Would you want a cultural purge of qablism in favour of nationalism?

[Spongebob]

When I mean cultural purge, I mean anything that could lead to division or conflict.

Some people say this is the only way of uniting all lands, and some say we need do preserve history. But what do YOU say?

By the way, this sort of purge could go 2 ways. We could remove it and end up like Cambodia during the khmer rouge, whom destroyed all culture and largely failed

Orr like when German unification occurred in 1871, with all the clans (or in this case, principalities) uniting under the white star and retaining things like names of principalities (or in our case, clans) and etc.

I've noticed I have a bias towards the German model, so research more into how these previous nations united.


So, do you want a successful German model, successful Cambodian model, or our current model but if it were successful.

 

[jusbrowsin]

Khmer Rouge would be catastropic for Somalia and the german model focuses on centralisim. Gonna go have to go with the middle.

 

[ilmoweyn]

Other alternatives are post feudalist Korea or post Tokugawa Japan

 

[Internet Nomad]

You should read the Federalist papers

 

[Spongebob]

I'm seeing a lot of interesting votes - which I like.

 

[MalcolmFitzhugh08]

When I mean cultural purge, I mean anything that could lead to division or conflict.

Some people say this is the only way of uniting all lands, and some say we need do preserve history. But what do YOU say?

By the way, this sort of purge could go 2 ways. We could remove it and end up like Cambodia during the khmer rouge, whom destroyed all culture and largely failed
View attachment 352875

Orr like when German unification occurred in 1871, with all the clans (or in this case, principalities) uniting under the white star and retaining things like names of principalities (or in our case, clans) and etc.

View attachment 352874

I've noticed I have a bias towards the German model, so research more into how these previous nations united.


So, do you want a successful German model, successful Cambodian model, or our current model but if it were successful.

You lot in the south kill me your all qabiliste but when you get depressed talk about uniting do you get tired of the gimmicks.

 

[Spongebob]

You lot in the south kill me your all qabiliste but when you get depressed talk about uniting do you get tired of the gimmicks.

I am my own person - I haven't started any qabalayad

 

[MalcolmFitzhugh08]

I am my own person - I haven't started any qabalayad

Fairs Centralised government is preferable German way which is what will happen these mamuuls will disappear.

 

[Sol]

As long as it exists (no matter what form) it will always be an avenue for foreign parties to divide us

 

[Aurelian]

you are nuts

 

[Spongebob]

you are nuts

How

 

[Itsnotthateasy]

Which Qabil is going to carry out this purge?

Anyway you could argue that qabil is being purged by a revolutionary force in Somalia, just not a secular one. It not only purges qabil, but ethnic and national lines too but that's a topic for another time.

You guys think you can pick a secular revolution? Or the revolution is based on the existing factors. It's a weird question its' like choosing whether you want a hurricane or a wildfire, you can't choose these things. It's based on the natural conditions.

The situation in germany was that secularism was already growing due to the influence of the enlightenment so the battle between secular government and the church was set.

 

[Spongebob]

Which Qabil is going to carry out this purge?

Anyway you could argue that qabil is being purged by a revolutionary force in Somalia, just not a secular one. It not only purges qabil, but ethnic and national lines too but that's a topic for another time.

You guys think you can pick a secular revolution? Or the revolution is based on the existing factors. It's a weird question its' like choosing whether you want a hurricane or a wildfire, you can't choose these things. It's based on the natural conditions.

View attachment 352973

The situation in germany was that secularism was already growing due to the influence of the enlightenment so the battle between secular government and the church was set.

I think that the German model is best as it allows people to fully unite under nationalism, whilst retaining their clan identity. Anything to do with clan conflict and etc is wringed out