One week after the fight

Status
Not open for further replies.

Saalax Bidaar

Truthfulness so often goes with ruthlessness
How can it subjugate anyone with Toyatas and ak47s , a full scale war can't be ever undertaken by somaliland because it doesn't have the resources nor the man power to last more than 3 months in battle.

You don’t know that, but I do. I studied a lot of this stuff. Somaliland can take over Puntland but not vice versa, of course is not gonna be easy and would require full effort and United front and strong leadership

FYI I am not advocating for violence just speculating
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
It's not about retaking LA, Puntland can do that with the utmost ease. The difficulty is maintaining a working administration. There's a lot of internal power struggle and Puntland is seen as an ally of the most dominant faction.
 

Saalax Bidaar

Truthfulness so often goes with ruthlessness
It's not about retaking LA, Puntland can do that with the utmost ease. The difficulty is maintaining a working administration. There's a lot of internal power struggle and Puntland is seen as an ally of the most dominant faction.

Or how much Gaas is willing to commit to recovering LA? One thing is for certain, it won’t be easy.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
Or how much Gaas is willing to commit to recovering LA? One thing is for certain, it won’t be easy.

The last week war showed that Puntland is militarily superior than SL in Sool and SL was close to being wiped out if it wasn't for Jamac Siyad militia that saved their asses. As soon as JS entered battlefield, PL stopped their attack as they don't want to lose the hearts and minds of certain Dhulbahante.

Puntland needs a different mindset if they want to take LA. They shouldn't view it as a liberation but conquering land from opposing factions whether they are Harti or shisheeye.
 
Last edited:

Saalax Bidaar

Truthfulness so often goes with ruthlessness
The last week war showed that Puntland is militarily superior than SL in Sool and SL was close to being wiped out if it wasn't for Jamac Siyad militia that saved their asses. As soon as JS entered battlefield, PL stopped their attack as they don't want to lose the hearts and minds of certain Dhulbahante.

Puntland needs a different mindset if they want to take LA. They shouldn't view it as a liberation but conquering land from opposing factions whether they are Harti or shisheeye.

Last week war showed that despite 4 months of planning, coordinating, gathering of intelligence, weapons , and supplies Puntland still failed to accomplish their main objective, capture of Tukaraq.

All reports indicate that initially, Puntland’Southern flank( Hawd Side) was successful but immediate reinforcement from SL troops stationed Back rendered that attack useless.

Mahad Canbaashe captured the tank and killed the POWs as previously reported but now they are denying and saying Jamac Siyaad had nothing to do with capturing of the tank or killing of the prisoner of war.

All in all, War was costly for Both sides particularly Puntland since they lost a lot of men for no gain, whatsoever.

Militarily speaking Puntland has the home field advantage because of the location(deep within Harti land)Obvious divisions within SL lines, all those should translate to victory for Puntland yet it hasn’t .

That is a failure imo.
 

Factz

Factzopedia
VIP
You don’t know that, but I do. I studied a lot of this stuff. Somaliland can take over Puntland but not vice versa, of course is not gonna be easy and would require full effort and United front and strong leadership

FYI I am not advocating for violence just speculating

The truth is ina abti that if Somaliland were to invade and colonize all of Puntland. Puntland and it's people would cry to the U.N which would affect our recognition and also, sanction us but your right Somaliland does have the capability of doing that.

Somaliland can even capture and destroy Garowe with eas but that would damage our reputation to the world leaders so Muuse Biixi will play smart by closing the borders of Bari and Nugaal very soon after Ramadan ends, inshallah.
 
The reality is the border is 5 miles outside garowe...if we want to secure the border your going to have to ANNEX garowe. That's a fact.

For security reasons garowe must be neutralized in order to main a safe border...ethier they do it peacefully or somaliland annexes garowe...

I don't buy the argument of UN sanctions. We ain't even a member of the UN.

All we do is explain to donor friendly countries. This is the border of Somaliland, same border as somalia djibouti Ethiopia as per colonialism.

We need garowe to secure our eastern border from ISIS attacks....

No one will care...trust me.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
Last week war showed that despite 4 months of planning, coordinating, gathering of intelligence, weapons , and supplies Puntland still failed to accomplish their main objective, capture of Tukaraq.

All reports indicate that initially, Puntland’Southern flank( Hawd Side) was successful but immediate reinforcement from SL troops stationed Back rendered that attack useless.

Mahad Canbaashe captured the tank and killed the POWs as previously reported but now they are denying and saying Jamac Siyaad had nothing to do with capturing of the tank or killing of the prisoner of war.

All in all, War was costly for Both sides particularly Puntland since they lost a lot of men for no gain, whatsoever.

Militarily speaking Puntland has the home field advantage because of the location(deep within Harti land)Obvious divisions within SL lines, all those should translate to victory for Puntland yet it hasn’t .

That is a failure imo.

Lol no tank was captured no matter how often you repeat.

Anyways if you think PL planned for months than you're ciyaal mama who's new to fkd. Yes PL buffered up but it was SL that brought their finest commanders to frontline. The highest SL general, Gen. Taani, is in Soil and was in Tukaraq the day the fight took place. PLs highest general, gen Siciid Dheere is not leading the forces. Col. Carays is still guarding the southern front in Mudug. Believe me if PL brought its best those two would be in Tukaraq.

SL is chased out of Tukaraq, that's indication who won the first round.
 
Abdalla is lying again. The lost tank caused upset and anger within the ranks to the point of finger pointing.

Everybody knows it. Abdalla is being cynical here where it borders to sheer idiocy trying to hold on to a lie when overwhelmingly it has been proven the tank was taken and captured in the offensive last Tuesday.

Also Puntland did not reach what it set out to achieve.

The talk is now of how can we return the tank rather on how can we take back the land.
 
Jaamac Siyaad elders distancing themselves from the captured tank saying it was not their clan and no reprisals should take place against them saying the Jaamac Siyaad men who took pictures with the tank did not represent the Jaamac Siyaad subclan

 
32489266_2053887037974364_3637674778149519360_n.jpg
 

Factz

Factzopedia
VIP
The reality is the border is 5 miles outside garowe...if we want to secure the border your going to have to ANNEX garowe. That's a fact.

For security reasons garowe must be neutralized in order to main a safe border...ethier they do it peacefully or somaliland annexes garowe...

I don't buy the argument of UN sanctions. We ain't even a member of the UN.

All we do is explain to donor friendly countries. This is the border of Somaliland, same border as somalia djibouti Ethiopia as per colonialism.

We need garowe to secure our eastern border from ISIS attacks....

No one will care...trust me.

Again, if we attack Garowe then our reputation by the world leaders will be ruined since we are known to be a peaceful and kind nation and it will affect our quest for recognition so it's not worth it.

Somaliland simply needs to build multiple military bases in eastern Sanaag and eastern Sool to secure the eastern borders of Somaliland. It's that simple since we have a much bigger and equipped army of course.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
Abdalla is lying again. The lost tank caused upset and anger within the ranks to the point of finger pointing.

Everybody knows it. Abdalla is being cynical here where it borders to sheer idiocy trying to hold on to a lie when overwhelmingly it has been proven the tank was taken and captured in the offensive last Tuesday.

Also Puntland did not reach what it set out to achieve.

The talk is now of how can we return the tank rather on how can we take back the land.

Go watch shiine culay and Kaligii duul fb pages. You lost all credibility
 

Cotton Eyed Joe

More law, less justice.
VIP
Over the past few months Puntland only reinforced their position outside Tukaraq but it was Somaliland who was quick to attack the encroaching forces and expecting no response which has resulted in them losing the town which is now controlled by neither party as well as 3 times the number of Puntland. A major factor for Puntland's unusual response was that it was Jeegaan troops including their leader Mr Tani who conspicuously fled to Laascaanood as soon as the battle began.

But @Abdalla point still stands, if it wasn't for the Laascaanood reinforcements the Jeegaan troops would have been wiped out and sent to an early grave along with their commander Colonel Daauud ala yaraxma. That's when the battle came to an end hence the positive response from the Jamac Siyad elders.
 
Abdalla it is you who lost credibility lying through your teeth while everyone acknowledges what took place.

I don't know why you go all to the length to hide the truth. It speaks about you and lack of character.
 

Factz

Factzopedia
VIP
Abdalla it is you who lost credibility lying through your teeth while everyone acknowledges what took place.

I don't know why you go all to the length to hide the truth. It speaks about you and lack of character.

You're an honest Majerteen even in the month of Ramadan which makes you a great Muslim indeed. I have respect for people like you wallahi.

The ones who are compulsive liars like these two have an inferiority complex and they think lying will make them feel better. I mean these two people were the same people that said that Puntland took over Tukaraq and now they made another excuse. They come up with new lies every time. They are truly pathetic, it's best not to waste your energy on detritus people.
 
Facts thanks walaal. The truth eventually comes out at the end. First it was 'victory' and that 'Tukaraq is liberated'.

I outlined the truth that both sides are at the outsides of the town and that neither controlled the town. I also clarified that the tank was captured from Puntland. I did a fact check when the two narratives did not correlate while they were pushing another narrative of 'total victory and annihilation'.

Slowly after I did that their version align with my intervention last week.
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
Abdalla it is you who lost credibility lying through your teeth while everyone acknowledges what took place.

I don't know why you go all to the length to hide the truth. It speaks about you and lack of character.

You're speaking of outrage about a supposed tank that was lost, yet there's not a shred of evidence that the said community is mourning.

The secessionists and the red eyed mooryaans accuse me of lying when I corner them. I take being called a liar by certain folks as a badge of honour. Your allies are the likes of Facts who is on YouTube harassing a 13 year old girl.

I advise you to go to shiine culay and Kaligii duul and steal from their content
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Top