Should the federal states each secede?

[Hubble]

Raxanweyn can have af Maay as a nation language. This will require Bakool Sare (Minority Sare) to liquidise, move to Jubaland.

Jubaland can have it's own country bordering Kenya and Ethiopia seeing as their meddling is practically occupation now.

Somaliland will finally get the recognition they've longed for.

Puntland has independence sentiments, not much of an issue here and they'll finally have a real border with Galmudud.

Galmudug will need to have a pact with the Mx there (Out of Place Sare) and put the civil war mentality to rest

Hiiraan and Middle Shabeele secede. Make billions a year from selling agricultural produce to dry Somali regions. Make a pact with DDSI over dam.

Benadir becomes it's own country.

 

[Canuck]

The world would not allow 7 or 8 countries of same people religion and shared history all waiting for aid nope I do not think so. The borders lines were done all time ago for certain reasons and suddenly they would not change them

 

[Hubble]

The world would not allow 7 or 8 countries of same people religion and shared history all waiting for aid nope I do not think so. The borders lines were done all time ago for certain reasons and suddenly they would not change them

What's your solution to our clan crisis?

 

[Canuck]

What's your solution to our clan crisis?

Stop meddling from neighbours let Amisom leave the country and replace them IF it needed with PL / GL defence and Algeria Mauritania Egypt army.

 

[Hubble]

Stop meddling from neighbours let Amisom leave the country and replace them IF it needed with PL / GL defence and Algeria Mauritania Egypt army.

And the clan hatred?

 

[TheSayid]

this wouldn't help everyone,jubaland for example might still have clan issues considering its so diverse,same with shabeele regions.., if we're gonna secede i think it would be somaliland, puntland somalia(south of galkacyo).

 

[Hubble]

this wouldn't help everyone,jubaland for example might still have clan issues considering its so diverse,same with shabeele regions.., if we're gonna secede i think it would be somaliland, puntland somalia(south of galkacyo).

The South is the place which can't live as one. They can move to the states where their clan is the majority, the land is big enough for all.

 

[waraabe]

Lol you people never cease to amaze me.

Somalia gobols won't be allowed to split

Somaliland is a nation that joined somalia to form the somali republic.

It would mean awdal should be it's own country, Togdheer, saahil etc
.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

I was once a die hard midnimada somalia waa muqadaas camp, no more. I will vote for PL independence in a heartbeat

Inshallah one day

 

[legend]

There is no way that the world will accept another balkanisation specially in a country like Somalia, it will just cause more problems.

The only solution for Somalia is this federal model, let each state govern their territory and let's just all move on, that's where we are heading now anyway.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

Somalia is a colonial project and we were always independent from one another.

 

[Hassan Garguute Buldanana]

There is no way that the world will accept another balkanisation specially in a country like Somalia, it will just cause more problems.

The only solution for Somalia is this federal model, let each state govern their territory and let's just all move on, that's where we are heading now anyway.

I can live with full autonomy for now

 

[TheSayid]

The South is the place which can't live as one. They can move to the states where their clan is the majority, the land is big enough for all.

i doubt they will be willing to leave that easily... telling hawyie to leave shabeele would be impossible,it might start more wars in the south as every clan is trying to carve out its own independent nation.

 

[Hubble]

i doubt they will be willing to leave that easily... telling hawyie to leave shabeele would be impossible,it might start more wars in the south as every clan is trying to carve out its own independent nation.

Which Shabeele? I don't even know which non Hawiye clans live there besides Madow and smaller minorities.

 

[Hubble]

Lol you people never cease to amaze me.

Somalia gobols won't be allowed to split

Somaliland is a nation that joined somalia to form the somali republic.

It would mean awdal should be it's own country, Togdheer, saahil etc
.

They're not gobols, they're two or more gobols which form a state. Similar to Somaliland but colonized by the same power which means nothing now.

 

[TheSayid]

Which Shabeele? I don't even know which non Hawiye clans live there besides Madow and smaller minorities.

i believe theres been clashes between habar gidir and biyomaal over the years in lower shabeele.

 

[waraabe]

They're not gobols, they're two or more gobols which form a state. Similar to Somaliland but colonized by the same power which means nothing now.

Well it isn't like somaliland but somalia italia can do whatever it wants.

Somaliland is trying to regain sovereignty

 

[Hubble]

i believe theres been clashes between habar gidir and biyomaal over the years in lower shabeele.

Biyomaal have the right to lower Shabeele, Habar Gidir should move to Benadir or Galguduud.

 

[AceofSom]

This is what you get when ciyaal discuss somali politics y

 

[Hubble]

This is what you get when ciyaal discuss somali politics y

You're into qabiil like real bad, I made this for people like you. It's the final solution. Don't act like Somalia is united, it's not.