He was once introduced as "The ex husband of Ilhan Omar", literllay everyone knows him as such.
View attachment 248025
If we shouldn't listen to the scholars then who? Should we listen to you? What rights are being taken away? Women's right made up by who? Or our Allah given rights in Islam? I have to remind people like you that there is nothing stopping you or any female from becoming a scholar. Nothing is stopping you from memorizing the quran, reading the tafsiir, reading the ahadith. My favorite sahabi is Aisha Radiyallahu Anha. Why? Because she is a rolemodel for every female. When I talk about what kind of wife I want? I picture an Aisha, a modest female, a knowledgeable female who I don't have to remind but have to be reminded. The reason why people like you don't want to study the faith is because it will prove you wrong. It will change your mindset.You are seriously unhinged.
Because of some "scholars" deciding that women will get distracted by a new husband the ex should have custody? Keep in mind there isn't always a consensus between scholars as well.
Get out of here. Any woman that falls for that bull is basically giving her rights away. I dislike it when some of you try to use religion to abuse and control women. There's a reason why the Western world is the best at championing women's rights currently...
No. He is actually a Muslim. That is thumbs up. May Allah guide her and her family.She really marry a kaafir ?
Thats just a personal no no. I wouldn't want my kids to be with my ex wife if she marries another male.Firstly, whilst the father has more rights in Islam after the mother’s re-marriage, It isn’t set in stone as the father can decide he doesn’t want to take on the custody.
There is nothing in Islam to suggest that parents can’t come up with their own arrangements. In many cases fathers simply prefer the mother keeps the kids and that is halal.
Also, some scholars such as Ibn Hazim believed the mother has more rights to custody with many others believing that custody instead goes to the Grandmother, the mothers mother. Hence, it’s a lot more complicated. In fact, the Hanafis, Shafis and Malikis believe it’s mother to grandmother, the mother’s mother. That is why in Somali culture, you see grandmothers raising kids a lot.
Secondly, step-fathers in Islam are not ‘strange’, they actually become Mahram to the daughters/kids of a woman. Therefore, Islamically you’re wrong. A step father having his arms around his Mahram step-daughter isn’t haram. I don’t know why you’re positioning it in that way. In fact, he is allowed to take her to Umrah, hajj ect as he is her Mahram.
ExactlyIts very dangerous and we know many sexual molesting cases are from ex wives being negligent with their ex’s children and allowing them too intermingle with a foreign man. Its the great wisdom of Islam too allow the father to take the children to a neutral household like his grandmother…
in Islam when you marry a women you become mahram to her daughtersIts very dangerous and we know many sexual molesting cases are from ex wives being negligent with their ex’s children and allowing them too intermingle with a foreign man. Its the great wisdom of Islam too allow the father to take the children to a neutral household like his grandmother…
Yep, that is a personal preference.Thats just a personal no no. I wouldn't want my kids to be with my ex wife if she marries another male.
Its very dangerous and we know many sexual molesting cases are from ex wives being negligent with their ex’s children and allowing them too intermingle with a foreign man. Its the great wisdom of Islam too allow the father to take the children to a neutral household like his grandmother…
I think their is alot to unpack in this topic, I know a man becomes mahram to his wifes daughters when he gets married,Yep, that is a personal preference.
I heard stories aren't really good enouhg for this topic, I know people who were raped by fmaily members. Unless your telling me you know the guy and he was a completely normal guy, this can't be used as evidence ot scaremonger peopleYou don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
I agree, I can see it would be a worry for any man. But the issue is that kids usually spend more time with their female parent. Hence, If the father takes custody, they will not spend that much time with their fathers. It would be a step-mother raising them. Do you think a child will get the mercy of a mother from a woman who didn’t birth them? Early classical scholars realized that, which is why they believed that a grandmother should step in before the father. Whilst grandmothers didn’t birth the child, they’re a second mother, the closest to a hooyo. There are no Hadiths that say grandmothers get more of a right than fathers, but it is the basic knowledge that children need a mother figure more when they’re at a certain age.I think their is alot to unpack in this topic, I know a man becomes mahram to his wifes daughters when he gets married,
but in our current day and age their are some people who say their is data to show children with step parents have a steep increase in sexual assualt cases, having your young daughter around a strange man would be a concern for most parents. Now their are multiple factors effected this, but the main one is thetype of man your ex-wife marries, if he is going to be around your daughter, you would like to know who this man is, also if you trust your ex-wife enough to make a good decision when marrying a man
From the research I have seen their are conflicting views, and this article states https://www.goodtherapy.org/blog/stepchildren-family-parents-abuse-0409132 that having a step parent doesn't increase a childs sexual abuse rate at all, rather it is based on socioeconomic factors.
Really, it is up to the father. If a father goes to an Islamic courts, upon hearing the mother has re-married, he can petition the courts and he will be the one that gets custody according to Salafis and some Hanbalis and other madhabs say that the kids would straight to the grandmother if they’re younger.If a women marries a good normal man, then she should be completely fine, Islam tells us the reality of the situation, and if marrying a women makes her daughters mahram to you, then it should be fine. If a extreme situation happens where the wife or former husband is suspicious of the step-parent, and showing signs they may be abusing the child, then this rule will be overid as the man is sick in the heart.
Honestly, only a minority of mothers. Seriously, a woman is more obsessed with her kids than a father. Allah has given a natural intuition when it comes to their child. The instinct a mother has isn’t what a man has usually. Also, kids do get abused by uncles and cousins right under the nose of BOTH parents with the abo around, so I wouldn’t put it down to that. It’s sickening when you see how many children are abused by male relatives and the father has no clue as well.It is a genuine concern for alot of men to be protective over theur daughters, and alot of the time women can not see the warning signs of a predatory man compared to another man.
You hit the nail on the head. Even uncles can be a worry and that is a family blood Mahram. The sibling of the mum or dad and there are a lot of cases. Scary Wallahi.That being said, we live in a sick society, where even own family members abuse children, so it shouldn't be just in the case the step-parents to worry about but everyone. Their are alot of predators out their and it is always good to be careful, but if the man is a good man, you shouldn't worry too much, especialy if you trust your ex-wife
My overall point, even if the father has custody he would still need to get to know the step father as obviously, the mother will have visitation rights and the kids will be able to stay with her. He can’t stop a child from seeing their own mother so he will still have do his due diligence.Some articles which discuss this
Child abuse is 40 times more likely when single parents find new partners
Here are three steps to protect the childrenwww.phillyvoice.com
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
YH my point wasn't about time, I think the child should always spend more time with the mother, and depending on how old they are, if the husband is remarried, the child may be able to readjust to having a step parent, and the timings will differ, but this isnt a black and white topic, it is a grey area, everyone has their own life dynamics, their isn't one answer in terms of timing.But the issue is that kids usually spend more time with their female parent. Hence, If the father takes custody, they will not spend that much time with their fathers. It would be a step-mother raising them. Do you think a child will get the mercy of a mother from a woman who didn’t birth them? Early classical scholars realized that, which is why they believed that a grandmother should step in before the father. Whilst grandmothers didn’t birth the child, they’re a second mother, the closest to a hooyo. There are no Hadiths that say grandmothers get more of a right than fathers, but it is the basic knowledge that children need a mother figure more when they’re at a certain age.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Let’s not be too dramatic. We don’t know if he has the kids on the weekends and if Ilhan and him have an understanding in place as to how involved the step-father can be.I hope he learns from his mistakes as a father, I would suffocate if a random man was playing daddy to my own children nacalaa. He is a who abandoned his kids to a random. Man didn’t even bother to take 1-2 kids custody.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
His kids are mostly grown enough, I would understand if the kids were under 10 year olds but they aren’t. I know fathers who took the oldest kids or the sons, he could have done that.Let’s not be too dramatic. We don’t know if he has the kids on the weekends and if Ilhan and him have an understanding in place as to how involved the step-father can be.
At the end of the day, it’s the mother that does all the day to day nurturing and raising not many men are willing to take all of that on. Usually, it’s left to the step-mother.
At that age, kids can choose tbh. They’re able to voice their preferences.His kids are mostly grown enough, I would understand if the kids were under 10 year olds but they aren’t. I know fathers who took the oldest kids or the sons, he could have done that.