Step a side
VIP
The history of Gragn is beyond Somali history, all of the works around him are based on Hararge which has multuple ethnic groups. An Amhara scholar who wrote the history of Ethiopia from Nubians to Yakuno Amlak to Menelik and a Harari scholar who has copies of the earliest history of Harar preceding Ifat are in agreement that Gragn is Somali Karanle, what Somali mainland scholar can compare in weight to a nation of people who write their own history?Sxb Somali scholars do not claim ahmed gurey is another blow to the story and is just mythology in FKD clan circles with no Somali scholar giving it any credibility.
@DR OSMAN
Ppl still talk about ajuran that ruled 600 years ago and gave commentary on its history to colonial writers. The sources in the book are from emperors like Minas who were caught by Gragns army and sold to Yemen before his freedom was exchanged by Gragns wife with their captured son
These Portuguese that your talking about were defeated and their commander killed in Battle by Imaam Ahmed’s Somali army. The survivors left their weapons and fled into the highlands where the Somalis followed them into and occupied for over a decade. They weren’t exactly war geniuses like your implying@Step a side It doesn't sit well with logic that Somali general led Adal wars while habesh had portugese legionaire leading and escalating the conflict dimension as the Somali general wouldn't be able to respond to portugese calibre general war strategy.
Plus what's the date on the book is another important factor. If it's modern, i'd be careful as it's not even from the time period unless it has strong un-deniable universal evidence(not evidence muran keenayso universal means no muran) and I hope it's not just ku tiri ku teen(hearsay) written in the modern age either as that will hurt its credibility.
Its unanimous with many Germans such as Manfred Kropp who wrote Ethiopian history of the 20th century, Paulitschke who met Rer Ibrahim in the 19th century and said they were the first Somalis in the land and are the most important of people, several European institutes have taken from Ahmed Shami, Berhanu Kamal wrote his own book in Amharic today and has 30 books on Ethiopian history and confirms the same lineage, Layla Sabag a Syrian writer the same.At least when Ugaaska Murusade or Karanle puts sharaftisa on the line and claims Ahmed Gurey, A local response will be garnered by Somali academics and historians, till then brother, be very careful about what u believe to be true due to sub-conscious bias or finding a history 4 karanle.
Its unanimous with many Germans such as Manfred Kropp who wrote Ethiopian history of the 20th century, Paulitschke who met Rer Ibrahim in the 19th century and said they were the first Somalis in the land and are the most important of people, several European institutes have taken from Ahmed Shami, Berhanu Kamal wrote his own book in Amharic today and has 30 books on Ethiopian history and confirms the same lineage, Layla Sabag a Syrian writer the same.
View attachment 287059
Its unanimous with many Germans such as Manfred Kropp who wrote Ethiopian history of the 20th century, Paulitschke who met Rer Ibrahim in the 19th century and said they were the first Somalis in the land and are the most important of people, several European institutes have taken from Ahmed Shami, Berhanu Kamal wrote his own book in Amharic today and has 30 books on Ethiopian history and confirms the same lineage, Layla Sabag a Syrian writer the same.
At least when Ugaaska Murusade or Karanle puts sharaftisa on the line and claims Ahmed Gurey, A local response will be garnered by Somali academics and historians, till then brother, be very careful about what u believe to be true due to sub-conscious bias or finding a history 4 karanleAt least when Ugaaska Murusade or Karanle puts sharaftisa on the line and claims Ahmed Gurey, A local response will be garnered by Somali academics and historians, till then brother, be very careful about what u believe to be true due to sub-conscious bias or finding a history 4 karanle.
Typical Low IQ Somali that goes against universally agreed upon scholarly consensus. Go and cry somewhere else saxib. Crowned on live TV kulahaBrother when Ugaaska Karanle or Murusade come out on TV and put up their sharaf on the line for your theory kkkkk and have PROOF of harar on TV giving them recognition for being ahmed gurey descendants, only then will I even begin to take a Somali was Ahmed Gurey. Till then cut n paste all u want
There is no Harar ruling family. Use your brain a bit more saxib. Swallow your pride. Here is us defending our city. We eventually lost it to Menelik s explained by that tiktok video I send you earlier. Here is the war documented by the Italians.@Step a side Why don't u just go to harar baan ku iri and have their harar ruling family recognize that karanle is ahmed gurey, rather then cutting n pasting every document u can and doing ku tiri ku teen.
Why u scared to be recognized in public, RECOGNITION, ama tarikh iskeeda isku sheegtay sida somaliland oo iskeeda meel uu istagay kkkkk, somaliland hadi la diido becuz of no recognition, why would I accept where there is no official recognition for karanle on TV between harar and karanle. U think I would accept darod father tomb in zabid yemen if abdillahi yusuf didnt go there and there is youtube video and it was official trip by dawlada.
Kkkk why would i need to go Harar with isimo when the books are already there and preceded me, there is no formal need to recognise history when history is written. We celebrate it at will. The Barre regime did what it could to hide Ajuran and Gureys history doesn't mean it it aint there. Somalis in Djibouti, Sudanese and Eritreans read about us and approach our people online and offline to learn about the Greater Horn. Go and ask your mother what her ppl say about Ahmed Gurey and you will hear the same things.@Step a side I want my maternal awoowe to be the best dummy, it's in my genes, lakin inla ceebeeyo ma yeelayo, even bring all somalis isimo together to provide historical recognition and then go to harar to seal it and your done brother, lakin ha noqon somaliland qaran iska heesaayo with no recognition idinkuna tarikh isku heesayo with noone recognizing it. Dont open up beesha to assaults
MJ Boqor all somalis must be present at all times when crowned niyahow as he is Somali Boqor, he dont crown himself as he is longest surviving boqortoyo in somali penisula. Even my futo xun who we warred with and left bari attend and put down my bad taste @Libaax-Joore tarikh lama samaysan karo by recognizing yourself.