What's your problem with khairelaawe? I thought you guys are all on the same team.I have defended him always. but not his government or kheyre.
Mashallah welcome abti RD is big though you gotta be more specificReer diini.
What's your problem with khairelaawe? I thought you guys are all on the same team.
I disagree, Muslims are obliged to remain united in religion not in country or governance like I’ve explained before and an example is the government of khulufa arrashideen ali and the government of the famous sahaba muawiya ibn abusufiyanTheres a better chance of somalia becoming a jewish country than puntland seperating from somalia boowe puntland is the backbone of somalia.
Muslims are obliged to remain united and not to seperate from eachother.
Mashallah welcome abti RD is big though you gotta be more specific![]()
That divison was a mistake we all know it yet we tend to not blame either side.I disagree, Muslims are obliged to remain united in religion not in country or governance like I’ve explained before and an example is the government of khulufa arrashideen ali and the government of the famous sahaba muawiya ibn abusufiyan
Are you saying the Sahaba made a mistakeThat divison was a mistake we all know it yet we tend to not blame either side.
It was a big Fitna
No thats enough im siyaad tooRer Siyad. reer osman siyad. should I go on?
what's yours abti?
Is the sahaba A Maczuum.Are you saying the Sahaba made a mistakeI disagree, this lead to the creation of the great Umayyad empire which wouldn’t have happened if they didn’t split
Islam spread far and wide because of this
What have you got against the current federal system?I disagree, Muslims are obliged to remain united in religion not in country or governance like I’ve explained before and an example is the government of khulufa arrashideen ali and the government of the famous sahaba muawiya ibn abusufiyan
Yes humans make mistakes however this split being a mistake is an opinion and I don’t see it that way, we flourished and expanded because of this split allowing multiple Islamic caliphates since it would be impossible to run all together, we benefited greatly because of this and entered our golden yearsIs the sahaba A Maczuum.
People make mistakes. The prophet even made mistakes even though he was forgiven.
You are directly contradicting what islamic eschatology says about a United muslim ummah, how can you want a United muslim ummah and yet want to cause division between somalis who are Muslim? Unless you are suffering from cognitive dissonanceYes humans make mistakes however this split being a mistake is an opinion and I don’t see it that way, we flourished and expanded because of this split allowing multiple Islamic caliphates since it would be impossible to run all together, we benefited greatly because of this and entered our golden years
@Reiko, is still contemplating about revoking my MJ card!!
@Shaolin23, save me a spot incase I get kicked out. They don't take marehan supporters lightly.
![]()
Do you mean united in religion if so I agree however I don’t think there should be a united umma in governance as has been the case historically, a United ummah in would be a dissaster and would never work practically which is why we instead had multiple contemporary caliphates in our past as MuslimsYou are directly contradicting what islamic eschatology says about a United muslim ummah, how can you want a United muslim ummah and yet want to cause division between somalis who are Muslim? Unless you are suffering from cognitive dissonance
How wasnt it a mistake. A whole lot of sahaaba died fighting eachother????Yes humans make mistakes however this split being a mistake is an opinion and I don’t see it that way, we flourished and expanded because of this split allowing multiple Islamic caliphates since it would be impossible to run all together, we benefited greatly because of this and entered our golden years
Abti we can’t protect you for too long when @Reiko comes for you we gonna have to hand you over we can’t risk another war![]()
Short term, yes however it was probably their time calling them and allah is the greatest of planners and in the long term we would have been more weaker centralized and would have trouble withstanding attacks from the likes of genghis khan if he just had to break us from our capital, Luckily there were several caliphates and for our case the mamluks in Egypt able to protect us which is the good thing of having several allied caliphates which are harder to destroy and better govern their actual constituentsHow wasnt it a mistake. A whole lot of sahaaba died fighting eachother????
Shouldn’t have been cooning against your own peopleNo wonder why the OGs hate you. I heard you sided with the hutttus 30 years ago. and now you're sending me to my grave.
I guess I will take the beating just this once.
![]()