Then why do you call someone a Gaal if they don't find them credible?Nobody treats them like prophets and Nobody said they're infallible, stop with the strawman arguments.
Then why do you call someone a Gaal if they don't find them credible?Nobody treats them like prophets and Nobody said they're infallible, stop with the strawman arguments.
I did not.Then why do you call someone a Gaal if they don't find them credible?
(FYI : I get the point, before someone states it ain't the point your trying to put across)
Would you go to a headteacher who you have a meeting with looking all rough and not ready? Or would you present yourself in the best of ways, clearly neat and ready to meet. If you do so for the headteacher, why not to Allah SWT. How can you pray without a hijab? That isn't sunnah, nor does it have basis in the deen. If you present yourself well to a headteacher, why can't you do the same to Allah SWT. I wouldn't go into a headteachers office with a skinny jean and a tight vest. So I shaln't do the same for prayers.
If you pray the obligatory 5 and extra sunnah, but fail to follow the basic rule of modesty, both men and women, then your somewhat on par with the hijabi who doesn't pray. At the end of the day, both party transgressed.
What I do know is that a lot of you muslims take Hadith for face value instead of using logic. How is a man that was born over a millennium after the prophet passed gonna know if a Hadith is authentic or not
These Wahhabis also take Hadith gradings from Al Albani. A guy who lived in the 20th century.
None of them can explain how a guy knows whether a hadith is authentic 1,000-1,200 years after its been penned down.
There’s even been a book dedicated to prove his gradings wrong
When Al Albani Disagrees With Himself : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
It is known among those who read Shaykh Albani’s books in Arabic that he contradicts himself when grading hadith. He may grade a hadith weak in one of his...archive.org
Wallahi its crazy. They will call you a murtad for questioning the authenticity of a Hadith or scholar but will hold the sayings of these scholars to higher positions than the what the Quran saysThese Wahhabis also take Hadith gradings from Al Albani. A guy who lived in the 20th century.
None of them can explain how a guy knows whether a hadith is authentic 1,000-1,200 years after its been penned down.
There’s even been a book dedicated to prove his gradings wrong
When Al Albani Disagrees With Himself : Free Download, Borrow, and Streaming : Internet Archive
It is known among those who read Shaykh Albani’s books in Arabic that he contradicts himself when grading hadith. He may grade a hadith weak in one of his...archive.org
Your right, they ain't comparable. That was incorrect for me to compare. But one knows to pray, but refuses to do so, and the other one knows that Hijab in a salat is a connection with Allah SWT, but refuses to do so. Both are in the wrong, in different levels.I get what you're trying to say, but surely you can't compare not praying to not wearing hijab?
The prayer is what distinguishes a Muslim and gaal. Not praying can take you out of the fold of Islam. The same can never be said about not wearing hijab. They are not on par.
I agree with the rest of what you said though.
Your right, I was incorrect there, the one who doesn't pray and knows to do so, whilst wearing the hijab, has fully transgressed. Its a pillar of Islam, a important one.The Pakistani girl that’s praying, fasting is more of a Muslim than big ole jilbabi xalimo that does none or partially. If anything wearing a hijab while not practicing is akin to munafiq as your external and internal conflict.
Sufyan ibn 'Uyayna told us from Salim Abu al Nadr- a freed slave of 'Umar ibn 'Ubayd-Allah - who heard 'Ubayd-Allah ibn Abi Rafi' relate from his father that the Apostle had said:The way you weirdos interpret Quran verses and base credibility on Hadiths on if you agree with it or not.