if you had to pick between a rich secular governed somalia or a poor sharia governed somalia which would you pick?

[Giftxo]

Aren't even that religious somalis are the most religious people your delusional.

Let me rephrase it: “They don’t know that much about Islam”. They “think” that they know a lot about Islam but they really don’t. A lot of things that are considered to be normal in Somali culture is considered to be a sin in Islam.

 

[Marsh]

Let me rephrase it: “They don’t know that much about Islam”. They “think” that they know a lot about Islam but they really don’t. A lot of things that are considered to be normal in Somali culture is considered to be a sin in Islam.

You have no clue what your talking about. All people sin sure but somalis are the most religious group their is. I agree with you about secularism being better than sharia though.

 

[Ras]

Now way this is going to work if Somalia had to be one or the other.

We should just let each region decide for itself.

The richest and most developed place wins all after 20 years.

 

[The alchemist]

From within it will be easy to manage since there is an constitution that dictates how to share power.
We don’t have to become western to succeed, we can upgrade the xeer laws for the rural communities, shariah for the urban communities and secular in regards to foreign policy etc.

Xeer, kkk. Get out of here with that pastoralist shit.

But seriously: very unrealistic as the whole system would implode. There is no empirical evidence or even an applicable state-building theory that could convince a sane person of this nonsense. Complicated systems in the 3rd world always get built on unstable foundations, and the people that would run such systems are not qualified; you need well-functioning intuitions that bureaucratically operates the synergy for checks and balances, we don't have the human capital for it.

 

[Leeban]

Islam is what made Somalia a terrorist haven and we should controll Islam's hardline influence in the country, religion is too backward for 2020 and we should arrest anyone who promotes these 13 century pagan religion, we should also need to stop wasting money building mosques and turn the exiting ones into shelters for the homeless people.

Democracy made Somalia a weak unstable government

 

[mr steal your naag]

Islam is what made Somalia a terrorist haven and we should controll Islam's hardline influence in the country, religion is too backward for 2020 and we should arrest anyone who promotes these 13 century pagan religion, we should also need to stop wasting money building mosques and turn the exiting ones into shelters for the homeless people.

So religion is to backward for you but being a qabilist in 2021 is the most normal thing?

 

[Vanessa]

If Somalia was rich and secular. The women have to share bathroom with men aka trans women.