Arab Slavers or White America Slavers?

[Juke]

I doubt your even somali

I'm more Somali than you. That doesn't mean I have to be delusional and go Madow WE WUZ KANGZ style. Beenta naga daaf.

 

[Ace the shank]

I'm more Somali than you. That doesn't mean I have to be delusional and go Madow WE WUZ KANGZ style. Beenta naga daaf.

Haye do your have proof to your bs claims drop your sources

 

[Juke]

Haye do your have proof to your bs claims drop your sources

Sure give me a sec

https://books.google.com/books?id=t...KnNygPu5oKgAQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

https://books.google.com/books?id=H...ry_r&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=walashma&f=false

The Walashma dynasty came from inland Ethiopia in the former emirate of Showa (that was ruled by the Makhuzmi dynasty) they were of argobba-harari stock (harari are an offshoot of argobba) and they did the typical horn of african muslim thing to do and claim descent from the prophet's family.

 

[Farabuuto]

Administration of Zeila was under the Ifat and Adal Sultanates (ancestors of modern Hararis) then the Ottoman Empire (Turks) for a near millennium before the British conquered it. You don't see Hararis and Anatiolians bragging about selling those slaves.

You're correct but it won't be long until they mass report you for 'anti Somali' comments lol be more lowkey

 

[Juke]

You're correct but it won't be long until they mass report you for 'anti Somali' comments lol be more lowkey

Hey the Hararis fought to join Somalia until the christian Habeshas nearly genocided them

 

[Farabuuto]

Sure give me a sec

https://books.google.com/books?id=t...KnNygPu5oKgAQ&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q&f=false

https://books.google.com/books?id=H...ry_r&redir_esc=y#v=onepage&q=walashma&f=false

The Walashma dynasty came from inland Ethiopia in the former emirate of Showa (that was ruled by the Makhuzmi dynasty) they were of argobba-harari stock (harari are an offshoot of argobba) and they did the typical horn of african muslim thing to do and claim descent from the prophet's family.

Aren't Hararis descendants of Harlas?

 

[Ace the shank]

@CaliTedesse @SuleymanPitt look at this

 

[Juke]

Aren't Hararis descendants of Harlas?

That's their old name

 

[CaliTedesse]

Haye do your have proof to your bs claims drop your sources

That's a weak source, the author is assuming that the dynasty was Harari based on one person claiming descent from Yusuf Al Kawnayn. We can find multiple people that claim descent from him or other noble figures today. He could have also been absorbed by Hararis. Many Somalis or Oromos got absorbed into the wall.

 

[Ace the shank]

That's a weak source, the author is assuming that the dynasty was Harari based on one person claiming descent from Yusuf Al Kawnayn. We can find multiple people that claim descent from him or other noble figures today. He could have also been absorbed by Hararis. Many Somalis or Oromos got absorbed into the wall.

thats what I have been saying the whole time but I let slide and let him have his little momment

 

[Juke]

That's a weak source, the author is assuming that the dynasty was Harari based on one person claiming descent from Yusuf Al Kawnayn. We can find multiple people that claim descent from him or other noble figures today. He could have also been absorbed by Hararis. Many Somalis or Oromos got absorbed into the wall.

It's 3 separate sources you can throw this link in as well and make it four

Where's the source Yusuf Al-Kawneyn was Dir or an ethnic Somali?

 

[Ace the shank]

It's 3 separate sources you can throw this link in as well and make it four

Where's the source Yusuf Al-Kawneyn was Dir or an ethnic Somali?

is the guy on your source somali?

 

[Juke]

is the guy on your source somali?

Which particular source, I proved 4?

You have provided none.

The PDF was a Somali.

 

[CaliTedesse]

It's 3 separate sources you can throw this link in as well and make it four

Where's the source Yusuf Al-Kawneyn was Dir or an ethnic Somali?

There is no consesus reached by scholars that they wer Argobba, but they do agree the the Walashma was a local dynasty. Your sources mention they boast an Arab descent. All Somalis did.

 

[Xasusi]

@CaliTedesse @SuleymanPitt look at this

Don't want to read all that shit. Give me a rundown.

 

[Ace the shank]

t

Which particular source, I proved 4?

You have provided none.

The PDF was a Somali.

the mohamed Abdullahi rirash is he even somali

 

[Juke]

There is no consesus reached by scholars that they wer Argobba, but they do agree the the Walashma was a local dynasty. Your sources mention they boast an Arab descent. All Somalis did.

Lol I literally said their Arab claim was bogus and thats what all HOA muslims claim.

The other guy said they claimed their forefather was Dir. Poor guy is delusional.

Scholars agree the ruling dynasties were Ethio-Semite Muslims originally from the interior.

 

[Juke]

t

the mohamed Abdullahi rirash is he even somali

Yeah, he's a Somali.

 

[Ace the shank]

Lol I literally said their Arab claim was bogus and thats what all HOA muslims claim.

The other guy said they claimed their forefather was Dir. Poor guy is delusional.

Scholars agree the ruling dynasties were Ethio-Semite Muslims originally from the interior.

I never said their forefather was dir don't put words in my mouth I said the walshama was a dynasty of dir tribe

 

[Juke]

I never said their forefather was dir don't put words in my mouth I said the walshama was a dynasty of dir tribe

That's literally the same thing, are you okay my guy?