He’s not even arguing about industry , he is saying they lack ways to store food. I've actually shown that in many parts of the country they have set up storage and processing facilities, so it's an outdated reality.
But let’s actually take what @Thegoodshepherd said about “milk going to waste” and look at the incomes of people before and after introducing cooling/storage equipment. It completely kills the “$695 per capita” nonsense he keeps clinging to.
Take Sahra a rural mother from an area near Mogadishu, she sells camel and cow milk to support her family. Previously losing much of it to spoilage, her income rose from $7 to $20 a day after receiving training and basic cooling equipment from a Somali association, allowing her to sell fresher milk and better support her children.
Mind you this is from 2017:
Key points :
- The lowest wages that can be found in Somalia average at 7$ a day or 215$ a month or 2600$ a year, very far from the official number of 695$ a year.
- Even with 7$ a day this single mother could feed her 8 children and send them to school.
- Some micro-businesses like these can easily make 20$ a day or 620$ a month or 7450$ a year, indicating a stronger consumerism.
View attachment 373719![]()
Milking the Benefits for Small-Scale Women Milk Retailers in Somalia - SATG | Somali Agriculture Technical Group
Sahra Mohamed lives in Daynile district three miles from Mogadishu, the capital of Somalia, which is located in the Horn of Africa. The country is ravaged by a 25-year civil war. Government institutions/agencies hardly function.satg.org
View attachment 373720
Another similar example. Milk sellers were able to triple their gains from $500-$700 per month to $3200 per month just by being given cool equipment and joining a business cooperative.
View attachment 373721![]()
Milk Cooperative — SomReP
Ceelsame milk cooperative is one of the cooperatives established and supported by World Vision under DFAT Project. Ceelsame consists of 30 members who are mainly women and it is operational in Ceel-same village under Odweyne District.www.somrep.org
And again, these are rural underprivileged women, not an “urban elite.” Even without cooling/storage they were already making far more than the official GDP per capita claims.
It also extends to Fishing as well, which i am sure people are completely unaware of how much the fishing industry has grown in recent decade from 2013-2018 it grew by 300% : Millions are employed directly or indirectly through it because fishermen sell it to stores, shops, restaurants , processors, exporter etc
From the above the report from 2019 it showed the average fisherman earned 470 dollars a month in 2018 and now they on average earn 15k$ to 20k$ a year from catches made on their small fishing boats
See this:
View attachment 373722
We have collected many such examples across sectors etc. That i will organize into post InshaAllah. This is what i was talking about before they don't look at direct income statements or base it from a consumer price index to measure real income per capita.
There is no way these examples can earn 1000-6000 USD a month with weak or poor consumer market economy as people like to claim.
Also @Midas @Barkhadle1520 another thing i want to point out is how significant the wage growth displayed above has been.
For comparison take what this economist points out about China for example, she points to how China has a deficit in demand because of low wage growth, scaring effects of pandemic(Export dependency hit them hard because other countries could bounce back by relying on internal mechanisms) and the real estate crash.
She also says almost a billion people in China make less than 300$ a month and that only 48% of Chinese is employed in the service sector compared to 80% in advanced economies. 22% of Chinese are employed in agriculture and 28%-32% industrial.
This China example proves that being “industrial” doesn’t automatically mean higher wages or broad wealth. Almost a billion Chinese still earn under $300/month despite all their factories. This is what @Dagdag /Hilmaam positing in the Ethiopian Garment Factory thread. That factories will lift Ethiopians out of poverty.
But i disagreed and is still proven right. Where wages are high in China isn’t in the factory belts but in the service and finance heavy coastal provinces (Hong Kong, Macao, Shanghai, Shenzhen). These places are globally integrated through trade, finance, and services and that’s what drives incomes up.
Those places actually earn on par with Japan and Korea or on part with even richer nations like Singapore. Particularly Honk Kong and Macao (50K and 76K per capita)

List of top Chinese cities by GDP per capita - Wikipedia
This actually shows the real key to wealth and wage growth is it’s domestic market expansion and the service sector that drive higher incomes. Domestic demand matters just as much , if not more than exports and industrial output.
Somalia’s trajectory is much closer to this service-driven path than the traditional agricultural/industrial one. I’ve already shown how wage growth in Somali sectors (teaching, medicine, fisheries, retail, agriculture, telecom, transport etc.) far surpasses the “$695 GDP per capita” narrative. These gains have come from value chain expansion, financialization, and stronger market inclusion.
@Idilinaa I think you guys might like this video. T The guys talks about rhe challenges india faces and that part of what led him to understand india's situation was that the dominance of IT in the service sector was based on foreign companies using india's labor and not actual Indian growth since there was no domestic market for these It services.
Very interesting, it helps me understand a few things.
It’s almost the opposite trajectory of Somalia. We’re already at around 56% service sector employment, but unlike India, the push here comes from domestic demand rather than foreign demand. Our fintech and telecom sectors unlike India’s IT sector are built around serving Somalis directly, reaching and benefiting the general population.
This is why the general Indian population remain poor and don't reap the benefit from the IT industry and why it's IT industry isn't advanced or very innovative.
Since this is based on 2022, i really wonder that the distribution looks like in 2025.
Last edited: