Puntland has the lowest Poverty incidence of Somalia [incl. Somaliland]

Status
Not open for further replies.

Cotton Eyed Joe

More law, less justice.
VIP
I knew that moryaan was lying, he made up figures ya Allah we live in grave times this xoolo have no shame.

735.gif
 

Thegoodshepherd

Galkacyo iyo Calula dhexdood
VIP
If you include sool and sanaag into Somaliland as it is in this survey then Puntland gets more per capita

Why would you assume that the aid Puntland gets is not also for Sool and Sanaag? Puntland gets a lot of aid that goes to Sanaag and Sool. The biggest project currently being funded by Puntland is the Ceeldaahir road in Sanaag.
 

Cotton Eyed Joe

More law, less justice.
VIP
What's gonna be ur new argument if I give u the source, u seem scared, are u sure u want me to give u wut u want:lolbron:
Indulge me. It's not even in the report will you come with a better source than the World Bank? I love how the censored just co-signed it like it was a fact.

jck.gif
 

Abdalla

Medical specialist in diagnosing Majeerteentitis
Prof.Dr.Eng.
VIP
Even so, the sample population is way to small. 4k house holds let's say on average have 5 persons, that's 20k out of population of roughly 15million( SL+Somalia). That is hardly representative. That's 0.001% that they're working with. I'd wait for more comprehensive studies before jumping the gun

You have no clue how statistical power and sample size interact. :gucciwhat:

Again study this table

xqwyIwa.png
 
Why would you assume that the aid Puntland gets is not also for Sool and Sanaag? Puntland gets a lot of aid that goes to Sanaag and Sool. The biggest project currently being funded by Puntland is the Ceeldaahir road in Sanaag.
But if we're comparing poverty based on the borders in this survey then sool & sanaag is part of SL.

If they were included as part of PL then the results will be entirely different.
 

Thegoodshepherd

Galkacyo iyo Calula dhexdood
VIP
But if we're comparing poverty based on the borders in this survey then sool & sanaag is part of SL.

If they were included as part of PL then the results will be entirely different.

But the results are already very different. Northeast includes all of South Mudug. My state of North Mudug is probably as well off as Nugaal but is being dragged down by having its score be averaged with South Mudug.

@XamarCade no one in the survey mentions foreign aid as a significant source of income. The NGOs in Somalia are very corrupt, barely any of the money you mentioned actually reaches the people. Puntland and Banadir have a difference in per capita income of over $300 dollars. Even If we were to accept your 2 year data for foreign aid, that would only explain about 20% of the disparity!

sl0sKSn.jpg
 
But the results are already very different. Northeast includes all of South Mudug. My state of North Mudug is probably as well off as Nugaal but is being dragged down by having its score be averaged with South Mudug.

@XamarCade no one in the survey mentions foreign aid as a significant source of income. The NGOs in Somalia are very corrupt, barely any of the money you mentioned actually reaches the people. Puntland and Banadir have a difference in per capita income of over $300 dollars. Even If we were to accept your 2 year data for foreign aid, that would only explain about 20% of the disparity!

sl0sKSn.jpg
foreign aid is what helps boost the economy and income b/c reer PL with it's small population don't have to worry about building institutions while getting huge boost of aid, even tho the aid isn't included as income to the families in this report the PL gov don't have to worry about the costs such as health, security, education and other institutions cause it's already covered in the aid, and Actually the NGO's recieves $303,896,000 in aid from 2015-2017 they're classified as unattributed and they have their own separate category and not included into the regions aid distribution (but I do agree that they're very corrupt)
 

xisaabiye

Ibnu Suxuufi Ibnu Al Dhoobe
Somalia had a population of 12.3 million as of 2014. To have a representative sample with a confidence of 99%, you would only need 4k people.

You need to take stats classes from doktor @Abdalla.

:mjcry:

Bruh Stats for the most part is b.s, that's the first thing I learned whilst studying it in uni ages ago.

No sane person would accept 0.001% as a whole truth, it's a fraction of a fraction of a percent:pachah1:
 

xisaabiye

Ibnu Suxuufi Ibnu Al Dhoobe
foreign aid is what helps boost the economy and income b/c reer PL with it's small population don't have to worry about building institutions while getting huge boost of aid, even tho the aid isn't included as income to the families in this report the PL gov don't have to worry about the costs such as health, security, education and other institutions cause it's already covered in the aid, and Actually the NGO's recieves $303,896,000 in aid from 2015-2017 they're classified as unattributed and they have their own separate category and not included into the regions aid distribution (but I do agree that they're very corrupt)

To call PL a small population isn't it, it's a sub sub sub sub clan based population:icon lol:. It's like SL being sparsely populated by my subclan alone & receiving relatively close to as much aid as the rest of the somali populace

If they conducted this stat based on 0.001% of the entire somali race, how many fractions of a percent do you think represents MJ in this sample:pachah1:
 
To call PL a small population isn't it, it's a sub sub sub sub clan based population:icon lol:. It's like SL being sparsely populated by my subclan alone & receiving relatively close to as much aid as the rest of the somali populace

If they conducted this stat based on 0.001% of the entire somali race, how many fractions of a percent do you think represents MJ in this sample:pachah1:
These are the same ppl that told the Italians they made up the majority of the Somali population :drakekidding:
 

Arma

GRAND Wizard of MJ SIXIIR
VIP
Lol at the level of bitter butthurt from HAGites and Samosa boys. Love it when, IRIR have their knickers in a twist.
 

xisaabiye

Ibnu Suxuufi Ibnu Al Dhoobe
These are the same ppl that told the Italians they made up the majority of the Somali population :drakekidding:
If I conducted a survey in SL asking if they would reunite with Somalia & I told you based on my studies 90% said yes. Then I continued to inform you that I covered 0.001% of the population, would you
a) sing somaliyey tooso in public while cooking cambuulo in Burco:cosbyhmm:
b) sing somaliyey tooso in private while remaining somewhat hopeful of unity in your heart:cosbyhmm:
c) sing qabiilkeyga hatooso knowing 0.001% isn't represtative of population :cosbyhmm:
 
Status
Not open for further replies.

Trending

Latest posts

Top