Qiyas and ijtihaad is part of islam, we can't come with that logic and label people dubious so the four imams of ahlul sunnah you were dubious of their teachings ?
Surah Duha
- Thread starter Basra
- Start date
Qiyas and ijtihaad is part of islam, we can't come with that logic and label people dubious so the four imams of ahlul sunnah you were dubious of their teachings ?
huuno u r also confusing Sin & Shariah law. Its not the same.
Sin is a private action. Shariah Law is practices legally implemented by a govt.
The two should not be confused.
You can live in a Secular Law and practice Shariah Law in private. Which is the proper way for Muslims.
But knowing Muslims, they are not happy with that. They want to open their chest and walk town showing their nipples and harrassing non muslims
We need to be Muslims by example.
Sharia is the entire religion which includes the law..
its contradictory as i mentioned to practice aspects of the deen and leave out the rest, the secular law statement you made is leaving out the rest
it needs to be implemented in its entirety
How do you know everyone has some ulterior motive ?
The source is quran and sunnah and if a shaykh refers to quran and sunnah to make a point he is correct
You're just paranoid, laymen can make their own ijtihaad if they have a sufficient understanding and follow the correct opinion which is in most accordance to quran and sunnah
Sweety there is no such thing as Shariah law in its entirety when it comes to selfish humans
ha ha ha ha ha ha ha
Good luck finding that Utopian dream
There is because you believe the mahdi will appear and he is human, also not all humans are the same
There is because you believe the mahdi will appear and he is human, also not all humans are the same
Mahdi is blessed by ALlaah swt looooooool PURIFIED
you dont trust modern humans to implement shaira but you trust them to implement secularism were they can abuse their position with no rights to a rebellion
you dont trust modern humans to implement shaira but you trust them to implement secularism were they can abuse their position with no rights to a rebellion
Sweety dont u find it ironic that Muslims are able to flourish in Secular Law in the west than their own God for saken country ??? LOL
Thats cause muslims are their own worst enemies, also the muslim countries don't implement sharia entirely they pick and choose parts of it
Good. I am glad u r not in delusions. lol
Believe me, walaahi i am a big fan of Shariah Law as a concept.
But i dont trust Humans.
But i trust Secular law because it has showed me it works. The gaalos have proven to me that Secular law works.
Now of course, it is not perfect. There, are u glad i am not in delusions too?
Good. I am glad u r not in delusions. lol
Believe me, walaahi i am a big fan of Shariah Law as a concept.
But i dont trust Humans.
But i trust Secular law because it has showed me it works. The gaalos have proven to me that Secular law works.
Now of course, it is not perfect. There, are u glad i am not in delusions too?
It works for gaalo cause they have no morality also this dunya is jannah for them as the hadith states
The World is the Prison of the Believer and Heaven for the Kafir” [Muslim 5256]
The whole point of this discussion was for me to tell you as a muslim, secularism is anti sharia it makes haram halal and vice versa plus whats its framework of governance that it is built upon it is nafs ??
You don't trust people to implement sharia i get your point but at the same time it contradicts the fact you trust humans to
govern according to their nafs.. (secularism)
I gathered that you like sharia mashallah but you don't trust people lol, rather what you should say is we have no choice cause of the current dynamics of the world.. but sharia is the best system not secularism
Theres a strict vetting process to appoint a amir in a sharia state anyway, he must be sound mind, he must have knowledge of diin etc whereas secularism anyone can rule, any incompetent loser and he can make rules which are contrary to human nature and can effect society
It works for gaalo cause they have no morality also this dunya is jannah for them as the hadith states
The World is the Prison of the Believer and Heaven for the Kafir” [Muslim 5256]
The whole point of this discussion was for me to tell you as a muslim, secularism is anti sharia it makes haram halal and vice versa plus whats its framework of governance that it is built upon it is nafs ??
You don't trust people to implement sharia i get your point but at the same time it contradicts the fact you trust humans to
govern according to their nafs.. (secularism)
I gathered that you like sharia mashallah but you don't trust people lol, rather what you should say is we have no choice cause of the current dynamics of the world.. but sharia is the best system not secularism
Theres a strict vetting process to appoint a amir in a sharia state anyway, he must be sound mind, he must have knowledge of diin etc whereas secularism anyone can rule, any incompetent loser and he can make rules which are contrary to human nature and can effect society
Maybe i didn't explain properly why i support Secularism.
At the core of Secular Law is the tolerance aspect. The idea that Man is free. Particularly the United States of America Secularism which is the freedom of speech, Freedom to practice religion, and tolerance for society agreed upon norms. The point of Secularism is progress of human thru times. At its core there is a notion of Man being an animal, therefore man needs to be improved & progressed.
As opposed to Shariah Law which pretty much says Man is not Free. Man in governed by Gods law. Now, you can step out of ISLAM and become Kufaar, then you will be free again. Not governed by Gods law.
Do u see this stark difference huuno???
The Secular Law is already set to be followed. SO yes, any "loser" has a right to be a governor too. Because every loser has a right to exist too. lol Because he will be enforcing a law that is already set and works.
The Congress people are the people who set Secular Law, and usually they represent their constituents.
So, these gaalos have a centuries of practice to improve Secular Law where as Shariah law has not been implemented in Humanity except say Saudia Arabia.
And u have seen what happens there? Somalis & Brown foreign workers are being executed left & right, while the Saudi born are not.
The Reason Secular Law works is because there plenty of precedents. Shariah Law has no precedents. Legal precedents according to Quran practice is very rare, Saudi and other few countries practice it, but not its entirety. Therefore, going to my point again, Good luck on your Utopian Shariah law land. lol Human need to have legal precedents Shariah or Secular to be controlled!
Again, let me emphasize-- at the core of Secularism is tolerance for ALL. (which ironically is Islam law but Muslims dont practice this tolerance, Judging is their favorite past time lol)
Last edited:
Saudi arabia is a monarch which again like mentioned implements aspects of sharia and leaves the rest which basically = no sharia so there actions, saudis actions are not in accordance to quran and sunnah infact majority of their actions aren't
idk what you mean by not implemented in humanity, ottoman khilafahs, rashidun khilfas, many sultanates across muslim history implemented it successfully.
ok tolerance, there is tolerance which is jizyah gaalo can live under sharia law
"The Congress people are the people who set Secular Law, and usually they represent their constituents." - humans shouldnt set laws it goes against the statements of the quran ( you read quran you should know this)
Any loser- i meant leadership incompetency, not everyone is fit to lead there are strict criteria which must be met ... all the leaders in modern muslim countries are incompetent which is why those lands are not thriving
My dear @Dawo Lets agree to disagree. We are not very different in our views. I am realistic & you are Ideological.
I live in the real world. You live in the idealogical Utopia,
I live in the real practical world, with a hopeful view towards aqeero
You live in the aqeero now.
At least, lets agree we are agree to disagree, which is okey hon, inshalaah we will both have a tea party in Janaaah Inshalaah.
Last edited:
If the right people are in charge and are truly following islamic law would you then support it? Obviously this is what Muslims call for when they say they'd want Sharia, not something being called Sharia in name but in actuality has things against islam and is run by corrupt filthy people, much like a lot of the arab nations that claim their land is under sharia
My dear @Dawo Lets agree to disagree. We are not very different in our views. I am realistic & you are Ideological.
I live in the real world. You live in the idealogical Utopia,
I live in the real practical world.
You live in aqeero.
At least, lets agree we are agree to disagree, which is okey hon, inshalaah we will both have a tea party in Janaaah Inshalaah.
May Allah guide us and have mercy on us
