Hmmm, since you mentioned Dir dhaba you could be Dir. T is very common with the Dir tribes from that region near Djibouti and Dirdhaba. I assume you are young and don’t have the means to spend 149 dollars? The only way we can be sure is for you to take the Yfull.
Yea he is. Kaariye, Gidir, Sixawle and Wa-Adari (Murusade)
Yes but the name Gedir does sound a Dir sub clan, we don't know the original Karanle unless all sub clans get tested.
If the kid of his fathers brother is T he’s T aswell. There’s really no need to do a generic test but a yfull test would be useful
Nah Gidir is Karanle. It’s like saying Warsengeli Darood is Warsengeli Abgaal because they sound the same.
Yes I am aware brother. I want to know if he will be getting the same T as the Dir from that region. This is what I want to know.
This is what I need to find out. The common denominator among us all. Due to the complex multi ethnic nature of the region we will have Karanle with different types of lineages. There was a Gugundhabe with Ydna L from Galbeed on this forum. The area seems to have underwent a major transformation since the invasion of the Menelik and Lig Yasu. Many people from Harar run toward Baabili for safety because of Christian persecution.
So far on Yfull most members I believe are from Gadbursi and other Dir and Isaaq clans. If he happens to be on the same tree as the Dir-Isaaq clans then he is definitely a Dir assimilated into Karanle. For just 149 dollars we can find out.
Yh I’m young + I’m saving money for new laptop for school work because I can’t be ask going to the library
MashaAllah. Focus on your studies.
Interesting. I remember reading about a karanle in djibouti that got the t haplogroup and i remember coming across this post about about a karanle with the t haplogroup.
Yeah that’ll be great to have. What about studies or 23andme results. I haven’t come across any non isaaq/dir on mine
That study happend to have been undertaken by a scientict in Djibouti. The sample was labelled as “Hawiye”. No one knows what type of Hawiye it is as many Hawiye went there as refugees during the civil war. This study was made back in the early 2010s.
I need to ask niggaibn and @CulturedKay.
Thanks for the info. Much appreciated. It seems I need to continue with my quest to find the common denominator among us. It need to focus on the other Karanle as Murusade seem to be all getting the same E as mine. I hope any karanle readjng this thread to get tested with Nebula deep whole genome sequencing or join this genetic forum for more information https://anthrogenica.com/showthread.php?11485-Somalis-and-E-Y17859/page165
No. They are Habar Ceyno who are Foolculus. Why?
This is what baffles me. The T in those regions is so common in only Isaaq/Dir that I can’t help but wonder if our brother Niggaibn is Dir in origin.
