Puntland has the lowest Poverty incidence of Somalia [incl. Somaliland]

[Bahal]

Anyone want to give me the tldr

 

[XamarCade]

No one will take you seriously until you post the source of that data.

http://somaliaaidflows.so

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

Anyone want to give me the tldr

You have been missed. It all started when I posted a World Bank study that showed Puntland had the lowest rate of poverty in Somalia, even lower than that of Ethiopia. I summarized the study in this thread, it is the tl;dr.

https://www.somalispot.com/threads/huge-world-bank-poverty-survey.31811/

 

[Bahal]

You have been missed. It all started when I posted a World Bank study that showed Puntland had the lowest rate of poverty in Somalia, even lower than that of Ethiopia. I summarized the study in this thread, it is the tl;dr.

https://www.somalispot.com/threads/huge-world-bank-poverty-survey.31811/

Thank you, I was scandalously banned.

Very interesting, congrats to Reer PL

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

http://somaliaaidflows.so

Hirshabelle+Galmudug 2015-2017: $188 million
Puntland 2015-2017: $238.5 million

$238.5 - $188= $50.5 million is what Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug over 3 years. $50.5/3 is about $17 million.

That is a difference of about $17 million a year that Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug although it has more people than both combined.
Our friend @XamarCade wants to use this $17 million, which is 1% Puntland's gdp, to explain the disparity in rates of poverty. Keep in mind that the gap in per capita income between Mogadishu and Puntland is a whopping $300.

 

[Abdalla]

Does that make my statement any less true that 0.001% of the population was covered

No it does not you idiot. The 4k household sample size can be projected to predict for 900k households, which is 70+% of the entire total households in every region. Likewise the the 21k sample size is representative for 12 million people.

The irony is that the writer of the World bank survey has a bachelors, masters and a phd in statistics.

 

[XamarCade]

Hirshabelle+Galmudug 2015-2017: $188 million
Puntland 2015-2017: $238.5 million

$238.5 - $188= $50.5 million is what Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug over 3 years. $50.5/3 is about $17 million.

That is a difference of about $17 million a year that Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug although it has more people than both combined.
Our friend @XamarCade wants to use this $17 million, which is 1% Puntland's gdp, to explain the disparity in rates of poverty. Keep in mind that the gap in per capita income between Mogadishu and Puntland is a whopping $300.

PL has more population than GM and HS kulaha lol, even SW with more population gets less than half of wut u get,

 

[Abdalla]

Hirshabelle+Galmudug 2015-2017: $188 million
Puntland 2015-2017: $238.5 million

$238.5 - $188= $50.5 million is what Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug over 3 years. $50.5/3 is about $17 million.

That is a difference of about $17 million a year that Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug although it has more people than both combined.
Our friend @XamarCade wants to use this $17 million, which is 1% Puntland's gdp, to explain the disparity in rates of poverty. Keep in mind that the gap in per capita income between Mogadishu and Puntland is a whopping $300.

Great way to use his own numbers against him. Puntland outdid SL and Mogadishu with a 40+% margin in almost everything. Surely that's not because of receiving 17 million a year more than the rest

@XamarCade esteemed and beloved Sheikh, please stick to tafsir. That's your expertise

 

[XamarCade]

Great way to use his own numbers against him. Puntland outdid SL and Mogadishu with a 40+% margin in almost everything. Surely that's not because of receiving 17 million a year more than the rest

@XamarCade esteemed and beloved Sheikh, please stick to tafsir. That's your expertise

Being a small numbered region with the highest aid isn't anything to be proud of, it's embarrassing

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

Great way to use his own numbers against him. Puntland outdid SL and Mogadishu with a 40+% margin in almost everything. Surely that's not because of receiving 17 million a year more than the rest

@XamarCade esteemed and beloved Sheikh, please stick to tafsir. That's your expertise

It is not funny though, I was angry reading that website. The donor money is being given to Hirshabelle+Galmudug on the basis of clan. They don't control 60% or more of their territory. This means that about 50% of Hirshabelle+Galmudug's population is receiving as much money as all of Puntland.

 

[Yonis]

Hirshabelle+Galmudug 2015-2017: $188 million
Puntland 2015-2017: $238.5 million

$238.5 - $188= $50.5 million is what Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug over 3 years. $50.5/3 is about $17 million.

That is a difference of about $17 million a year that Puntland gets more than Hirshabelle+Galmudug although it has more people than both combined.
Our friend @XamarCade wants to use this $17 million, which is 1% Puntland's gdp, to explain the disparity in rates of poverty. Keep in mind that the gap in per capita income between Mogadishu and Puntland is a whopping $300.

 

[Abdalla]

Being a small numbered region with the highest aid isn't anything to be proud of, it's embarrassing

You're all over the place, recollect yourself. Have an ounce of redeeming quality.

It is not funny though, I was angry reading that website. The donor money is being given to Hirshabelle+Galmudug on the basis of clan. They don't control 60% or more of their territory. This means that about 50% of Hirshabelle+Galmudug's population is receiving as much money as all of Puntland.

If you add what Banadir gets, on clan level, Hawiye receive way more aid than everyone else.

 

[XamarCade]

You're all over the place, ecollect yourself. Have an ounce of redeeming quality.



If you add what Banadir gets, on clan level, Hawiye receive way more aid thank everyone else.

Sheikh Honorable Abdalla, if u go by clan, Darood recieves 411mill and Hawiye+DM combined recieves 446mil

 

[Bernie Madoff]

Damn look how low we become. Comparing which tuulo has less poverty

While bantus are sending satellites into space

 

[xisaabiye]

No it does not you idiot. The 4k household sample size can be projected to predict for 900k households, which is 70+% of the entire total households in every region. Likewise the the 21k sample size is representative for 12 million people.

The irony is that the writer of the World bank survey has a bachelors, masters and a phd in statistics.

Bruh I don't care if dude is Einstien, I have a diploma, bachelors & masters in engineering that doesn't mean shit. The fact is the sample size is 0.001% of the entire somali populace. It's a good benchmark for future data collection that's about it

 

[Shades]

Damn look how low we become. Comparing which tuulo has less poverty

While bantus are sending satellites into space

It's always good to compete on quality of life, especially on state levels, america does it too, it's not good to be mean spirited about it, but its to encourage other states to do better.

 

[BANTU]

I saw more beggars in Hargeisa.

Your soldiers are literally beggars

Setting up isbaaro in "clean" Garoowe and taking over government buildings

 

[sanger]

From 2015-2017:

Puntland recieves $238,594,000 in aid
Benadir recieves $140,900,000 in aid
Hirshabelle recieves $107,066,000 in aid
Galmudug receives $80,694,000 in aid
Jubaland recieves $173,757,000 in aid
Southwest recieves $118,900,000 in aid
Somaliland recieves $371,315,000 in aid

Sources?

 

[waraabe]

guys why you taking punanis seriously? they print fake money and dont pay their soldiers :siilaanyolaugh:

 

[Thegoodshepherd]

guys why you taking punanis seriously? they print fake money and dont pay their soldiers :siilaanyolaugh:

Bosaso a city in the middle of the desert that gets less than 50mm of rain a year is better off than Hargeisa that gets more than 500mm of rain a year. Hurts don't it?