Any Puntlander take South Somalia ID will lose his puntlander rights

[FBIsomalia]

I don’t think he is, nor will xamar accept it even if he was

Somalia elections decide by clan, HAG screw up,who will decide coming president is reer SWS.

 

[FBIsomalia]

 

[AbdiBashirJR]

why is puntland claiming Khatumo state?

 

[Gacmeey]

Every country in the world has a national i.d system seperate from thier passport.

No complete lies. ID is the responsibility of the state government here in Australia. Last time the federal government tried to introduce a national id there was a massive backlash

 

[Gacmeey]

Fundamentally, the FGS cannot and will not manage the domestic affairs of Puntland which is the purpose of the ID card. If the government wants to create an overarching standard where IDs are standardised fine, but they cannot usurp state powers and responsibilities. Xeerka yaalo haalagu dhaqmo or we can just balkanise right here right now.

 

[𐒋𐒖𐒆𐒔𐒖𐒕𐒈]

A good reference is the US, where it took the US approx. 250 years to even attempt a Federal ID subsequent to the 9/11 events, and even then it was rejected,. and out of that, flowed the REAL ID, as issued under the REAL ID Act, H.R.418, Article II, as introduced by Rep. Sensenbrenner of WI. The REAL ID is still issued by the States, and the Fed. gov't was accommodated with three requirements under the infamous National Security doctrine.

https://www.congress.gov/109/bills/hr418/BILLS-109hr418rfs.pdf

Again, Somalia's Fed. gov't has no authority in issuing national ID. It is a Power reserved for FMSs.

Here is a good lecture about the hiStory, controversy, and critiques of the REAL ID.

 

[FBIsomalia]

A good reference is the US, where it took the US approx. 250 years to even attempt a Federal ID subsequent to the 9/11 events, and even then it was rejected,. and out of that, flowed the REAL ID, as issued under the REAL ID Act, H.R.418, Article II, as introduced by Rep. Sensenbrenner of WI. The REAL ID is still issued by the States, and the Fed. gov't was accommodated with three requirements under the infamous National Security doctrine.

https://www.congress.gov/109/bills/hr418/BILLS-109hr418rfs.pdf

Again, Somalia's Fed. gov't has no authority in issuing national ID. It is a Power reserved for FMSs.

Here is a good lecture about the hiStory, controversy, and critiques of the REAL ID.

Second point, ID information will be leaked by Alkabaab plus data will be storage outside Somalia!.

First let FGS free lands from Alkabaab before talking about Puntland affairs.

 

[FBIsomalia]

 

[FBIsomalia]

 

[𐒋𐒖𐒆𐒔𐒖𐒕𐒈]

Second point, ID information will be leaked by Alkabaab plus data will be storage outside Somalia!.

First let FGS free lands from Alkabaab before talking about Puntland affairs.

Plus considering .So's recent history, it is susceptible to its being abused, check current FGS Leaders a) airlifting poor soldiers to Ras Kamboni to invade JL, and dislodge State leadership, b) sabotaging emergency medical evacuation, c) school certificates, d) scholarships, e) politicizing and withholding of aid / grants to FMSs ... list goes on.

.So is 100 years away, and is no where near close to having anything, which resembles cohesive national politics let alone highly centralised system.