What’s something glorified/praised in Somalia, but shouldn’t be?

Bille

Sidii roon Raba og
Fighting.
Somalia has never been peaceful in a period of 10 years straight. There was always a war going on somewhere in Somalia. Somalis always glorify war whether they're fighting eachother or they're fighting outsiders. It looks like every Somali generation has experienced a period of war in their lives.
 
Fighting.
Somalia has never been peaceful in a period of 10 years straight. There was always a war going on somewhere in Somalia. Somalis always glorify war whether they're fighting eachother or they're fighting outsiders. It looks like every Somali generation has experienced a period of war in their lives.

From 1960-1977 there was no war. You could probably extend that to 1990, there was no internal war or Somali fighting eachother if you discount the Ethiopian invasions or their proxy conflicts.

The transition of power between the 1960 government and 1969 government was deliberately done without war or bloodshed and in a way to safeguard peace.

Also after 1990 depending on which region you lived in Ogaden 2018-2025, Somaliland 1995-2023 or Puntland 1999-2025 , its been peaceful and stable without much war or fighting at all.

Those examples show you that if Somalis are left alone their preferred mode of operandi is to live in peace not war.

So i don't agree with you. Somalis don't glorify or praise fighting or qabil talk like OP said.

Somalis culturally speaking they prefer to talk things out then fight and their culture revolves around disuading people from war and agression.
dZ6EKwg.jpeg



The instability or war you are trying to associate with Somalis is connected to colonialism, our Terrible neighboor ''Ethiopia'' and their allies(particularly Isreal)

Colonialist forked over Somali territory to Ethiopia, and in an attempt to either claim more of our territory or or prevent Somalis from Somalia in supporting our brothers in Ogaden.
They sowed division conflict and war in Somalia, by exploiting and empowering traitors.

You see this plainly mentioned in classified documents from the late 70s and 80s
media%2FGfXj34iX0AAsRyp.jpg



Since then there has been just successive attempts to destabilize Somalia
1735564247907.png
 
Last edited:
From 1960-1977 there was no war. You could probably extend that to 1990, there was no internal war or Somali fighting eachother if you discount the Ethiopian invasions or their proxy conflicts.

Also after 1990 depending on which region you lived in Ogaden 2018-2025, Somaliland 1995-2023 or Puntland 1999-2025 , its been peaceful and stable without much war or fighting at all.

Those examples show you that if Somalis are left alone their mode of operandi is to live in peace not war.

So i don't agree with you. Somalis don't glorify or praise fighting or qabil talk like OP said.

Somalis culturally speaking they prefer to talk things out then fight and their culture revolves around disuading people from war and agression.
dZ6EKwg.jpeg



The instability or war you are trying to associate with Somalis is connected to colonialism, our Terrible neighboor ''Ethiopia'' and their allies(particularly Isreal)

Colonialist forked over Somali territory to Ethiopia, and in an attempt to either claim more of our territory or or prevent Somalis from Somalia in supporting our brothers Ogaden.
They sowed division conflict and war in Somalia, by exploiting and empowering traitors.

You see this plainly mentioned in classified documents from
media%2FGfXj34iX0AAsRyp.jpg



Since then there has been just successive attempts to destabilize Ethiopia and they are added by Isreal
View attachment 351595
There was war in between that period you named, 64 border war with Ethiopia which ended in a stalemate, and the “shifta” conflict
 
Being “landheere”
How does having a few extra names or belonging to a more important clan/subclan make you any different to the average Johnny. These people are usually the bums too
 
'Xamar Cadey' is not the Capital for Somalis, southerners just like to insist on it for their own personal gains (unakah leh), if they were truly about 'Somalinimo', the events of 91 would not have transpired.

There shouldn't be any Capital for Somalis, we're too xaasid and shortsighted for it, let every clan build his own cities/deegans. 🤷🏾‍♂️
 
Being “landheere”
How does having a few extra names or belonging to a more important clan/subclan make you any different to the average Johnny. These people are usually the bums too

Yeah that one is the weird to me, how that term has taken on a new meaning.

Spoke about how it was used traditionally speaking:
Even the concept of Landheere and Langaab which i see being thrown around even has been greatly distorted as well, it really has nothing to do with someones inherent value or position. It's a description of long branch in the lineage tree and short branch, the number of generations. They could also be cousin lineages, so it's not really about division either.

The langaabs were historically often politically alied to and were given protection by the landheere clans as patrons. Some cases were even given client status if adopted, to grow themselves .
So opposed to oppressing, they were actually tasked with ensuring their well being and inclusion.
 
'Xamar Cadey' is not the Capital for Somalis, southerners just like to insist on it for their own personal gains (unakah leh), if they were truly about 'Somalinimo', the events of 91 would not have transpired.

The events 1991 was Ethiopian proxies toppling the government, what happened after is that they took their armed advantage to brutalize everyone. Later on was backed by the CIA and Mossad.

It wasn't clan driven, because those very same people went against their own clan members, it led to a decade of local Somalis fighting them to regain control and safeguard eachother in ICU

The direct foreign interventions also undermined the local authorities that would pacify the area like we saw in Puntland and Somaliland.


There shouldn't be any Capital for Somalis, we're too xaasid and shortsighted for it, let every clan build his own cities/deegans. 🤷🏾‍♂️

It goes against Somali history and culture. Major cities have always been multi-clanal.

There has never been a region or city built by a single clan. It really wouldn't make sense.

Somalis of all clans move cross regionally and invest in eachother cities and regions.

For example when Bosaso was experiencing growth in late 90s and early 2000s Professor Samatar wrote this:

Horn of Africa - Volume 15 - Page 131

1735566308098.png
 
The events 1991 was Ethiopian proxies toppling the government, what happened after is that they took their armed advantage to brutalize everyone. Later on was backed by the CIA and Mossad.

It wasn't clan driven, because those very same people went against their own clan members, it led to a decade of local Somalis fighting them to regain control and safeguard eachother in ICU

The direct foreign interventions also undermined the local authorities that would pacify the area like we saw in Puntland and Somaliland.




It goes against Somali history and culture. Major cities have always been multi-clanal.

There has never been a region or city built by a single clan. It really wouldn't make sense.

Somalis of all clans move cross regionally and invest in eachother cities and regions.

For example when Bosaso was experiencing growth in late 90s and early 2000s Professor Samatar wrote this:

Horn of Africa - Volume 15 - Page 131

View attachment 351596
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
 
Some Somalis seem to think they are too good for physical labor and only consider office jobs acceptable.(Not diaspora)

I think that's an oversimplification, although there is a perception like that. There is also a lot of Somalis back home who want to do manual labour work but the companies prefer cheaper labour done by foreigners like Indians or chinese recently

Somalia needs to have tougher labour policies to protect and encourage local workers and open up more vocational schools.

Shared a report that talks about this:
No in Somalia a good sizeable portion of the construction builders are still Somalis. Not all foreigners. Foreigners are more recently being recruited to meet a demand.

He said that the foreigners they employ do not do any work that can be done by local workers. They also encourage the transfer of skills to the local workforce.

Iftin currently employs 17 foreigners and 10 locals on permanent contracts. When a project is under construction, they hire more locals on daily wages, such as men like Ali and Hassan.


There is outsourcing happening to Chinese and Indians from overseas not Kenyans, that may puts pressure on the job availability/security of locals: According to this article


“We have the right skills and experience, among us are tilers, builders, and plumbers. We are all sitting here while foreigners are all over the town doing what was ours!” he complained.

Also aggrieved is Hassan Abdinoor, who worked on building sites for 21 years before finding himself unable to get work recently.

“The lack of construction jobs has affected us badly. We are sitting here idle by the walls of these shops the whole day. These men you see here are all builders, they have families waiting for them at home, but we come here in the morning and leave in the evening empty handed. The construction jobs have been taken by foreigners!” Hassan stated.



Outsourcing of labour is pretty much something happening world wide. It has to do with the incentive of companies to make a profit
 
The events 1991 was Ethiopian proxies toppling the government, what happened after is that they took their armed advantage to brutalize everyone. Later on was backed by the CIA and Mossad.

It wasn't clan driven, because those very same people went against their own clan members, it led to a decade of local Somalis fighting them to regain control and safeguard eachother in ICU

The direct foreign interventions also undermined the local authorities that would pacify the area like we saw in Puntland and Somaliland.




It goes against Somali history and culture. Major cities have always been multi-clanal.

There has never been a region or city built by a single clan. It really wouldn't make sense.

Somalis of all clans move cross regionally and invest in eachother cities and regions.

For example when Bosaso was experiencing growth in late 90s and early 2000s Professor Samatar wrote this:

Horn of Africa - Volume 15 - Page 131

View attachment 351596

Be that as they may, that is Ethiopian proxies, crimes were committed against civilians.

This is not an attack on anyone, what I am advocating for is that there shouldn't be any Capital, no clan should have a monopoly on their city having the seat of government, we should all opt for a Confederation. UAE, Switzerland, Belgium and many other countries function just fine with it.

Somali culture (qabil/ignorance) is not synonymous with government, we can't keep doing the same thing and hoping to expect different results.
 
Be that as they may, that is Ethiopian proxies, crimes were committed against civilians.

This is not an attack on anyone, what I am advocating for is that there shouldn't be any Capital, no clan should have a monopoly on their city having the seat of government, we should all opt for a Confederation. UAE, Switzerland, Belgium and many other countries function just fine with it.

Somali culture (qabil/ignorance) is not synonymous with government, we can't keep doing the same thing and hoping to expect different results.

You are trying to suggest what happened in 1991 means Somalis lack somalinimo or care only about their narrow clan. It's not true, local Somalis across clan lines, businessmen, sheikhs , elders went far and beyond to defend, unite and rescue each other in the midst of it all. Covered it here:

I don't fully support the current federal structure in the long run, but i now believe it could possibly evolve into some kind of unitary decentralized structure, that allows for local governments in different regions but that citizenship or political participation is not clan based. That what i am hopeful about.

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

The had a hand in arming, organizing and creating that group. It was an ongoing harassment campaign for several years by those same groups that eventually exhausted the resources and defense capabilities by the government that led to toppling.
 
Last edited:

Khaem

Früher of the Djibouti Ugaasate 🇩🇯
VIP
From 1960-1977 there was no war. You could probably extend that to 1990, there was no internal war or Somali fighting eachother if you discount the Ethiopian invasions or their proxy conflicts.

The transition of power between the 1960 government and 1969 government was deliberately done without war or bloodshed and in a way to safeguard peace.

Also after 1990 depending on which region you lived in Ogaden 2018-2025, Somaliland 1995-2023 or Puntland 1999-2025 , its been peaceful and stable without much war or fighting at all.

Those examples show you that if Somalis are left alone their preferred mode of operandi is to live in peace not war.

So i don't agree with you. Somalis don't glorify or praise fighting or qabil talk like OP said.

Somalis culturally speaking they prefer to talk things out then fight and their culture revolves around disuading people from war and agression.
dZ6EKwg.jpeg



The instability or war you are trying to associate with Somalis is connected to colonialism, our Terrible neighboor ''Ethiopia'' and their allies(particularly Isreal)

Colonialist forked over Somali territory to Ethiopia, and in an attempt to either claim more of our territory or or prevent Somalis from Somalia in supporting our brothers in Ogaden.
They sowed division conflict and war in Somalia, by exploiting and empowering traitors.

You see this plainly mentioned in classified documents from the late 70s and 80s
media%2FGfXj34iX0AAsRyp.jpg



Since then there has been just successive attempts to destabilize Somalia
View attachment 351595
Or Djibouti which has never seen war in general for the whole 20th century. Last war in Djibouti was the ottoman conflict in the 1800s, Aussa sultanate becoming a vessel then france leasing the land from Ciise Ugaas and Afar Sultan to create a trading port called Djibouti
 

Trending

Top