The whole place is crawling with Zios
You can’t question Sahih cause it don’t sit right with youAishas age upon marriage to our beloved Prophet SAW is one of the biggest issues damaging our faith.
I personally believe the hadith about her age upon marriage is not true and it has been fabricated for some reason, most popular reason being political (amplifying Aishas virginity) but many believe it to be true for the sake of preserving authenticity of hadiths.
However I do believe she got married young, from 15-18.
The originator of the infamous hadith, Hisham Ibn Urwah was first a reliable narrator but after becoming old was deemed unreliable narrator by Ya'qub bin Shayba and reportedly also by his student, Malik Ibn Anas. Browsing through the net I haven’t found good sourcers for these claims and I do not understand arabic so I can’t read arabic sources.
Why not, its not the Quran.You can’t question Sahih cause it don’t sit right with you![]()
I don’t think it’s that much of a problem tbh, it was just a practice of those times, my non Muslim friends ask me about it, I tell them straight, it was a practice of those days, even the Christians and Jews of that were known to marry at that age. However there’s no need for it in the modern day and we’ve progressed well over a thousand years from that time.Aishas age upon marriage to our beloved Prophet SAW is one of the biggest issues damaging our faith.
I personally believe the hadith about her age upon marriage is not true and it has been fabricated for some reason, most popular reason being political (amplifying Aishas virginity) but many believe it to be true for the sake of preserving authenticity of hadiths.
However I do believe she got married young, from 15-18.
The originator of the infamous hadith, Hisham Ibn Urwah was first a reliable narrator but after becoming old was deemed unreliable narrator by Ya'qub bin Shayba and reportedly also by his student, Malik Ibn Anas. Browsing through the net I haven’t found good sourcers for these claims and I do not understand arabic so I can’t read arabic sources.
No, you can't "affirm" this, you're not a woman. When I had my first period (and i started mine late) i was still very childlike physically and mentally, certainly not ready for marriage. Same with all the other girls I know.View attachment 333598
Hijab had to defend it cause kaffir used this Hadith. Even I will affirm that a girl become a women at menstruation. That’s the Muslim position.![]()
From an Islamic and jurisprudential perspective it is legal but morally it’s unacceptable in this day and age. I can see people a thousand years ago marrying underage but there’s been a thousand years of progress in which people live longer and have access to medicine and treatment, therefore there wouldn’t be a need to marry underage.
View attachment 333598
Hijab had to defend it cause kaffir used this Hadith. Even I will affirm that a girl become a women at menstruation. That’s the Muslim position.![]()
The whole place is crawling with Zios