Repatriate Somalia

[bobby_hill-Punt]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

 

[mubnub]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

But Isreal had the west helping it and no terrorists

 

[The Oponian Guild]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

Somalia is artificial. it’s not one unified polity. and even then there are Somalis who’ve gone back to their deegans and states and are working in health/business sectors etc

 

[Pastoralist]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

We have nothing on the scale you’re suggesting. It would help Somalia tremendously if the country focused on gaining the skills of those abroad. They did something like that with the EAC conference in which many Somali businessmen looking to invest in Somalia and its regions attended (can’t find my thread on it). Problem is, those are a few affluent Somalis, not middle income Somalis with skills like Israel attracted many of.

 

[bobby_hill-Punt]

But Isreal had the west helping it and no terrorists

Sxb think about it like manifest destiny. When the colonist arrived to the American they had to fight of millions of Native American and they colonized the americas in few decades. These people your afraid of cant even stand against Puntland arm. these people are afraid and US is help Somalis to fight off the terrorist but they want you to do the leg work always nothing comes free in life. We don't take back Somalia or the region we are from the Oroms will take it all. The isreals that to fight off 1 million Palsnestines during the 1920-1950

 

[bobby_hill-Punt]

The west is crashing people get what you can now while the money is good. for instance invest in small factories you would like to ship to Somalia and you can start. I think in 15 years the dollar is not gone be worth shit. Im not stating go back now but have a foot in Somalia also. The rich cadaans are leaving the west. The Americans will be a Slave colony soo. The only thing that stoping these large corporation and government from financial enslaving is the gun laws and those are get chipped away at it each year. If you don't believe me ask yourself what do your truly own in the west?

 

[Sadam96]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

Back then, Israel was more developed than Somalia is today, and they had more money. Plus, Jews weren’t really welcomed anywhere, so Israel took advantage of that to get them to move there.

Are Somalis in any real danger that would make them want to return? And does Somalia even have financial aid to support returning diaspora? If a million Somalis came back, I don’t think the country could handle it. There aren’t enough skilled jobs, so a lot of them would end up unemployed. On top of that, remittances—which make up like 15-20% of Somalia’s economy—would take a huge hit and fucked up since diaspora in the West wouldn't be sending money back anymore.

Somalia doesn’t have a large affluent or middle class, so the priority should be strengthening its blue-collar economy and exports first. That means focusing on farming, fishing, manufacturing, mining, factories, transport, and construction. Some diaspora can return if their skills are needed in these areas. The key is exporting more than they import, which would bring in more money for Somalis to reinvest and grow the economy.

In 15-30 years, with better education producing more skilled workers, Somalia will look very different. By then, there will be a larger middle class and more affluent people, making it more appealing for the diaspora to return and settle permanently—without needing financial aid from the government

 

[bobby_hill-Punt]

Back then, Israel was more developed than Somalia is today, and they had more money. Plus, Jews weren’t really welcomed anywhere, so Israel took advantage of that to get them to move there.

Are Somalis in any real danger that would make them want to return? And does Somalia even have financial aid to support returning diaspora? If a million Somalis came back, I don’t think the country could handle it. There aren’t enough skilled jobs, so a lot of them would end up unemployed. On top of that, remittances—which make up like 15-20% of Somalia’s economy—would take a huge hit and fucked up since diaspora in the West wouldn't be sending money back anymore.

Somalia doesn’t have a large affluent or middle class, so the priority should be strengthening its blue-collar economy and exports first. That means focusing on farming, fishing, manufacturing, mining, factories, transport, and construction. Some diaspora can return if their skills are needed in these areas. The key is exporting more than they import, which would bring in more money for Somalis to reinvest and grow the economy.

In 15-30 years, with better education producing more skilled workers, Somalia will look very different. By then, there will be a larger middle class and more affluent people, making it more appealing for the diaspora to return and settle permanently—without needing financial aid from the government

I have to disagree with the notion that Israel in the 1930s was more developed than Somalia’s large cities today. Somalia’s major cities now have colleges and trade schools that are gradually improving, providing education and technical skills to the population. In contrast, during the 1930s, what is now Israel was primarily focused on relocating Jewish communities from Europe to the Middle East. Infrastructure in Palestine at the time was underdeveloped—paved roads were scarce, whereas Somalia’s major cities today have established road networks, telecommunications, and access to modern technology like cell phones and computers.

That being said, Somalia’s infrastructure still needs significant advancement, especially in areas like transportation, energy, and public services. However, the presence of educational institutions and technology in major cities provides a strong foundation for growth. With strategic investment in infrastructure and governance, Somalia could accelerate its development and create a more sustainable and prosperous future.
In my view, Somalia would not necessarily need to provide financial aid to returning diaspora. Instead, these individuals could establish their own businesses, producing goods that the local population currently cannot manufacture. For example, by investing in small factories, they could create jobs and introduce industries that add value to the economy.

Beyond serving local demand, these factories could also produce goods for export to neighboring countries, diversifying Somalia’s economy beyond its traditional reliance on livestock. This shift would strengthen Somalia’s position in regional trade, reduce import dependence, and create sustainable economic growth. Rather than relying on government support, returning diaspora could play a crucial role in revitalizing industries, fostering innovation, and boosting employment—directly contributing to the country's long-term development.

There aren’t enough skilled jobs, which leaves many people unemployed. If I were to return home without prior experience in factories or B2B businesses, I would have to rely on my current skill set. Having studied computer science with a focus on data and programming, I understand how data is collected, analyzed, and used to drive decision-making. One major challenge in Somalia is immigration management. I could build a business that collaborates with the Somali regional government to collect and analyze immigration data, identifying key entry points and determining where to establish checkpoints. Instead of working with just one city, I could expand my services to multiple regions, creating a nationwide system.

Beyond basic immigration tracking, this system could integrate biometric identification, smart ID cards, and a digital registry to help monitor movements and ensure security while respecting personal freedoms. Additionally, predictive analytics could be used to anticipate migration patterns, allowing for proactive policy-making. By leveraging data-driven solutions, we could improve border security, streamline legal immigration processes, and even support economic planning by understanding population movement trends. These are the kinds of skilled, innovative solutions that regions like Somalia need to address complex challenges effectively.

I believe we need to phase out remittances altogether. While they currently make up around 15-20% of Somalia’s economy, they create a dependency that discourages productivity and economic self-sufficiency. I've heard from many Somalis who have returned home that a significant portion of the population doesn’t actively work, relying instead on house workers—many of whom are Oromo—to handle daily tasks like cleaning, cooking, and childcare. This lifestyle resembles that of the wealthy elite in the West, even though Somalia as a whole is still developing.

The problem is that remittances provide a steady income, reducing the urgency to build roads, improve infrastructure, or engage in meaningful economic activity. If Somalia is to truly develop, people need to move away from reliance on outside financial support and take responsibility for their own progress. Encouraging entrepreneurship, industry, and a strong work ethic is key to breaking this cycle. Instead of waiting for monthly remittances, people should be focusing on creating businesses, building industries, and developing the country’s infrastructure with their own hands.

 

[Sadam96]

I have to disagree with the notion that Israel in the 1930s was more developed than Somalia’s large cities today. Somalia’s major cities now have colleges and trade schools that are gradually improving, providing education and technical skills to the population. In contrast, during the 1930s, what is now Israel was primarily focused on relocating Jewish communities from Europe to the Middle East. Infrastructure in Palestine at the time was underdeveloped—paved roads were scarce, whereas Somalia’s major cities today have established road networks, telecommunications, and access to modern technology like cell phones and computers.

That being said, Somalia’s infrastructure still needs significant advancement, especially in areas like transportation, energy, and public services. However, the presence of educational institutions and technology in major cities provides a strong foundation for growth. With strategic investment in infrastructure and governance, Somalia could accelerate its development and create a more sustainable and prosperous future.
In my view, Somalia would not necessarily need to provide financial aid to returning diaspora. Instead, these individuals could establish their own businesses, producing goods that the local population currently cannot manufacture. For example, by investing in small factories, they could create jobs and introduce industries that add value to the economy.

Beyond serving local demand, these factories could also produce goods for export to neighboring countries, diversifying Somalia’s economy beyond its traditional reliance on livestock. This shift would strengthen Somalia’s position in regional trade, reduce import dependence, and create sustainable economic growth. Rather than relying on government support, returning diaspora could play a crucial role in revitalizing industries, fostering innovation, and boosting employment—directly contributing to the country's long-term development.

There aren’t enough skilled jobs, which leaves many people unemployed. If I were to return home without prior experience in factories or B2B businesses, I would have to rely on my current skill set. Having studied computer science with a focus on data and programming, I understand how data is collected, analyzed, and used to drive decision-making. One major challenge in Somalia is immigration management. I could build a business that collaborates with the Somali regional government to collect and analyze immigration data, identifying key entry points and determining where to establish checkpoints. Instead of working with just one city, I could expand my services to multiple regions, creating a nationwide system.

Beyond basic immigration tracking, this system could integrate biometric identification, smart ID cards, and a digital registry to help monitor movements and ensure security while respecting personal freedoms. Additionally, predictive analytics could be used to anticipate migration patterns, allowing for proactive policy-making. By leveraging data-driven solutions, we could improve border security, streamline legal immigration processes, and even support economic planning by understanding population movement trends. These are the kinds of skilled, innovative solutions that regions like Somalia need to address complex challenges effectively.

I believe we need to phase out remittances altogether. While they currently make up around 15-20% of Somalia’s economy, they create a dependency that discourages productivity and economic self-sufficiency. I've heard from many Somalis who have returned home that a significant portion of the population doesn’t actively work, relying instead on house workers—many of whom are Oromo—to handle daily tasks like cleaning, cooking, and childcare. This lifestyle resembles that of the wealthy elite in the West, even though Somalia as a whole is still developing.

The problem is that remittances provide a steady income, reducing the urgency to build roads, improve infrastructure, or engage in meaningful economic activity. If Somalia is to truly develop, people need to move away from reliance on outside financial support and take responsibility for their own progress. Encouraging entrepreneurship, industry, and a strong work ethic is key to breaking this cycle. Instead of waiting for monthly remittances, people should be focusing on creating businesses, building industries, and developing the country’s infrastructure with their own hands.

Israel was still more developed for its time than Somalia is today. According to the Human Development Index estimated for around 1939, out of 36 countries, Palestinian Jews (irasel) ranked 15th—higher than Turkey, which ranked 35th. The argument about comparing Israel to Somalia’s major cities misses the point. Israel’s major cities were far more developed too, so while Somalia’s cities might be better off than rural Israel was, overall, Israel was still more advanced.

As for remittances, they’re still a key part of Somalia’s economy. But that doesn’t mean we shouldn’t focus on infrastructure. The key is demand—if there are no roads, traffic can’t flow, and that limits growth. At the same time, without money, there’s no demand either, so nothing gets built.

I also think we need to diversify the economy and reduce dependence on remittances.

What Somalia really needs is a strong government and a stable currency that prioritizes the internal economy. Even if there’s little money, the government can print more to invest in blue-collar industries like farming, fishing, manufacturing, mining, factories, transport, and construction. This would create jobs and reduce dependence on remittances while also meeting domestic consumption needs.

I’ve always maintained that printing money only works when it's invested in production that creates goods Somalia needs. For example, if we build farms focused on cotton production, we can then process the cotton in local manufactory to produce clothing. As long as the clothing meets domestic demand, we can sell it in Somali markets without causing hyperinflation. The key is ensuring that the money being printed leads to actual goods and services that people need, rather than just increasing the money supply without production growth.

However, if certain industries can’t start without importing essential tools, we would still need to pay for those in an international currency like the U.S. dollar to have them delivered to Somalia. In that case, printing money wouldn’t work since foreign suppliers won’t accept Somali currency. But once the necessary tools are acquired, money could be printed to pay workers until production kicks off. This way, locals could buy Somali-produced goods instead of imports, keeping more money within the economy. That alone would add value and stimulate blue-collar growth.

Right now, this approach won’t work because Somalia’s government is weak, and there isn’t a strong central bank. Each state having its own currency limits Somalia’s ability to print money and drive economic growth.

At the end of the day, it’s just my idea XD

 

[Aurelian]

I've always wondered why Somalia hasn't called on Somalis to repatriate back to Somalia yet. We have so many members of our diaspora who have developed valuable skills over the past 30 or so years. For instance, Israel actively calls back anyone with ancestral ties to the country, encouraging their return. If Somalia were to initiate a repatriation program, it would likely need to offer incentives to its diaspora.

Israel successfully brought back Jewish populations from Europe and other parts of the world in the 1900s, especially after World War II. They implemented policies such as the Law of Return, which granted automatic citizenship to Jewish immigrants. Additionally, the Israeli government provided incentives like financial aid, housing, and land to help new arrivals settle and integrate. This played a crucial role in strengthening the country economically and demographically.

Somalia could learn a lot from Israel’s approach. By offering incentives such as land, housing, business grants, or tax breaks, the Somali government could encourage its skilled diaspora to return and contribute to national development. A structured repatriation program could help rebuild the country by leveraging the education, experience, and wealth accumulated by Somalis abroad.

What are your thoughts on this idea? Do you think Somalia could successfully implement such a program?

Israel had something to provided for Jews unlike Somalia, who doesn't to provide anything or want to provide, in fact some places in Somalia is very hostile for progress or Somalis qurbojoog.
Look at Somaliland who has many Somalis in UK who have professionals and extremely proud Somalilanders, but almost non tries to go back to Somaliland and build. The same applies to other parts. Maybe Puntlanders are becoming a exception, but the state itself is not different to SL or the southern states.

 

[bobby_hill-Punt]

Israel had something to provided for Jews unlike Somalia, who doesn't to provide anything or want to provide, in fact some places in Somalia is very hostile for progress or Somalis qurbojoog.
Look at Somaliland who has many Somalis in UK who have professionals and extremely proud Somalilanders, but almost non tries to go back to Somaliland and build. The same applies to other parts. Maybe Puntlanders are becoming a exception, but the state itself is not different to SL or the southern states.

Same story as the Jewish people . Now we need a party to spur this along that outside the country that from our own people that request our people to head back. Always look at other communities who to had guide there people back to there lands. Nothing under the sun is new. It's just the same old song you have to catch the rhythm. How long was the Jewish people outside of there homeland? Your just talking about less than 150 years. The Jewish people had to recreate the language from scratch and had to teach it to a population that was divided amongst different countries. I don't understand why people are making this something new

 

[bobby_hill-Punt]

I'm not stating to head back now, but just understand no foreigner will build your homeland for you. This is our assignment