Which studies and again Arabs have different ancestry, Real ancient Arabs were not J1
Were camels domesticated first in the horn or arabia?
- Thread starter Nikka
- Start date
Garaad diinle
There are no writting evidance of who or where camels were domesticated. There are no genetic evidence either that explains who were the first camel domesticators. All we have is archaeological evidence which is often time baised towards the arabian peninsula. There are people that would tell you that from linguistic evidence camels must have originated from arabia refering to geel and gamal. Thing is the transition from gamal to geel or gaal is not clear lingusticly and have yet to be demostrated.
Let's just say that gamal and geel or gaal has the same lingustic origin does that mean that camels were exported from arabia? Have you ever heard of the name lo'y لؤي? It's an arabic name minuturised form from the original lo'a meaning wild cow. Al-'smacy a arabic lingust that lived along time ago said that bedoens also call domesticated cow lo'a. In akkadian they call cows litu or lu' somali lo'. Akkadians call donkey imēru somali damer plurar damero arabic ximar. You've got the arabic ضأن Dh'n plural أَضْؤُن ad'n and somali ido by the way i pronounce it as itho. Heck Akkadians call sheep arru somali ari while nothing similar is found in arabic.
In fact dub in arabic or semitic meaning bear might be a congnate with the somali dibi. Dibi meaning big bull or bull in somali and early semites might have described a bear as a large bull but this last one is speculation. Can we say since these names have a common origin arabs have domesticated them and then delivered them to somalia? Answer is no because somalis or to be more specific their cushitic ancaster were already pastoralist long before they entered the horn of africa or even before semitic languages were a thing
Let's just say that gamal and geel or gaal has the same lingustic origin does that mean that camels were exported from arabia? Have you ever heard of the name lo'y لؤي? It's an arabic name minuturised form from the original lo'a meaning wild cow. Al-'smacy a arabic lingust that lived along time ago said that bedoens also call domesticated cow lo'a. In akkadian they call cows litu or lu' somali lo'. Akkadians call donkey imēru somali damer plurar damero arabic ximar. You've got the arabic ضأن Dh'n plural أَضْؤُن ad'n and somali ido by the way i pronounce it as itho. Heck Akkadians call sheep arru somali ari while nothing similar is found in arabic.
In fact dub in arabic or semitic meaning bear might be a congnate with the somali dibi. Dibi meaning big bull or bull in somali and early semites might have described a bear as a large bull but this last one is speculation. Can we say since these names have a common origin arabs have domesticated them and then delivered them to somalia? Answer is no because somalis or to be more specific their cushitic ancaster were already pastoralist long before they entered the horn of africa or even before semitic languages were a thing
Last edited:
Garaad diinle
For somalis to domesticate camels they would need a camel in the first place so were there camels in the horn of africa thousands of years ago? Yes camel presense in africa is said to have started durning the miocene and they made it al the way to tanzania. In fact there might have been a bactrian camels in the omo valley which are not found today anywhere in the arabian peninsula. So somalis didn't need camels from the arabian peninsula because they already had some in the horn to domesticat. Now this does not mean that somalis were the first to domesticat camels or that they did so independently rather it means or alludes to the possibliy that they might have did so.
@Luffy why do you attribute everything to Arabs? How will you respond to Garaad? Do you worship Aryabs or Allah?
The Arabs are Muslims, and the Messenger and his companions came out of them, who made the Somalis Muslims
In Islam, you must love the Arabs. Hating them means that you are a hypocrite and not a true Muslim
Garaad diinle
Yes love abu lahab love abu jahl love musailimah al kadab, they are all arabs otherwise you're a hypocrite kkkkkkkkkk.
According to you because we don't attribute certain aspects of our culture To Arabs we hate them and by extension the The prophet and his companions . Rather we dislike people that believe All of Somali culture is derived from the Arabs. Your agenda is pretty clear and your just hiding behind the deen.
Garaad diinle
Here is a good read for the presence of camels in africa and east africa.
Alot of Arabs arent muslim, and less than 20% of Muslims today are Arabs
Who let this shegaato xaywaan in this forum
If East Cushites got their camels from Arabs how come East Cushites don't ride Camels like Arabs do? Somalis, Afar, Saho, Rendile, and Oromos do not ride Camels at all.
You'd think if Arabians introduced Camels to Africans they'd show them how to ride them too the f*ck. Makes zero sense otherwise, other populations Arabs introduced Camels to ride them as well like Saharan groups.
You'd think if Arabians introduced Camels to Africans they'd show them how to ride them too the f*ck. Makes zero sense otherwise, other populations Arabs introduced Camels to ride them as well like Saharan groups.
You do not know anything about Islam. Look for the hadiths of the Prophet about the Arabs
But these 20% are the ones who made the other 80% Muslim God chose the Arabs to protect the last message because they are good people
Most of the Somali culture came with Islam. Somalis before Islam, no one knew them. They were often just primitive people living in the Stone Age.
Garaad diinle
Please teach me kkkkkkkkk.
No, I only love the Arabs who made us Muslims and the best people came out of them. You can look into the interpretation of the Qur’an and hadiths and you will see.You must love the yahuuds of Israel then cause guess who's their ancestors nigga?
Then you my brother are a hypocrite
The hadith of the Messenger of Allah may Allah prayers and peace be upon him: “Loving the Arabs is faith, and hating them is hypocrisy.”
حديث رسول الله صلى الله عليه وسلم: ((حب العرب إيمان، وبُغضهم نفاق)
Trending
-
-
-
Why do we make the mentally ill in our community famous- Started by Geeljire lotus
- Replies: 31
