Arabic skit showcasing the brotherhood between Somalis and Yemenis

[Al Adnani]

Don't try to come with lies about my tribe then, we are larger than you

Not in Aden sxb, I'll post my source shortly. Let's be cordial till then

 

[Cush]

Not in Aden sxb, I'll post my source shortly. Let's be cordial till then

No we are larger because Daroods always move there on top of that we have the Darood tribes who got assimilated into the Yemenis, so your argument is void,

 

[HabarSteven12]

Ximyaar comes from Xamar and yes Azania is Somalia the tribes still live there and the graves which are 1400 years old are there

Also, James Dahl alludes to the ancient kingdom of himyar controlling Zeila. My point was not to deny any Somali presence in Zeila. But for most of history, the ruling elite of Zeila were Arabs. The leaders of the walashma and Ifat sultantes were Arabs.

 

[Emir of Zayla]

Ximyaar comes from Xamar and yes Azania is Somalia the tribes still live there and the graves which are 1400 years old are there

Source? And don’t pull up colonial garbage books

 

[Odious Delirium]

Also, James Dahl alludes to the ancient kingdom of himyar controlling Zeila. My point was not to deny any Somali presence in Zeila. But for most of history, the ruling elite of Zeila were Arabs. The leaders of the walashma and Ifat sultantes were Arabs.

Are somalis arab

 

[Emir of Zayla]

Also, James Dahl alludes to the ancient kingdom of himyar controlling Zeila. My point was not to deny any Somali presence in Zeila. But for most of history, the ruling elite of Zeila were Arabs. The leaders of the walashma and Ifat sultantes were Arabs.

You know this isn’t true.

 

[Cush]

Also, James Dahl alludes to the ancient kingdom of himyar controlling Zeila. My point was not to deny any Somali presence in Zeila. But for most of history, the ruling elite of Zeila were Arabs. The leaders of the walashma and Ifat sultantes were Arabs.

Ximyaar never controlled Saylac, it was under Punt and the Puntites controlled even Jeddah and during the Ummayad times under Uthman RA it was called the port of Bunt, in Benaadir the whole coast is filled with cad cads, why not the same for Somaliland?

 

[Emir of Zayla]

Are somalis arab

Only way for his claims to make sense

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Actually archaeological evidences point to Arabs first settling the coast and this is from the Arab type graves in Xamar, in the periplus of the eryhtrean sea it also states the coast of Somalia is called "Azania" and is ruled by Ximyaaris, thus where Xamar comes, from had it really been always Somali and so ancient, it'd be a booming metropolis and foreigners would say they saw Somalis, but this is not the case

Saylac on the other than is ancient and was always Cushitic, and the Puntites ruled Jeddah, we are migratory Arabs, our haplogroup isn't even old enough to be Puntite and that's 95% of Somalis, had we been paternally Puntites there'd be 300 million Somalis

Send the archeological works

Archeologicalists discovered pre Islamic stone structures in Mogadishu built by somalis

Also archeologicalists said that somali pastoralists communities built the city of Zaylac

 

[Cush]

Source? And don’t pull up colonial garbage books

Periplus of the erythrean sea by the Greeks and Benadir oral history from the Ximyaar tribes who first settled, there's a reason they are called Reer Xamar and notice how the first Lamagoodles there were Reer Mataan Abgaal during Hiraab Imamate, Ajuuran controlled the interior while the coast was cad cad

Why are there no Ajuuran remaining there if they ruled it or any history on them?

 

[Cush]

Send the archeological works

Archeologicalists discovered pre Islamic stone structures in Mogadishu built by somalis View attachment 296851

Also archeologicalists said that somali pastoralists communities built the city of Zaylac
View attachment 296852

Never denied Saylac was Somali, you think I am a troll with an agenda? I came here to spread the truth, Saylac was 100% Somali, always was since the time of Punt and Arabs only ruled it for a brief period
Benadir of course has these ancient structures, Ximyaarites came in 400 CE they are ancient

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Also, James Dahl alludes to the ancient kingdom of himyar controlling Zeila. My point was not to deny any Somali presence in Zeila. But for most of history, the ruling elite of Zeila were Arabs. The leaders of the walashma and Ifat sultantes were Arabs.

You once said walashama were eitho-semitics now arabs?!

Why don't you simply admit that you're intellectually dishonest and leave the forum

 

[Emir of Zayla]

Periplus of the erythrean sea by the Greeks and Benadir oral history from the Ximyaar tribes who first settled, there's a reason they are called Reer Xamar and notice how the first Lamagoodles there were Reer Mataan Abgaal during Hiraab Imamate, Ajuuran controlled the interior while the coast was cad cad

Why are there no Ajuuran remaining there if they ruled it or any history on them?

Periplus of the Erythrean sea claims that Himyarites settled in Azania, which is in modern day Swahili coast. Xamar & Himyarites have nothing to do with each other outside of trade. You’re saying this because your a darood who doesn’t like hawiyes.

 

[Emir of Zayla]

Never denied Saylac was Somali, you think I am a troll with an agenda? I came here to spread the truth, Saylac was 100% Somali, always was since the time of Punt and Arabs only ruled it for a brief period
Benadir of course has these ancient structures, Ximyaarites came in 400 CE they are ancient

Arabs never ruled Zeila, source?

 

[Somali_patriotic]

Never denied Saylac was Somali, you think I am a troll with an agenda? I came here to spread the truth, Saylac was 100% Somali, always was since the time of Punt and Arabs only ruled it for a brief period
Benadir of course has these ancient structures, Ximyaarites came in 400 CE they are ancient

There's no prove whatsoever that himyarites were in mogadishu except for peusdo-science that is backed by neither primary sources or archaeological evidences

 

[HabarSteven12]

You once said walashama were eitho-semitics now arabs?! View attachment 296853
Why don't you simply admit that you're intellectually dishonest and leave the forum

No that was Adal not walashma

 

[Cush]

You once said walashama were eitho-semitics now arabs?! View attachment 296853
Why don't you simply admit that you're intellectually dishonest and leave the forum

Walashma=Warsame

Periplus of the Erythrean sea claims that Himyarites settled in Azania, which is in modern day Swahili coast. Xamar & Himyarites have nothing to do with each other outside of trade. You’re saying this because your a darood who doesn’t like hawiyes.

No the periplus states it was in Somalia and Xamar comes from Ximyaar and the tribes still live there

The tribes still have the oral history and the Arab style graves proves this

Also the arcitecture is strictly Persian and Arab influenced, further proving it was not Somali

If Somalis ruled it why are a huge proportion of the buildings not in a unique Somali architecture?

And why is there no Somali oral history about it?

To think a city is so ancient and Somali yet it's influences are all either Persian or Semitic

 

[Odious Delirium]

Only way for his claims to make sense

Her* habar claims everything under somali rule today was usurped from a minority or Arabs or arab mixed somalis and somalis never contributed a thing to the horn.

Now I'm wondering where she even stands on the whole are somalis arab or not debate because she's done a lot of trashing and the sources she uses are rather questionable so I would assume that sources saying somalis are arab must be equally as valid to her.

I want to know @HabarSteven12 do you believe somalis or at least some clans (the ones that claim it) are Arabs if so doesn't this make everything you have said on this site redundant since the arab elites you keep talking about are interchangeable with modern somali clans and according to these random dna stuff these Ana arab guys are pushing?

 

[Somali_patriotic]

No that was Adal not walashma

Nga prior to imam ahmed who took over by force adal was ruled by walashama

 

[Cush]

There's no prove whatsoever that himyarites were in mogadishu except for peusdo-science that is backed by neither primary sources or archaeological evidences

As I previously stated, periplus of erythrean sea and oral history, Azania included Somalia
Xamar is from Ximyaar