MJ,MX and DH loose positions on SFG

[Abaq]

Kismaayo is actually doing relatively well given its development only started in 2012 and it has been blockaded for much of that time since. Interesting stuff.

Locally grown food is also very cheap in Kismayo thanks to the Jubba valley produce, even the poor can afford a decent meal, waa miskiin koris. I also like that most people rely on a small business rather than a salary, we need to keep promoting this and the free market

 

[Rationale]

To continue,


Access to bank account and mobile bank account is higher in Mogadishu, Baidoa, north west than in north east.

View attachment 243204


Mogadishu and north west households managed to save more money than north east

View attachment 243205


Employment opportunities are better in Mogadishu and Kismayo than north east.

View attachment 243206


North-west and Biadoa are safer than north-east.


View attachment 243208




@Thegoodshepherd makes out Puntland to be some sort of isolated anomaly in Somalia. The way he speaks about north-east like its piece of jannah. Wake up your shit stinks too.

Selective presentations of the data. You intentionally left out these:

Kismayo has lower poverty rate than Bosasso
View attachment 243186


Mogadishu, Kismayo, north west (Hargeisa) and even IDPs have better access to improved sanitation than north east (Bosasso)



View attachment 243187



Central (Dhusamareeb) & north west (Hargeisa) have higher ownership rate than north east.

View attachment 243188


View attachment 243190

Mogadishu has the biggest proportion of the labor force as a percentage of population (not to mention Mogadishu's market dwarfs Bosasso or any city in the north-east. Perception of employment is also better than north-east. North west is safer than north east , rural areas in South west (Konfur Galbeed- Baidoa) is safer than rural areas in North east.



View attachment 243191

Poverty is higher in North east than Kismayo, hunger is higher in North east than north west.

View attachment 243192

Access to piped water is higher in Mogadishu than north-east.


View attachment 243193


Primary school enrollment is higher in Mogadishu and north-west than north-east



View attachment 243195

Literacy rate is higher in Mogadishu than north-east.

View attachment 243196

Satisfaction of health service quality is higher in Mogadishu than north-east


View attachment 243198

- Access to market in Mogadishu, north-west and central are better than north-east.
-Access to public transport is better in Mogadishu, Baidao, central than north-east. Even IDPs have better access to public transport than north-east.
-Mogadishu, Baidaoa and north-west have better access to internet than north-east.

Even the carefully selected data he posted were bit embarrassing since the difference was barely marginal. Considering 20 years headstart.

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

To continue,


Access to bank account and mobile bank account is higher in Mogadishu, Baidoa, north west than in north east.

View attachment 243204


Mogadishu and north west households managed to save more money than north east

View attachment 243205


Employment opportunities are better in Mogadishu and Kismayo than north east.

View attachment 243206


North-west and Biadoa are safer than north-east.


View attachment 243208




@Thegoodshepherd makes out Puntland to be some sort of isolated anomaly in Somalia. The way he speaks about north-east like its piece of jannah. Wake up your shit stinks too.

What was my argument? Garowe and Qardho are better off than Hargeisa and Mogadishu.

If North East urban is doing better than Mogadishu and Hargeisa on most of these metrics while including Galkayo and Bosaso, then Garowe and Qardho on their own would be even more better off.

All this data only bolsters my argument.

 

[Rationale]

These are the most important charts to keep an eye on and they are solid indicators of potential economic growth as they give a good picture to the businesses and investors.

Xamar has combination of the most important factors.

-High literacy rate
-Easy access to health care
-Almost universal access to electricity.
-Greate sanitation
-Easy access to markets.
-Solid waste management
-Best chance to find a job
-Healthy economy

These are the indicators that tell the quality of live. Only field Xamar was lacking behind was safety and iA when that happens. Only Allah knows where the city will be.


I have no doubt right now based on these charts Xamar has the best quality of live in Somalia. That is just a fact.

 

[Rationale]

What was my argument? Garowe and Qardho are better off than Hargeisa and Mogadishu.

If North East urban is doing better than Mogadishu and Hargeisa on most of these metrics while including Galkayo and Bosaso, then Garowe and Qardho on their own would be even more better off.

All this data only bolsters my argument.

You provided no specific data for Garowe or Qardho. These charts just showed NE urban not Garowe or Qardho. Nor was Hargeysa even singled out it was just lumped into NW urban.

 

[Cumar Cowl]

To continue,


Access to bank account and mobile bank account is higher in Mogadishu, Baidoa, north west than in north east.

View attachment 243204


Mogadishu and north west households managed to save more money than north east

View attachment 243205


Employment opportunities are better in Mogadishu and Kismayo than north east.

View attachment 243206


North-west and Biadoa are safer than north-east.


View attachment 243208




@Thegoodshepherd makes out Puntland to be some sort of isolated anomaly in Somalia. The way he speaks about north-east like its piece of jannah. Wake up your shit stinks too.

Puntland beats every federal member state in overall metrics. Mogadishu is the capital with all the international aid so I won't debate that. JL controls less than 10% of it territory with major infrastructure issues. Southwest is really only Badioa and few other cities, much of the hinterland are under AS. Hirshabelle is non existent admin tbh and Galmudug is not comparable to PL.

 

[ciyaalka xaafada100]

40% of Hargeisa is Madhibaan. Muqdisho has Hawiye,Rahaweyne,Darood, Dir and all Somalis living there. Even if Hawiye politically claim it they only account for over 60% and they divide into subclans

There is no daarood city where hawiye can live and do business freely with out being deported.

 

[Cumar Cowl]

There is no daarood city where hawiye can live and do business freely with out being deported.

They live and do business in Bosaso. You clearly don't know the Salebaans/Ceyrs and Xawaadles that live there.

 

[Cumar Cowl]

View attachment 243273
View attachment 243274
View attachment 243275
View attachment 243277
View attachment 243278
These are the most important charts to keep an eye on and they are solid indicators of potential economic growth as they give a good picture to the businesses and investors.

Xamar has combination of the most important factors.

-High literacy rate
-Easy access to health care
-Almost universal access to electricity.
-Greate sanitation
-Easy access to markets.
-Solid waste management
-Best chance to find a job
-Healthy economy

These are the indicators that tell the quality of live. Only field Xamar was lacking behind was safety and iA when that happens. Only Allah knows where the city will be.


I have no doubt right now based on these charts Xamar has the best quality of live in Somalia. That is just a fact.

Somalia invested in Xamar from 1960 to 1990 The amount of urban planning that went in there is crazy. 80% of governemnt building and facilieties were in banadir, Jowhar and Afgoye. Garowe was a tuulo before 2004 but I've made it into a magaalo something you haven't been able to with any other city.