Did Somali representatives agree to join this new state and dissolved their own? No? Then forget it.
Cirro Says He Wants Recognition Based On 'Valid Legal Arguments'
- Thread starter IKHALIIL
- Start date
There was no record of a final agreement approved by both parliaments.
There is that cope again.
That's how international agreements work unfortunately take it up with the lawyers not me.
They work with imaginary parliaments? Okay.
This is the only real cope going on, my argument is sound and can be found in legal journals. Yours is just delusion, maybe of a clinically significant level.
Nothing about it was sound. You are arguing that dissolved parliment should have over saw a law.
It's not a law unless the parliament approved it, so yeah dummy.
Which Mogadishu (central government) did. No problems.
Questionable:
Go train as a lawyer and write a journal paper then I might accept your argument, until then we listen to the laywers.
He said it was questionable, not that it was factually void. Sorry but that isn't cutting it. At best he is arguing semantics but the real way we know its legit is the fact that there was next to no disagreements or resistence by former Somalilanders or anyone else after the union was ratified. Or that Somaliland politicians (to my knowledge) have never brought up the idea of the union being void. Probably because the union was in fact legit.
I don't think it's a paper on semantics, it's a legal paper from the international and comparative law quaterly.
There was no resistance because it was a gentelmens agreement that was evolving over time until it was revoked. Now you are trying to argue it's legally solid when there is clearly problems there.
Can anyone explain how this fake news of trump recognizing sland spread? What type of lobbyiest are these, you got the ethiopians, the oromo, the israelis, the emiratis What the hell is going on
Working fulltime acting like a somali, you are a clear ethiopian being funded to push this somaliland idea to split somalis further.
Where are the experts?
Argue with the experts.
SL has been taking Ls for over 30 years.
Don't leave without taking your L first.
The Somali Republic's parliament, which by passed the Act of Union on Jan 18 1961, was composed of the 33 British Somaliland MPs and the 90 Italian Somaliland MPs. They together passed by acclamation the Act of Union which the president they had elected on July 1st 1960 signed into law. The union is ironclad.
This is what Cotran says later in the same paper:
ps. none of this matters as Somalis is a sovereign state that has domestic jurisdiction when interpreting its own legal matters. Only the Somali state can interpret its own constitutive laws.
Technicalities do not impact matters of existential importance. Congress forgot to admit Ohio to the United States and this remained the case for 150 years. No one cares about technicalities in constitutional matters.
https://nowiknow.com/ohios-admission-problem/
Trending
-
-
BREAKING NEWS Saudi ex-Muslim Terror attack in Germany kills 12 people during Christmas Festival- Started by TekNiKo
- Replies: 125
-
