Why is Somalia the Most Corrupt Country in the World?

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cotton Eyed Joe

More law, less justice.
VIP
Somalia has ranked as the most corrupted country in the world, with instability and restricted press freedom as factors hindering transparency in the Sub-Saharan African nation.

Transparency International said in its Corruption Perception Index 2017 that most of the countries surveyed made very little progress in ending corruption last year.

The index ranked 180 countries and territories by their perceived levels of public sector corruption "according to experts and business people". It found that Somalia, South Sudan, Syria, Afghanistan and Yemen—all marred by wars and insurgencies—were the five most corrupted countries. On the other hand, New Zealand, Denmark, Finland, Norway and Switzerland were deemed as the least corrupted.

Somalia has ranked as the most corrupted country in the world, with instability and restricted press freedom as factors hindering transparency in the Sub-Saharan African nation.

Transparency International said in its Corruption Perception Index 2017 that most of the countries surveyed made very little progress in ending corruption last year.

The index ranked 180 countries and territories by their perceived levels of public sector corruption "according to experts and business people". It found that Somalia, South Sudan, Syria, Afghanistan and Yemen—all marred by wars and insurgencies—were the five most corrupted countries. On the other hand, New Zealand, Denmark, Finland, Norway and Switzerland were deemed as the least corrupted.

worlds-most-corrupted-countries.jpg

TRANSPARENCY INTERNATIONAL
"Somalia is only beginning to emerge from a long period of state collapse and is therefore faced with the typical corruption challenges that affect countries in post-conflict contexts," Paul Banoba, Transparency International's East Africa expert, told Newsweek.

Somalia was ravaged by a bloody civil war from 1986 till 1992. Rebel groups continued to fight for the hegemony of territories even after the end of the conflict. The civil war and instability provided fertile ground for the birth of Al-Shabaab, one of the deadliest terrorist organizations in Africa.

"Fighting corruption in post-conflict contexts is particularly challenging and Somalia needs all the support it can get," Banoba said.

Elections

somalia-elections.jpg

Somali lawmakers attend a voting session to elect a new president inside Mogadishu airport on February 08, 2017 Somali lawmakers were choosing a president under tight security on February 8, with roads closed and residents urged to remain indoors over fears of a strike on the capital by Shabaab militants. Mortar fire hit several neighbourhoods of Mogadishu and fighting broke out between the extremists and African Union peacekeepers (AMISOM) just outside the capital on Tuesday evening, according to police and witnesses.MUSTAFA HAJIABDINUR/AFP/GETTY IMAGES)
Last year, the country held presidential elections. Through an indirect vote, members of parliament and an upper house chose a president from 23 candidates.

The vote, hailed as a landmark for a country that hadn't had a functional government since 1991, was marred by corruption scandals. Reports claimed parliamentarian candidates bought seats and votes for anywhere between $5,000 to $30,000 dollars.

A joint statement by the U.N. mission in Somalia (UNSOM) read: "International partners strongly believe that elections must be re-run for seats where the voting outcomes were clearly distorted by violence, corruption, intimidation, the unauthorized substitution of electoral college delegates and a failure to set aside one of every three seats for exclusively female candidates."

Freedom of speech

Transparency International noted that countries with the least protection for press and NGOs were also likely to be the most corrupted.

According to the Committee to Protect Journalists (CPJ), at least 64 journalists have been killed in Somalia since 1992.

More recently, the organization has documented at least five cases of journalists detained in connection with their work in the autonomous region of Somaliland since September 2017.

Earlier this month, CPJ called for the release of local journalist Abdishakur Abdullahi Ahmed, also known as Shaasha, who was arrested last December after being accused "of airing false news" after he reported critically on the local administration.

Last year, the government passed a law prohibiting the spread of news deemed as false and propagandistic, without providing clear guidelines. Rights groups condemned the move, arguing it would curtail freedom of speech.

Journalists are under threat also by Al-Shabaab. Amnesty International said in its annual report on the state of human rights worldwide that the group prohibits journalists from operating in areas under its control.

"The group continued to detain, threaten and harass media workers throughout the
country," it said.

Drought

somalia-drought.jpg

A displaced Somali child sits on May 24, 2017 at a makeshift camp in the Garasbaley area on the outskirts of the capital Mogadishu, where people converge after fleeing their homes due to the dire drought that hits the country. The World Health Organization warned in April that the drought was fuelling an outbreak of cholera and acute diarrhoea in Somalia that has already killed hundreds of people. The warning came as Somalia faces the threat of its third famine in 25 years of civil war and anarchy.MOHAMED ABDIWAHAB/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
Two consecutive seasons of poor rainfall resulted in severe water shortages last year, causing a drop in food production, livestock deaths and rising costs of food that pushed the country towards the brink of a famine just six years after some 260,000 people starved to death in the East African nation.

Persisting insecurity and travel restrictions imposed because of attacks by Al-Shabaab resulted in the escalation of food prices and a drop in supplies, meaning that people do not have access to basic goods to cope with the ongoing crisis.

Somalia relies heavily on foreign aid, which can however end up in the wrong hands unless controls are tightened in the country.

"Resources going into a country with weak systems are vulnerable to misappropriation," Banoba explained.

Violence

al-shabaab-group.jpg

Somalian security personnel look towards burning vehicles as they secure an area in Mogadishu on July 30, 2017, after a car bomb explosion in the Somalian capital. At least five people have been killed and ten wounded in Somalia's capital Mogadishu when a car bomb detonated on a busy road, the security ministry said. There was no immediate claim of responsiblity but the bombing fits the pattern of Al-Qaeda linked Shabaab Islamists, who have carried out numerous suicide bombings and raids in the capital targeting civilian, government and military targets.STR/AFP/GETTY IMAGES
Some analysts have pointed out that violence is a major driver of corruption.

Somalia has been rocked by instability and bloody insurgencies since 1992. Last year, the country's capital Mogadishu became the site of one of Africa 's deadliest terror attacks when a truck laden with explosives was detonated, killing more than 500 people.

Al-Shabaab claimed responsibility. The group, whose splinters have links to both Al-Qaeda and the Islamic State terror groups, aims to overthrow the Somali government and impose its own version of Islam in the country.

"The government of Somalia is suffering from a decade-long problem that has been created by the inability of the government to have full control of the country," security analyst David Otto told Newsweek.

"Corruption is a huge driver of instability but it is also fair to say that instability creates an environment for corruption to prosper as the legitimate state loses control of its institutions and the people that it is supposed to govern.

"Groups like Al-Shabaab use public corruption and what they see as Western nations taking full advantage of the instability to radicalize young men and women to join their ranks."

Shabaab controlled the capital Mogadishu and the southern region of Somalia from 2006 until 2011, when it was defeated by African Union peacekeepers.

The group still controls pockets of the country. It also carries out attacks in Kenya, in retaliation to the Linda Nichi operation, which saw the deployment of Kenyan troops to the neighboring country to tackle terrorism.

Somalia's president, Mohamed Abdullahi "Farmajo" Mohamed, declared war on Al-Shabab terrorists last year. He offered a 60-day amnesty period to militants to surrender and vowed to help them reintegrate into society. The group dismissed the declaration of war and rejected the offer of amnesty.

"Fighting corruption in post-conflict contexts is particularly challenging and Somalia needs all the support it can get," Banoba said.

"Transparency is a good place to start. International agencies and institutions supporting Somalia should continue to enhance transparency and accountability in their own program, and call for the same from their counterparts in Somalian government," he concluded.
 

Jiron

wanaag
NABADOON
VIP
I personally take these “ranking” with a pinch of salt, sure the country is on a recovery mode with obvious problems but like I said there are people who benifits from the chaos in Somalia both ajnabi and Somalis in ways more than meets the eye :)
 
"The index ranked 180 countries and territories by their perceived levels of public sector corruption "according to experts and business people". It found that Somalia, South Sudan, Syria, Afghanistan and Yemen—all marred by wars and insurgencies—were the five most corrupted countries."


First off, there is no meaningful public sector in Somalia. It's not even big enough to get a good sample size for the purposes of statistical inference. In this and many other cases, TI is well known for its poor methodology and doesn't show any evidence of actual corruption

Secondly, I have no doubt that these experts and business people are even more corrupt than the so called Somali public sector. In fact they are the most corrupt elite in war torn countries. Yet TI relies on these to form an opinion about public sector corruption in a country, a very complex issue anywhere,and just give a random number to that country. TI doesn't measure actual corruption, but perceptions about corruption, two very different things. And they always ask the same people, businessmen and experts.

You can check their index for the last two decades, the Nordics are always the first five and some war torn shit holes in Africa or nearby are always last. The Berlin based TI and its Index is actually meaningless in terms of actual corruption.

I'm sure if you asked Trump, the list would be in the same order.
 
Freedom of press entails granting hegemony to the enemy to pollute and brainwash your populace through various subversion techniques, the more you grant this, the higher your rank goes of course.

The same people doing these so called studies are funded and instituted by these same genocidal mafia's who are the most corrupt people on this earth,

The great irony is that they themselves facilitate and drive 90% of the corruption that takes place in the world, all the dirty money sits in banks in London, New-York, Paris and Switzerland were they all share the loot with each other.

London is rich because it's very well known that it's the money laundering capital of the world, your money is so safe that the 'city of London' itself were all the banks are is independent from the UK much like the Vatican.

This excludes all the money and resources which they have stolen and which they continue to pillage until this very day. You and I cannot even send 10k to each other without being heavily audited while the corrupt leader they empower send 100's of millions to their institutions with no questions asked.

To take statistics from the same criminal kingpins that continue to pillage much of the world while being the Godfathers of corruption which is a racket they designed from the ground up and continue to maintain is highly idiotic.

We have no one but ourselves to blame her, like Umar Bin Khattab said, we are a people that were honoured with Islam, if we try to find honour anywhere else, Allah will disgrace us! disgrace us by giving these infidels power over us while we remain divided at each other's throats.

This happened to the Israelite's as Surah Isra informed us about the two great punishment they were inflicted with (Babylonian conquest & Roman conquest) when they transgressed.

Our press is free from all western influences, I cannot think of a press like ours that is pretty much independently run for the most part, so of course we will rank the lowest.

In terms of so called 'public' sector corruption, we don't have any public sector we can speak off, pretty much all of the corruption that is referred to is related to the government, this is a system that was imposed on us by outsiders and leaders which they themselves have selected including MP's

All the corruption these snakes speak off stems from the outside done by their own puppets and the money sits in their own financial institutions, if there was corruption in the private sector, the companies themselves would have collapsed along with the country.
 
Last edited:

RasCanjero-

Self imposed exile
Vultures got to eat.

If we had a larger private sector then our current politicians would be rentiers of our wider economy instead of fighting over our current measly 250 million a year.

Once we have a proper private sector with companies more powerful than the government we would see a decrease in corruption since that will cut into their bottom lines.
 

Saalax Bidaar

Truthfulness so often goes with ruthlessness
Freedom of press entails granting hegemony to the enemy to pollute and brainwash your populace through various subversion techniques, the more you grant this, the higher your rank goes of course.

The same people doing these so called studies are funded and instituted by these same genocidal mafia's who are the most corrupt people on this earth,

The great irony is that they themselves facilitate and drive 90% of the corruption that takes place in the world, all the dirty money sits in banks in London, New-York, Paris and Switzerland were they all share the loot with each other.

London is rich because it's very well known that it's the money laundering capital of the world, your money is so safe that the 'city of London' itself were all the banks are is independent from the UK much like the Vatican.

This excludes all the money and resources which they have stolen and which they continue to pillage until this very day. You and I cannot even send 10k to each other without being heavily audited while the corrupt leader they empower send 100's of millions to their institutions with no questions asked.

To take statistics from the same criminal kingpins that continue to pillage much of the world while being the Godfathers of corruption which is a racket they designed from the ground up and continue to maintain is highly idiotic.

We have no one but ourselves to blame her, like Umar Bin Khattab said, we are a people that were honoured with Islam, if we try to find honour anywhere else, Allah will disgrace us! disgrace us by giving these infidels power over us while we remain divided at each other's throats.

This happened to the Israelite's as Surah Isra informed us about the two great punishment they were inflicted with (Babylonian conquest & Roman conquest) when they transgressed.

Our press is free from all western influences, I cannot think of a press like ours that is pretty much independently run for the most part, so of course we will rank the lowest.

In terms of so called 'public' sector corruption, we don't have any public sector we can speak off, pretty much all of the corruption that is referred to is related to the government, this is a system that was imposed on us by outsiders and leaders which they themselves have selected including MP's

All the corruption these snakes speak off stems from the outside done by their own puppets and the money sits in their own financial institutions, if there was corruption in the private sector, the companies themselves would have collapsed along with the country.

Bookmarked for reading later. Keep spitting the knowledge abti gacaliye
 
Vultures got to eat.

If we had a larger private sector then our current politicians would be rentiers of our wider economy instead of fighting over our current measly 250 million a year.

Once we have a proper private sector with companies more powerful than the government we would see a decrease in corruption since that will cut into their bottom lines.

The private sector in Somalia is much larger than the public sector. In fact this is one of the reasons why Somalia is so resilient despite being a failed state. The multiplier effect of the private sector economy helps to supplement in areas that should be supported by the public sector like employment, health, education, agriculture, housing etc.

The negative side of this is that the lack of a strong government means that business in Somalia is unregulated and untaxed. You may wonder why this is a problem, but the main role of government is to regulate, to tax and to provide the necessary infrastructure to enable business and other productive sectors of the economy to thrive. The private sector will never self regulate or do other public good services because of their innate desire for quick profit.

In the absence of regulation, to give examples, you see worthless universities in every village, hospitals manned by quacks, schools that teach different curricula in different languages, importation of cheap,expired,dangerous, carcinogenic products, collapse of indegenous farming, monopolies, mafia cartels etc the list is endless.

Governments are not perfect but a society run by an unbridled capitalist private sector is even worse. At the height of this unregulated capitalist madness it is said that in some areas of Somalia one would be asked to pay a fee to shelter under a tree during the hottest period of the day.

A strong public sector complimenting a strong private sector is what all countries strive for.
 

RasCanjero-

Self imposed exile
The private sector in Somalia is much larger than the public sector. In fact this is one of the reasons why Somalia is so resilient despite being a failed state. The multiplier effect of the private sector economy helps to supplement in areas that should be supported by the public sector like employment, health, education, agriculture, housing etc.

The negative side of this is that the lack of a strong government means that business in Somalia is unregulated and untaxed. You may wonder why this is a problem, but the main role of government is to regulate, to tax and to provide the necessary infrastructure to enable business and other productive sectors of the economy to thrive. The private sector will never self regulate or do other public good services because of their innate desire for quick profit.

In the absence of regulation, to give examples, you see worthless universities in every village, hospitals manned by quacks, schools that teach different curricula in different languages, importation of cheap,expired,dangerous, carcinogenic products, collapse of indegenous farming, monopolies, mafia cartels etc the list is endless.

Governments are not perfect but a society run by an unbridled capitalist private sector is even worse. At the height of this unregulated capitalist madness it is said that in some areas of Somalia one would be asked to pay a fee to shelter under a tree during the hottest period of the day.

A strong public sector complimenting a strong private sector is what all countries strive for.

Agree but it isn't large enough to attract the vultures away from our public coffers.

Other than the government; few entities are able to put together 10 million+ dollar deals.

Currently the public sector seems to be the only accessible fat piece of meat around.

Everything else worthwhile has already been claimed (telecoms etc).

Our 6-8 billion dollar economy might seem huge compared to the government budget but it's split between a million sole traders and pastoralists.

I'm not saying that the current private sector is the answer ..I'm saying that a bigger private sector is.

With more on stake; businesses will lobby the government to put up contract laws and other institutions that would protect them from corruption.
 
Last edited:
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trending

Top