Meca

[a1shire]

Dan Gibson has been debunked by everyone .

This short but elucidating paper by a Christian scholar, in refutation of Dan Gibson is quite informative and handy for Muslims engaging with Christians like @Lord on this topic

https://1islam.files.wordpress.com/2018/10/is_petra_islams_true_birthplace.pdf

 

[Timo Jareer and proud]

@Timo Madow and proud seems that you know quite abit about this but sadly the link on youtube does not work. Your thoughts?

The existence of the zamzam well in Mecca disproves any possible theory that the original location of Mecca was Petra.

 

[Lord]

The existence of the zamzam well in Mecca disproves any possible theory that the original location of Mecca was Petra.

Is there any sheikh that talks about this. Is really hard to find any of them. Please Send me links

 

[gbrlax3]

islamqa is a good website that answers your worries

Is there any sheikh that talks about this. Is really hard to find any of them. Please Send me links

 

[Karim]

Wow!! Some selfish bastard who wants to sell a book claims moronic logic that says 'Petra is the real Mecca' and the weak fainthearted souls fall for his trap without remembering Allah and his prophet.

If Petra is Mecca then why Allah swt narrated plenty of stories about Abraham and how he built the Kaaba?!

Are you saying that Allah and his prophet deceived us? Told us lies about the actual location of Mecca?!

@Lord you need to repent ASAP. This is not a good look for you.

 

[Lord]

Im. Ge

Wow!! Some selfish bastard who wants to sell a book claims moronic logic that says 'Petra is the real Mecca' and the weak fainthearted souls fall for his trap without remembering Allah and his prophet.

If Petra is Mecca then why Allah swt narrated plenty of stories about Abraham and how he built the Kaaba?!

Are you saying that Allah and his prophet deceived us? Told us lies about the actual location of Mecca?!

@Lord you need to repent ASAP. This is not a good look for you.

THATS not what i think. I dont think Allahs messenger would be capable of this but my worries lie with the calipha who ruler after the prophet. There are evidence that show burning of books. I think its very clear that there are wholes in the narative and it should be corrected if its indeed True.
Its seems weird to me that every established scholar is avoiding this topic or they dont have any clue about it.

 

[Karim]

Im. Ge

THATS not what i think. I dont think Allahs messenger would be capable of this but my worries lie with the calipha who ruler after the prophet. There are evidence that show burning of books. I think its very clear that there are wholes in the narative and it should be corrected if its indeed True.
Its seems weird to me that every established scholar is avoiding this topic or they dont have any clue about it.

So you're saying the Caliphs deceived the Ummah by telling us lies about the location of Mecca?!! You're INSANE.


BRING FORTH ONE SCHOLAR WHO DOUBTS THE LOCATION OF MECCA.

 

[Lord]

So you're saying the Caliphs deceived the Ummah by telling us lies about the location of Mecca?!! You're INSANE.


BRING FORTH ONE SCHOLAR WHO DOUBTS THE LOCATION OF MECCA.

Clearly muslim scholar wont go any where near this which i find disapointing. But i really suggest you look into this. I have looked responses from both sides and now im even less sure because i cant confirm this myself.

 

[المهندس]

Clearly muslim scholar wont go any where near this which i find disapointing. But i really suggest you look into this. I have looked responses from both sides and now im even less sure because i cant confirm this myself.

its in the quran man, is that not sufficient evidence for you

 

[a1shire]

there are wholes in the narative

Loool

 

[Lord]

its in the quran man, is that not sufficient evidence for you

Im am folowing the quranic and hadith description of meca

 

[Lord]

Loool

Sadly true

 

[The Honored one]

No Makkah is mentioned in the quran