This is the story of the founding of Mogadishu in the Arabic book and banadri books

[Banadiri Warrior]

I sent you four pages explaining that the dynasty of Fakhr al-Din continues until the fall at the hands of a Portuguese or al-Muzaffar.
The coins agreed on this also that Mogadishu had two ruling dynasties: Fakhr al-Din and al-Muzaffar.

First source disproves your point , 2nd and 3rd aren't banadiri sources, 4th isn't banadiri either, mentions "Somali" clans residing in muqdisho during fakhruddins era when none of the gibil madow clans or families claim to have lived in the city for that long.

 

[ibrahym]

Those aren't banadiri sources, them claiming Abubakar bin Shaykh Omar to be descendant of Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani is merely based upon assumptions

Also, the only ruling family that owns coins are Muzaffar and Fakhr al-Din

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Banadri sources is biased manuscripts written in the Omani era

Clearly your biased , banadiris are known for prioritizing manuscripts, everything was recorded from lineage, to major events to marriages . Alot of the sources date back to 17th century

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Also, the only ruling family that owns coins are Muzaffar and Fakhr al-Din

Those were the only coins of dynasties found so far and that doesn't prove any of your points

 

[killerxsmoke]

Clearly your biased , banadiris are known for prioritizing manuscripts, everything was recorded from lineage, to major events to marriages . Alot of the sources date back to 17th century

Where are they?

 

[ibrahym]

Those were the only coins of dynasties found so far and that doesn't prove any of your points

 

[ibrahym]

Where are they?

historians banadrii are famous for making a history. according to al-Maqrizi Ali bin Yusuf was the sultan of Mogadishu in the 15th century. His currency was found and it turned out that he was a descendant of Fakhr al-Din

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

Where are they?

Alot of the topics in shariif Caydaruus's books are from manuscripts like that, they were all kept in the qadhi's library or by other scholars and would be passed down. Currently most manuscripts would be in possession of families or in a library in xamarweyne

 

[Banadiri Warrior]

historians banadrii are famous for making a history. according to al-Maqrizi Ali bin Yusuf was the sultan of Mogadishu in the 15th century. His currency was found and it turned out that he was a descendant of Fakhr al-Din

How did it turn out he was a descendant of Abubakar bin Fakhruddin Al Qassani, is it just your baseless assumption?