Madhibaan

[The Macrobian]

Do the Madhibaan speak af may may and are they part of raxanweyn? what is the lineage of these othere somali qabiils like the ones descnended from Sab

 

[wonyluvr]

Madhibaan are not rx. A lot of Madibhaan are actually gorgaate hawiye.

 

[The Macrobian]

Madhibaan are not rx. A lot of Madibhaan are actually gorgaate hawiye.

Hw can they be a part of a different qabiil?

 

[wonyluvr]

Hw can they be a part of a different qabiil?

@Step a side help

 

[Step a side]

Hw can they be a part of a different qabiil?

This question doesn’t make sense. Madhibaan are Hawiye from the line of Gurgaarte.

 

[The Macrobian]

I thought madhibaan are a seperate qabil and part of the qabiils descended by Sab not Samaale

 

[Step a side]

I thought madhibaan are a seperate qabil and part of the qabiils descended by Sab not Samaale

You learn new things everyday

 

[The Macrobian]

You learn new things everyday

How are they hawiye if they have different haplogroup and are agriculltural blacksmiths? Dont they speak different dialect aswell?

 

[wonyluvr]

How are they hawiye if they have different haplogroup and are agriculltural blacksmiths? Dont they speak different dialect aswell?

Madhibaan live everywhere they lived in Mogadishu with other hawiye clans like Abgaal and Mursade historically they are in Puntland too SL Galbeed and so on they are litterally everywhere.Also a lot of them are E-V32

 

[Step a side]

How are they hawiye if they have different haplogroup and are agriculltural blacksmiths? Dont they speak different dialect aswell?

They carry E-Y515840 with Murusade and Hiiraab. Dialect is not an issue. You have Hawiye deep in Ethiopia

 

[The Macrobian]

They carry E-Y515840 with Murusade and Hiiraab. Dialect is not an issue. You have Hawiye deep in Ethiopia

Do madhibaan speak af-maymay

 

[wonyluvr]

Do madhibaan speak af-maymay

If said clan live and bakool and bay then yes.All clans who have lived in the area historically can speak Af Mai Mai

 

[The Macrobian]

Madhibaan live everywhere they lived in Mogadishu with other hawiye clans like Abgaal and Mursade historically they are in Puntland too SL Galbeed and so on they are litterally everywhere.Also a lot of them are E-V32

I think I'm in love.

 

[The Macrobian]

They carry E-Y515840 with Murusade and Hiiraab. Dialect is not an issue. You have Hawiye deep in Ethiopia

Are there other Clans that are haplogroup J?

 

[Step a side]

Are there other Clans that are haplogroup J?

Some of the Madhibaan carry J1 while others are E-V32

 

[The alchemist]

Sab is used for Gaboye (Madhibaan, Tumaal, and Yibir) - which is likely less of a proper clan name rather than a collective signifier of lower castes that deal with artisanal work.

Digil and Mirifle belong to a separate classification:

Not the same Sab.

 

[The Macrobian]

Sab is used for Gaboye (Madhibaan, Tumaal, and Yibir) - which is likely less of a proper clan name rather than a collective signifier of lower castes that deal with artisanal work.

Digil and Mirifle belong to a separate classification:
View attachment 343623

Not the same Sab.

I see

 

[Bundasliga]

Madhibaan are not rx. A lot of Madibhaan are actually gorgaate hawiye.

Now they are hawiye ?!

Wallahi qabil is pretty much support science & fake

 

[Step a side]

Now they are hawiye ?!

Wallahi qabil is pretty much support science & fake

When have they not been Hawiye? These gen Z are hilarious

 

[wonyluvr]

Now they are hawiye ?!

Wallahi qabil is pretty much support science & fake

They’ve always been hawiye everyone has known them as a gorgaate clan