Taliban ban female owned shops

[jemappelle]

No it's not. No law forcing it and no law for not wearing it.

Do you understand how Islam works? Wdym there is not law forcing it, it is obligatory in Islam to wear a hijab

 

[Nikka]

Their is no hudud punishment for not wearing a hijab.

 

[jemappelle]

Their is no hudud punishment for not wearing a hijab.

theirs no huduud punishment for going in the middle of the street naked either

 

[Nikka]

theirs no huduud punishment for going in the middle of the street naked either

I'm not saying it's not haraam.

 

[jemappelle]

I'm not saying it's not haraam.

so whats your point? Anything without a huduud punishment shouldn't be illegal?

 

[Nikka]

so whats your point? Anything without a huduud punishment shouldn't be illegal?

It should but there shouldn't be a physical punishment.

 

[jemappelle]

It should but there shouldn't be a physical punishment.

What should the punishment be?

 

[Angelina]

What should the punishment be?

just make it socially unacceptable to not wear it. People are conformists at heart.
Look at Somali society, everyone wears at least abaya minimum with many wearing jilbaab and niqab. Only a mentally I’ll woman would dare to venture out hijabless.

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Hamzza]

Their is no hudud punishment for not wearing a hijab.

theirs no huduud punishment for going in the middle of the street naked either

It should but there shouldn't be a physical punishment.

What should the punishment be?

The punishment should be whatever penalty the Qadi thinks is applicable to the offenses committed. It's called Ta'zeer.

 

[World]

The punishment should be whatever penalty the Qadi thinks is applicable to the offenses committed. It's called Ta'zeer.

So men who show their knees will go court and get punished?

 

[Angelina]

So men who show their knees will go court and get punished?

No, such laws are only for women. Only women should be punished.

 

[Hamzza]

So men who show their knees will go court and get punished?

No

 

[World]

No

if a woman can get punished for not wearing hijab then a man should get punished for showing his knees through shorts. both aren’t covering their awrah.

 

[Angelina]

No

You’re not making sense. Supposedly it’s up to the ruler.

 

[Hamzza]

But they’re both fard so why not? if a woman can get punished for not wearing hijab then a man should get punished for showing his knees through shorts.

Nah, knees are fine. The 'Awrah of the men is between the Navel and the Knee.

 

[Angelina]

Nah, knees are fine. The 'Awrah of the men is between the Naval and the Knee.

There are differences of opinion. Hence since it’s the rulers decision, supposedly he can, going by your argument.

 

[World]

There are differences of opinion. Hence since it’s the rulers decision, supposedly he can, going by your argument.

The ruler needs to punish these men at liido beach and throw them into prison

 

[Angelina]

@Hamzza

Even better, the fitnah argument could be used, even if there was unanimous agreement that men can show their knee, the ruler could decide its a fitnah for the ladies LOOOL.

 

[Angelina]

The ruler needs to punish these men at liido beach and throw them into prison

View attachment 248593

We both know, the full brunt of the law is only reserved for one gender.

 

[Hamzza]

There are differences of opinion. Hence since it’s the rulers decision, supposedly he can, going by your argument.

It's not my argument. In Sharia law theirs three major types of punishments that is Huduud, Qisaas and Tacsiir. And when there is difference of opinion on matters we will choose the strongest one.