No one cares what the failed warlord stuck in Kismayo thinks.
The gall. This is the same state that finances al-Shabaab through the illegal charcoal trade. Perhaps they should investigate the environmental degradation their greed has precipitated in Southern Somalia instead of sniping their own government.
The UN literally released several reports about Madoobe and Kenya collaborating with al-Shabaab to ship charcoal and sugar through Kismaayo port:fake news from CBB and Qatar
Nowhere in there does it say JL is financing AS. AS tax over charcoal is similiar to AS tax of produce in central states, far more money, around half of all revenue of AS comes from xamar mainly the port of Xamar a piece of national infrastructure under the guard of the fgs.The UN literally released several reports about Madoobe and Kenya collaborating with al-Shabaab to ship charcoal and sugar through Kismaayo port:
View attachment 199547
Source: S-2016-919, page 42
The KDF's role in exporting charcoal:
View attachment 199549
Source: S-2016-919, page 41
View attachment 199548
Source: S-2016-919, page 43
The KDF stonewalled UN investigators by preventing them leaving a base to assess nearby charcoal stockpiles:
View attachment 199550
Source: S-2017-924, page 48
This was further corroborated by American Professor Ken Menkhaus:
This is undeniable stuff. If Farmaajo did half the things Madoobe has done he would have been lynched. If anyone is interested in reading more about this story instead of running defence for your qabil, check it out here.
Fahad yassin is the AS financier.The gall. This is the same state that finances al-Shabaab through the illegal charcoal trade. Perhaps they should investigate the environmental degradation their greed has precipitated in Southern Somalia instead of sniping their own government.
Fahad yassin is the AS financier.
Read section six of the S-2017-924 report. Al-Shabaab collects rents on charcoal production in the hinterland. The charcoal is then transported to Kismaayo and exported to countries like Bahrain, Kuwait, and the UAE. If Jubaland - read Madoobe - prevented the export of charcoal it would deprive al-Shabaab of $10 million annually:Nowhere in there does it say JL is financing AS.
You are absolutely right but this doesn't detract from what I've said. Extricating al-Shabaab from the capital will be a difficult and prolonged endeavour but Madoobe can easily ban charcoal exports from Kismaayo. He could potentially deprive $10 million from coffers in an instant.far more money, around half of all revenue of AS comes from xamar
Fahad yassin is the AS financier.
Cutting charcoal would also deprive the JL admin of a share of its finances to fight AS and deprive numerous other communities from JL to elsewhere. I dont believe making it banned is fair nor productive no matter whats traded the taxation from AS is inevitable if they control the hinterland.Read section six of the S-2017-924 report. Al-Shabaab collects rents on charcoal production in the hinterland. The charcoal is then transported to Kismaayo and exported to countries like Bahrain, Kuwait, and the UAE. If Jubaland - read Madoobe - prevented the export of charcoal it would deprive al-Shabaab of $10 million annually:
View attachment 199558
Source: S-2017-924, p46
When I say Jubaland finances al-Shabaab this is what I am referring to. Madoobe is allowing charcoal to be shipped from Kismaayo port even though he controls it. It's not like he doesn't know about the UN ban on charcoal production.
You are absolutely right but this doesn't detract from what I've said. Extricating al-Shabaab from the capital will be a difficult and prolonged endeavour but Madoobe can easily ban charcoal exports from Kismaayo. He could potentially deprive $10 million from coffers in an instant.
View attachment 199557
It would be far easier for Farmajo to take control of the ports manifesto and not let it routinely be given to AS so they could accurately tax everything coming in and out of Somalias largest revenue stream.Extricating al-Shabaab from the capital will be a difficult and prolonged endeavour but Madoobe can easily ban charcoal exports from Kismaayo. He could potentially deprive $10 million from coffers in an instant.
To reiterate:Claiming JL is financing AS implies direct finance not them both taxing the same revenue stream. You and other baby kacaanists here have repeatedly made this claim with zero evidence
Absolutely for the reasons I stated above my direct interests as his constituent come before UN “law” which is not in anyway sovereign over us.he still allows charcoal to be exported from a territory under his direct control.
The definition of financing implies direct funding not taxing the same revenue stream by that logic AS is funding JL and Somalia as a whole by allowing goods to pass through their hinterlands.How is this not financing?
In what world does value go down with less supply? And AS profits is clearly not your main goal here you show far more interests in it financing JL then cutting the actual AS revenue stream.If Madoobe banned this trade, the value of charcoal would plummet and so would al-Shabaab's profits.
We went over thisBut by doing nothing, he allows them to collect millions in revenue
Looks real tenable to me. Either respond to the points in the prior post and apply that bizzare reach to Farmajo as a financier or please stop replying im not responding to any more unrelated cuqdad fueled babble.Your position is untenable.
So you admit Madoobe needs the charcoal tax to fund his regime and plunder the environment. UN is watching and UAE shall pay for allowing your exports.Absolutely for the reasons I stated above my direct interests as his constituent come before UN “law” which is not in anyway sovereign over us.
The definition of financing implies direct funding not taxing the same revenue stream by that logic AS is funding JL and Somalia as a whole by allowing goods to pass through their hinterlands.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
In what world does value go down with less supply? And AS profits is clearly not your main goal here you show far more interests in it financing JL then cutting the actual AS revenue stream.
We went over this
Looks real tenable to me. Either respond to the points in the prior post and apply that bizzare reach to Farmajo as a financier or please stop replying im not responding to any more unrelated cuqdad fueled babble.
Life would be easier if you just said “I hate Ogaden Kismayo unuka leh” I actually respected @kickz when he was open in his qabyalad
There's three points I have to address here: 1) the legality of charcoal production in Jubaland, 2) this false equivalence about al-Shabaab's finances, and 3) Jubaland's role in revenue generation for al-Shabaab.Looks real tenable to me. Either respond to the points in the prior post and apply that bizzare reach to Farmajo as a financier or please stop replying im not responding to any more unrelated cuqdad fueled babble.
Please stay on topic. I have no interest getting into a shit flinging contest.Life would be easier if you just said “I hate Ogaden Kismayo unuka leh”
“Wrong” means nothing to me coming from you. I want the Sayid to follow my interests under god not the UNSC. We will never agree on this because I dont want to end revenue streams of innocent Somalis in stead of actually stopping the taxation.Firstly, Jubaland is part of Somalia and Somalia is a part of the UN. This means Jubaland is party to any UN Security Council resolution. This is a fact and non-negotiable. What the Jubaland administration is doing is illegal and wrong.
The Somali government is worse it is not indirect taxation the port is public property why are its documents given to AS routinely!! You claim they are “trying” but I see no evidence to that particularly in regards to the port.Secondly, al-Shabaab's extortion of businesses in Mogadishu is not comparable to their indirect use of Kismayo port.
Producers will always produce should Hirshabelle ban farming to prevent AS taxation better yet lets stop paying the SNA because government workers are giving “tax” money to AS. After all inaction on this will be culpability it must be why we allegedly miss so many payments for the SNAMadoobe knows that al-Shabaab are taxing charcoal producers.
I most definitely wouldnt and dont because its completely unreasonable to expect Farmajo to control taxation in the bush of Hirshabelle as it is completely unreasonable for Sayid Axmed to control the taxation in Middle juba or beyond let alone call it financing AS.His inaction is culpability. If this were any other figure you would rightly call them out, but due to qabil, you defend him.
One there is no providing finances from one to another because their is no transaction between the two parties.Thirdly, to finance means to provide funding for (a person or enterprise). I use this word because it accurately describes the arrangement between al-Shabaab and Jubaland:
Please stay on topic. I have no interest getting into a shit flinging contest.If this were any other figure you would rightly call them out, but due to qabil, you defend him.