custom, right. I’m confused why you keep purposely spelling it costoms. It’s not even an accepted alternative spelling according to the Cambridge dictionary.
 
Cambridge definition

''a group of people, often of related families, who live together, sharing the same language, culture, and history, especially those who do not live in towns or cities''

Thats what most mean when they use the term ''Tribe''.



Costoms

You know:
''a way of behaving or a belief that has been established for a long time: a local/ancient custom, it is the custom for someone to do something.''

For example did you know that much of Taliban's laws and practices are influenced by mountainous tribal traditions? or a code of norms called Pashtunwali, That is not strictly just Sharia Law?

Yeah it's incredbly different and not remotely comparable to somalia. You have severa diffrent ethnic groups in Afghanistan . Pashtuns are only 40% of Afghanistan. But they're way outnumbered in the cities and urban areas. They have 2 official lanaguges one is pashtun and the other is dari(which is just a name for persian) . Most of the tribal areas are just pashtun . But the urban pouplation is of a compelelty different ethnic orgin and read and write in persian.
 
Top