The Disturbing Racism in Shi'ism

[cooli3o]

tbh i haven't studied shi'i books I would prefer a shi'i scholar to explain these things to me instead of getting a biased opinion
ive seen the same videos about how sunni Muslims are racist because having white and light skin in some ahaadeeth are "praised" or we will have bright faces in jannah

 

[xiin-finiin.]

what does this mean? do you have a racist hadith to share with us from Saheeh Bukhari?

No, i do not know of any hadith that are in sahih bukhari that are racist. What that gif was trying to get at was how there are racist sunni scholars (and i mean huge scholars that many many muslims look up to), and how using the fact that there are racist hadith in shia sources to somehow show they are "deviant" isn't really a strong argument.

 

[Omar del Sur]

No, i do not know of any hadith that are in sahih bukhari that are racist. What that gif was trying to get at was how there are racist sunni scholars (and i mean huge scholars that many many muslims look up to), and how using the fact that there are racist hadith in shia sources to somehow show they are "deviant" isn't really a strong argument.

Yes it is, having a racist quote from the historian Ibn Khaldun is nowhere near the same thing as having racism in your main hadith book.

 

[TekNiKo]

Shia sympathizers, how is your view on the racism in shi'ism?

If slandering the chastity of mother Aisha (who happens to be the wife of Prophet Muhammad ﷺ) is no big deal to you

is the view that blacks are "a distorted creation" also no big deal to you? Do you support the Shia view on blacks?

Rather trust a Shi’a than a Wahabi Kharijite.

 

[Omar del Sur]

Rather trust a Shi’a than a Wahabi Kharijite.

I'm against the Khawarij too, anyone who makes takfir based on major sins or wrongfully rebels against the Muslim ruler has definitely gone astray.

 

[xiin-finiin.]

Yes it is, having a racist quote from the historian Ibn Khaldun is nowhere near the same thing as having racism in your main hadith book.

am not talking about ibn khaldun.

 

[Omar del Sur]

am not talking about ibn khaldun.

Well who are you talking about? Do these scholars have names?

 

[NordicSomali]

Which scholars, Name drop them and bring evidence against them.

Whoever wrote those books with those quotes, and whomever is the source for those quotes.

 

[techsamatar]

@Xoxoxo You deny the purest Arabs were dark skinned and got replaced despite the hadiths, now read these backed by historical sources, first of all learn your Deen before you speak so ignorantly, I've sent the paintings of early Arab armies, all depict brown skinned people


The Ummayads saw themselves as superior, they massacred the family of the prophet SAW and discriminated non Arabs and Allah SWT says in the Quran he will always replace bad people for new good people
Now what happened??

The Abbasids arrived with a general from Khurasan leading great armies of Persians and central Asians, they conquered from east Khurasan to Kufa in modern day Iraq, the Abbasids later started massacring the Quraysh and the lands of the Arabs began to get filled with non Arab central Asians and Persians, there are many famous Persian families that assimilated now the 2 largest haplos are J1 and J2 both Persian


Also during conquests they everything in the captured territory is Ghaniima so millions of slaves, and when freed they take the masters tribe, and they had many European ones

do you have sources for this brother need to look into it, I know the replacement and original arabs and children of shem where black, but the time period of replacement and Abbasid stuff.

 

[Abu Hesi]

Whoever wrote those books with those quotes, and whomever is the source for those quotes.

Thought you was talking about Sunni Scholars, my bad.