Somalis and Horses

tyrannicalmanager

tyrannicalmanager

pseudo-intellectual
xawaadleboi121 said:
Somalis historically didnt like larger horses. They wanted something small and low maintenance. I wouldn't say theyre even medium. Theyre outright small, not even large enough to be considered horses but ponies. Minimum height to be a horse is 4'10 at the shoulder. Avg somali pony is 4'6. Internationally speaking, arabian horses are considered small horses. a Medium is about 5'4.

I read about Somali ponies being crossed with other horses in Kenya, and I've attached it here. and they said that Somali ponies were extremely receptive and that the first generations of mixes were already great racers. However, I think theres an issue with this way of thinking and its centered on appealing to standards that are not original to ourselves. Instead of undoing centuries and centuries of Somalis breeding for small, fast, agile, low maintenance ponies so that theyre more like other horses, why dont we breed the best somali ponies and make the best damn ponies on the planet?? Have something unique and beautiful in its own right. Ive seen some magnificient ones on tiktok as of late.View attachment 314707
Click to expand...
Mongolian horses are smaller than somali breeds, lol.
 
enda_el

enda_el

awsaleban667 said:
Here is another photo of full foot stirupps just give it up bro
View attachment 315305
Click to expand...
Again thats just a drawing. That could have been based on other drawings. The degodiya photo you sent literally showed toe stirrups. This illustration is literally signed by the artist. You clearly have a motive and are just bringing up anything possible to prove it rather than being academic and honest.
 
awsaleban667

awsaleban667

xawaadleboi121 said:
Again thats just a drawing. That could have been based on other drawings. The degodiya photo you sent literally showed toe stirrups. This illustration is literally signed by the artist. You clearly have a motive and are just bringing up anything possible to prove it rather than being academic and honest.
Click to expand...
Bruh I gave you multiple photos. Give just 1 photo of a Somali with a toe stirrup
 
enda_el

enda_el

tyrannicalmanager said:
Mongolian horses are smaller than somali breeds, lol.
Click to expand...
1707611046034.png


Thats a very good point lol. If these indhoyar can hotep horses we can too. Theyre technically ponies.
 
enda_el

enda_el

awsaleban667 said:
1707611563076.png
1707611505570.png
Bruh I gave you multiple photos. Give just 1 photo of a Somali with a toe stirrup
Click to expand...
The degodiya one you literally posted. Sxb are you ok?
1707611468642.png

1707611505262.png

1707611536399.png

1707611562761.png


What arent you understanding? You showed drawings and then you showed the Sultan of Geledi who was rich and could have just purchased it. These drawings do nothing. I literally posted a source about the toe stirrups too if you havent seen it here
 
awsaleban667

awsaleban667

enda_el

enda_el

awsaleban667 said:
Warya, how can you deny this one it’s another photo
View attachment 315366
Click to expand...
Lmao firstly, Thats a human zoo LOL those arent even somali horses. Whats next did we herd Zebras too? Secondly im certain thats a toe stirrup and hes wearing traditional Somali dacas over top of it. Im not even mad you made that mistake im mad youre using a HUMAN ZOO photo to make your argument 😂😂🤣 do you take yourself seriously?

1707612110531.png


1707612314408.png
 

Attachments

  • 1707612110635.png
    1707612110635.png
    317.8 KB · Views: 50
  • 1707612314696.png
    1707612314696.png
    1.2 MB · Views: 53
enda_el

enda_el

xawaadleboi121 said:
Somalis didnt do mounted archery for the same reasons Ethiopians didn't. Somalis either didnt have stirupps (the part you put your feet that connects to the saddle) or used the Big Toe stirrups just like them. By that I mean the stirrup was a leather loop that could only accommodate 1 toe and not the whole foot. You cannot aim without good stirrups that can hold your weight. To be able to aim a bow effectively on horseback, you have to stand up a little bit on your stirrups and keep yourself balanced and level while your horse gallops using your thigh muscles to absorb the shock of the horse galloping.

Heres a description of the somali saddle and stirrups.
View attachment 314716

Here is an Ethiopian horseman using the same sort of toe stirrups that we used. These small and weak stirrups would never allow for this sort of maneuver. They were just there to make riding more comfortable so aiming effectively like mongolians would never happen.View attachment 314717

Another reason is because somalis didnt use composite bows like mongolians. We used self-bows (one solid piece of wood) like western Europeans did. To have a bow as powerful as a mongolian composite bow, they need to be huge like these Somali bows, and thats just too awkward to deal with on a horse. Thats why we dont hear about English horse archers they moved from bows like us to guns without developing a horse archer culture
View attachment 314719View attachment 314720
Btw you may find images of somali horseriders with whole foot stirrups online, such as Risalder Major Musa, but these arent native. For him it was given to him by the British.

View attachment 314721
Click to expand...
Here
 
enda_el

enda_el

awsaleban667 said:
Milmil to the golis mountain range doesn’t seem that long? Or I did I misunderstand?
View attachment 315379
Click to expand...
Wasnt a straight march they were going all over. It was a geographic survery and also hunting for sport. Also cadaans cant take the heat so they probably didnt get super far lol. All the cadaan explorers always say how unbearable it is. Even read one who requested that the British station in Berbera be moved to the mountains in togdheer bc it was too much for him
 
enda_el

enda_el

Step a side said:
Where are the Oromo horses? Can you link them.
Click to expand...
Oromos are probably the only ethiopians that still take care of their horses they did a study the only horses with good conformity were Oromo and Somali
Cartan Boos said:
They're bit bigger but overall same statue as Somali horses, KKK oromo are dwarves they make the horses look big, it really depends on the oromo were talking about, the walaga oromo have the habesha horses the shewa have mixed ones and the bale,harage ones have Somali ones, they also have other ethnic groups like sidama,kanso horses
View attachment 267469
Click to expand...
Yea their average height is about the same. 4'4 to 4'10. Old records talk about them being small
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Trending

Latest posts

Top