Taliban ban female owned shops

[Angelina]

I'm talking about the measures he takes to prevent someone from doing it, a ta'zeer punishmnet is based on the judge and therefor needs to take into account the context of the society we live in

For example you know saudi arabia, the shuyookh there deduced such as albani that niqaab is obligatory for them, in actual fact, the vast majority opinion is that niqaab is not obligatory, and it is very hard to find evidence that it is, but due to the fact, that if you let women wear no niqaab, they figured that because the hijab can easy be tainted and gradually reveal more and more of a womens awrah, an example is constantly pushing hijab back to show more hair or making it loose, making it into a turban, wearing tighter clothes, wearing clothes with reveal body shape etc, the scholars decided that making niqaaab obligatory for the public would prevent any pushing of the boundaries and women would not try to taint this.
source- I got this from a madeenah graduate
My point is life is not black and white, in different situations different rulings will apply for the betterment of society.

Niqab was never compulsary in Saudi society. The scholars thought so. But the rulers didn’t enforce it. How can they? When women should not wear when they’re in a state of Ihram?

Btw, anything can easily be tainted. Some Saudi scholars were issuing fatwas against women wearing niqab but a lot of eye makeup.

That is human nature for you.

An example would be triple talaq which I am sure you are familiar of

Yes.

 

[jemappelle]

Niqab was never compulsary in Saudi society. The scholars thought so. But the rulers didn’t enforce it. How can they? When women should not wear when they’re in a state of Ihram?

In alot of places in saudi women wear it and if they don't wear it it will cause big problems.

 

[Angelina]

In alot of places in saudi women wear it and if they don't wear it it will cause big problems.

I have family that live there and some that lived there in the 90s. It isn’t and wasn’t illegal.

wearing niqab was already part of their Urf tbh. So, yes of course a lot of Saudi women would wear it.

 

[jemappelle]

I have family that live there and some that lived there in the 90s. It isn’t and wasn’t illegal.

wearing niqab was already part of their Urf tbh. So, yes of course a lot of Saudi women would wear it.

if scholars in your country say that it is haram to not wear niqaab then the women in the country are going to wear niqaab even if it isn't enforced