Should women be in the army??

[Odious Delirium]

She participated in numerous battles alongside the prophet.

idk where this narrative came from but women where never enlisted to fight on the frontline by the prophet they only came as medics, cooks and moral support etc

rare occasions where brave women took up arms in desperate scenarios isn't the rule and the prophet never made any woman fight.

nearly all instances of sahabiyat partaking in battle was once men breached the lines and tired to attack the women and children like the battle of the trenches when the men where fending off the siege and the jews tried to attack from behind to capture the women. in this instance one sahabiyah killed a jew and threw his body off the fort making the jews think that part of the muslim army had stayed behind to defend the forts so they ran away.

those few throughout muslim history that did fight on the frontline hid there identities so as not to be sent away. this was the case across all history in general up until modern times.

 

[Yaraye]

what woman wants to be a soilder anyways?

 

[Waa dhamatay]

In this instance one sahabiyah killed a jew and threw his body off the fort making the jews think that part of the muslim army had stayed behind to defend the forts so they ran away.

Blessed tactics

 

[Periplus]

idk where this narrative came from but women where never enlisted to fight on the frontline by the prophet they only came as medics, cooks and moral support etc

rare occasions where brave women took up arms in desperate scenarios isn't the rule and the prophet never made any woman fight.

nearly all instances of sahabiyat partaking in battle was once men breached the lines and tired to attack the women and children like the battle of the trenches when the men where fending off the siege and the jews tried to attack from behind to capture the women. in this instance one sahabiyah killed a jew and threw his body off the fort making the jews think that part of the muslim army had stayed behind to defend the forts so they ran away.

those few throughout muslim history that did fight on the frontline hid there identities so as not to be sent away. this was the case across all history in general up until modern times.

 

[cooli3o]

View attachment 280613

so we know 2 times at most, even then the ahaadeeth may not even be authentic
still doesn't prove anything, its one women in 2 battles,
so point still stands

 

[Periplus]

Quote your evidence

Go read about the battle of uhud lmao

 

[Odious Delirium]

View attachment 280613

In my reading of the authentic seerah of the prophet according to the ahadeeth I never came across this narration.
This is most likely a fabricated or weak narration.

can you actually post the narration and even then this doesn't disprove my point I literally state that a few brave women would fight in these types of desperate scenarios. The Battle of uhud is another defensive battle like the battle of the trenches and according to this she fought when the Muslim army was routed by khalid bin walid and fled leaving the women and children vulnerable to attack.
She had no choice she wasn't enlisted or recruited and you said she fought in numerous battles can you actually bring more narrations of expeditions/assaults led by the Muslims that she partook in and provide the narrations for those aswell?

 

[cooli3o]

Go read about the battle of uhud lmao

you said battles and proceed to quote 1 battle lmao

 

[Aegon]

Should women ever exist ?

 

[Prince of HS]

Should women ever exist ?

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[cooli3o]

Should women ever exist ?

Best question I have heard today