Are you a "Quranist"? Can you tell me based on the Quran how many raka'ah are in Isha?
I personally do not agree with apostasy laws
- Thread starter Xoxoxo
- Start date
Are you a "Quranist"? Can you tell me based on the Quran how many raka'ah are in Isha?
I think this Shabir Ally guy had at least like three different views that constituted apostasy.... I am not making takfir on him but I think there was a good case for it
edit: I was just listening to the video and I'm like 99% sure you could legitimately make takfir on him... he calls his show "let the Quran speak" but he even goes directly against the Quran
Last edited:
actually, there was a famous incident where Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) tried to look the other way when someone committed adultery... that doesn't mean the punishment for it isn't there in the sharia... and it ended up being carried out anyways in that case
Bundasliga
VIP
I'm not a a "Quranist".
"There is no compulsion in faith" is in the Quran & contradict this hadith
Isn't that compulsion ?
The source of Islamic law primarily comes from the Quran and Sunnah (Which are the Authetic Hadiths). There are countless Authentic Hadiths from the Prophet ﷺ and the companions رضي الله عنهم which establish that an Apostate deserved to be judicially executed, the scholars (May Allah be pleased with them all) looked into it and almost all of them unanimously agree that an Apostate deserves to be killed after due process in a Muslim judicial system.
Quran, Sunnah and Ijma (consensus) establishes this. What more do you need?
Who understands the Quran better? You or RasulAllah (peace be upon him)?
“No compulsion in religion” is understood to mean Non-Muslims shouldn’t be forced to accept Islam. As for those who leave Islam, then this verse does not apply to them.
Bundasliga
VIP
What's an apostate according to the Quran & sunnah ?
What kinda question is that lol.
I asked a normal question the hadith doesn't agree with this Quran verse "there is no compulsion in faith".
Bundasliga
VIP
But how? They become non-muslim.
& when kafirs don't disclose their kafirnimo doesnt that make them munafiqs hiding amongst us ?
An Apostate is an “Ex-Muslim”, one who leaves the religion of Islam. It’s very simple.
@Xoxoxo @Bundasliga
If you're in Darul-Islam, you left Islam and then promote apostasy amongst the Muslims, the rules on how to deal with you are very clear.
If you left Islam while living in Darul-Kuffaar, and then attack Islam and Muslims, then the rules are very clear on how to deal with you.
No sugar-coating in any way of form........Get to use to it, people. Islam isn't gonna change because you embrace the "woke" culture.
If you're in Darul-Islam, you left Islam and then promote apostasy amongst the Muslims, the rules on how to deal with you are very clear.
If you left Islam while living in Darul-Kuffaar, and then attack Islam and Muslims, then the rules are very clear on how to deal with you.
No sugar-coating in any way of form........Get to use to it, people. Islam isn't gonna change because you embrace the "woke" culture.
Yes, they are munafiqs but once they expose their Apostasy in public unambiguously then they are judged as such. If they live in a Muslim land where such an act is rightfully punished then they will be detained and the judicial authorities will look into the matter in detail. If he refuses to revert after a waiting period then the judicial authorities will order him to be executed.
This is why tafsir is so important. Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) wasn't only sent to teach the recitation of the Quran. In regards to the Quran, he also taught the interpretation. It isn't for us to make our own interpretation. We have to learn the correct understanding of the Quran.
I'm not out to keep debating this. The law on apostasy has been a part of Islam since the days of Prophet Muhammad (peace be upon him) and the sahaba. It has been a part of Islam for over 1,400 years.
If you are a Muslim then Allah has honored you with Islam. You have been given this beautiful din and you have to do your best to preserve it.
Apostasy law, feminism, lgbt, these are battle grounds. These are areas where Islam says one thing and Western ideology wants Muslims to say something else.
Are you going to cave to pressure to become Westernized or are you going to play your part in defending the din of Allah- and preserving this din intact for future generations? Allah honored you with this din- so will you play your part in defending the din of Allah, the din ul haq?
As @Tamir mentioned, this is an ijma of the scholars. It isn't even a debate.
Islam started as something strange and it will again become something strange. It will be totally in line with prophecies if Islam becomes more and more watered-down. You decide on the individual level whether you want to defend the din or you want to sell it out. No one can force a person to make the right decision in this regard.
If you are a Muslim then Allah has honored you with Islam. You have been given this beautiful din and you have to do your best to preserve it.
Apostasy law, feminism, lgbt, these are battle grounds. These are areas where Islam says one thing and Western ideology wants Muslims to say something else.
Are you going to cave to pressure to become Westernized or are you going to play your part in defending the din of Allah- and preserving this din intact for future generations? Allah honored you with this din- so will you play your part in defending the din of Allah, the din ul haq?
As @Tamir mentioned, this is an ijma of the scholars. It isn't even a debate.
Islam started as something strange and it will again become something strange. It will be totally in line with prophecies if Islam becomes more and more watered-down. You decide on the individual level whether you want to defend the din or you want to sell it out. No one can force a person to make the right decision in this regard.
Bundasliga
VIP
What if they dont make it public ,but get exposed like you can legit takfir on them .
They say they Muslim, they act Muslim, but saying stuff that's takfir-able (lol)
Phiirso
Getting draids inshallah
You and I are what they call 'revisionists". 30's year's war, white people(protestant) fought an entire war to reform Christianity. I share your beliefs, but they are wrong in the context of Islam. I don't consider a Gay Muslim, not of Islam, but 99% of Muslims will condemn him. <--- This is revisionist. (Meaning our revisionism is anti-Islamic, and thus, well brethren of Hell
) Revisionism is anti-Islam, anti-Islam is not Islam. The deen is perfect, it was handed down generations in perfect order without fault, without wrong, without need for #revisiosionism.You either leave the religion, or you bind yourself to everything it adheres to on everything. This is how Islam has been able to endure and this is how it will continue to endure for centuries. What bends is contorted, what doesn't bend either dies or endurs.
As @Amk said, you cannot change the words written in the Quran, nor it's customs, nor it's people, nor it's culture, nor it's history.
Your problem is using a spiritual/faith/(somali word for heart) thing in a rational manner.
Nigga, <---------------- This is intentional.
Nigga.
1+1 isn't a faith based system. If you grew up in the West, stop using your mind to understand Faith based system.
1+1 isn't 2 in Faith. Don't get this shit twisted.
1+1 = Islamic Answer. <=== Don't question it. To question is revisionism. That is literally no lie.
Your equation: 1+1 = 'My personal answer" =/(does not equal) 'Islamic Answer'
What you want: 1+1: 'My personal answer === 'the right answer, please change mfs'
No.
What keeps Islam strong, is that it doesn't bend. It'll never bend. Its laws and structure is for eternity or until the end of time.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Last edited:
Like @Omar del Sur said, Islam started as something strange and it will again become something strange.
Yh bc in the religion we dont want ppl to confess there sins if Allah hides a sin for u u should hide it and repent, the ounishments are an expiation for the people and a repellent to others.
Most ppl confessed their sins bc they felt so guilty they kept on insisting for the prescribed punishment to happen on them
As a muslim u want to think the best about ur muslim brother which is why the prophet ﷺ turned his head
Yep.
Lowkey ppl hate this religion in the forum and they make up the stupidest arguments as to why
ppl acc think they are scholars in this forum
Trending
-
serious question, do you ever see somalia becoming developed in 20 or 30 years?
- Started by Leonardo7373
- Replies: 66
-
Uprising in Syria! Ahlu Bayt Muslims protest in multiple cities- Started by TekNiKo
- Replies: 31
Latest posts
-
Uprising in Syria! Ahlu Bayt Muslims protest in multiple cities
- Latest: Fobnimo Till I Dhimo
-
