Very Interesting I was expecting him to get more somali but he only has 5% what do you geneticists and historians of the forum think of his results? @Step a side @The alchemist @DivineMartial @Idilinaa
Baraawe DNA Test Results
- Thread starter Aseer
- Start date
Very Interesting I was expecting him to get more somali but he only has 5% what do you geneticists and historians of the forum think of his results? @Step a side @The alchemist @DivineMartial @Idilinaa
Step a side
VIP
All his Somali ancestry is hidden in the Ethiopian and that’s because of the excess Arabian he has compared to the average Somali. It skews up the results.
His results matches what we know about the Banaadir coast which is local Somalis mixed with Arab & Indian merchants mixed with Bantu slaves. I can tell his Arab ancestry is Omani because of the extra Persian although this could be due to his central Asian ancestry.
Last edited:
Oh thats because theres not much data on benadiris that the data turned out this way, makes sense but the comments say otherwise pushing narratives that they built the cities and whatnot also is the portugese ancestry thing a myth or is it in select cadcads only?
Step a side
VIP
He's using a bad testing kit. I would guess he would get more Indian and Somali on a proper testing kit. A lot of the Arab ancestry would probably end up being Persian or some other Iranian group from the borderlands between South Asia and Persia. Reer Baraawe is quite different from the CadCad up north genetically and comes from a different migrational pool. I would argue the Arabian admixture was pre-mixed, as most Indians come from an Islamified group of South Asians long before they migrated to Somalia.
Linguistically, many of them speak a form of Swahili aswell as Somali. The only other Somali groups that speak non-Somali dialects are the Bantu-Somalis, which makes sense given their fractured ancestry. Bantu might be their single largest ethnic component, and this admixture occurred much more recently.
Interesting to contrast them with the CadCads in Mogadishu, who on average score well into the 50% range, with the median closer to 70% for most. To hypothesize, this might indicate that the Baraawe group in the city occupied a lower social status. This theory could be reinforced by their association with textile work, a craft they are still known for today. Given how Somali culture traditionally views craftsmanship, it is likely they predominantly married into surrounding freed Bantu populations and gradually adopted their language over time creating Chimini.
Linguistically, many of them speak a form of Swahili aswell as Somali. The only other Somali groups that speak non-Somali dialects are the Bantu-Somalis, which makes sense given their fractured ancestry. Bantu might be their single largest ethnic component, and this admixture occurred much more recently.
Interesting to contrast them with the CadCads in Mogadishu, who on average score well into the 50% range, with the median closer to 70% for most. To hypothesize, this might indicate that the Baraawe group in the city occupied a lower social status. This theory could be reinforced by their association with textile work, a craft they are still known for today. Given how Somali culture traditionally views craftsmanship, it is likely they predominantly married into surrounding freed Bantu populations and gradually adopted their language over time creating Chimini.
Step a side
VIP
Since when do Persians or Indian Muslims score Arab ancestry at a rate of 30%? Persians have nothing in common with Arabs. Their Natufian related ancestry is roughly 7%~. All his Arabian is actually Arab and the bit of Egyptian he gets further proves it.
Dont all cadcads speak chimini or is it only exclusive to some subsections of cadcad? Also do they have any correlation with the swahillis down in mombassa, dar es salam etc.?
Can you explain the arabic graves in xamar? Are they tied to the cadcads?
Step a side
VIP
Only reer Baraawe speak chimini.
That is more of a conjecture based on my assumption that the testing kit is flawed. There is genetic overlap between Arabs and Persians when it comes to shared ancestry from Anatolian Neolithic farmers and Iranian Neolithic farmers. Combined with some historical mixing during the Persian control of the Levant and later the Arabic control of the Levant and Persia, I suspect that these tests flag broad trends rather than finer details. Case in point, the little Somali and the overrepresentation of Ethiopia & Eritrea show flagging mistakes in the test kit/company.
Their database might be limited, or the genome regions they test might be incredibly narrow.
I am assuming this because, in the early days of genetic testing, the results for Somalis used to be incredibly inconsistent compared to what we see today.
I'll walk back using the word "A lot", I do however believe the Arabic admixture is overreprestented and a better result would show higher amounts of Indian and some persian results for this man.
Only the Reer Baraawe, and aside from both speaking Swahili in Mombasa and Dar es Salam, I would say it's saver to assume that it came from more local swahili speaking bantus, possible (freed) slaves in the Jubba valley.
Step a side
VIP
I do agree that these companies often time assign the wrong ethnicities but I don’t see how Arabs and Persians or Indians are related in any meaningful way. Somalis being assigned Ethiopian is understandable because of the shared ancestry. They both similar in admixture but just slight differences in proportions. Can’t say the same for Arabs and Persians/Indians.
The Anatolian on the spreadsheet above is way too high for Arabs (Saudis & Yemeni). The Anatolian is eating up the Natufian which is really small. Anatolian should be ~15 and Natufian should be 65%~ for Arabs. Persians on the other hand only have max 7% Natufian which is the ancestry that makes up 2/3 of the Arab total genome. I also believe they have plenty of Arab samples on their database by now.
Jungle
VIP
They have a little enclave in my borough. Grown men say they are from somalia yet speak this gibberish which sounds like swahili but isn't. This is why they stick together. They've pretty much kept the same practises from baraawe where men go out in the morning to get shopping for the day meat, veg etc to keep their girls indoors..
Very odd people and different to any other cadcads I've come across
