Xamar wa Somali

[Zak12]

Again your quoting Al jallad. He is the only amateur that says that. You do know he is still a student right? Here you have another Arab student clearly debunking his claims. It goes against logic to take Al jallad’s vague claims over 1000’s of classical Arab linguistic scholars the Islamic world had produced. Al jallad is literally a student

https://academicworks.cuny.edu/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?article=1018&context=oaa_pubs

Its not only him. Its the concensus. A random non-peer reviewed article doesn't mean anything.

.

 

[Step a side]

Its not only him. Its the concensus. A random non-peer reviewed article doesn't mean anything.

.

No it’s not a concensus. It’s only him. I’m well aware of this.

Sending me a students opinion and then pretending he knows better than all the classical Arabic linguistic scholars we had over the centuries is a joke

 

[Zak12]

No it’s not a concensus. It’s only him. I’m well aware of this.

Sending me a students opinion and then pretending he knows better than all the classical Arabic linguistic scholars we had over the centuries is a. joke

It is. The archeology makes it clear.

You haven't given any proof beyond just the writing of medieval Arabs that Yemen was the birthplace of Arabs. There is zero proof. There is a reason the very name "Arabia" originally referred to the southern Levant before being applied to the rest.

 

[ibrahym]

Those names he mentioned aren't names used by reer samaale: Xaramayn, Nuur, Sacaadah, Munye , Baanow etc

who said we don't used this names?
Aydarus was quoted the text from the book of Shakib Arslan , who uses Somalia to refer to samaale's .
Also, do not try to claim that is names Benadiri

 

[Step a side]

It is. The archeology makes it clear.

You haven't given any proof beyond just the writing of medieval Arabs that Yemen was the birthplace of Arabs. There is zero proof. There is a reason the very name "Arabia" originally referred to the southern Levant before being applied to the rest.

That’s not archeology That’s graffiti from tribes with known origin in the south.
Ancient Greeks way back in time called Yemen , “Arabia Eudaemon” “Arabia Felix” meaning happy Arabia. Caught you lying again I suggest you do some reading

https://pleiades.stoa.org/places/746710

 

[Zak12]

That’s graffiti from tribes with known origin in the south.

Graffiti is archeology. Feel free to ignore the blatant evidence of Arabic writing from the north. Your headcanon of southern origin is also quite funny.

called Yemen , “Arabia Eudaemon

Because they thought Yemenis and most of Arabia in general spoke Arabic. They make mistakes.

 

[Step a side]

Graffiti is archeology. Feel free to ignore the blatant evidence of Arabic writing from the north. Your headcanon of southern origin is also quite funny.

Because they thought Yemenis and most of Arabia in general spoke Arabic. They make mistakes.

The Quraish tribe existed way before these inscriptions from the north. Does it mean the Quraish received the Arabic language from the north? If so what language did the people of Makkah speak prior to the arrival of these Arabs from the north? Himyarite kings litterally styled themselves as “kings of Arabs”. There are 40 inscriptions from southern Arabia with the term “Arab” on it. Even the northern inscriptions you are on are from tribes that reached there in the 3rd century from Yemen. Many more followed afterwards. The standard Arabic you hear today is the dialect that people from the central Hejaz spoke. No one lives in the north apart from few bedouins because it’s impossible to have large population in the Syrian desert. Use your brain

 

[El Nino]

Those names he mentioned aren't names used by reer samaale: Xaramayn, Nuur, Sacaadah, Munye , Baanow etc

Are Munye, Baanow, Ikar(formerly Abu Bakr) and Macow used by arabs or persians or hindis or super saiyans

who said we don't used this names?
Aydarus was quoted the text from the book of Shakib Arslan , who uses Somalia to refer to samaale's .
Also, do not try to claim that is names Benadiri

His people are rocking some old school somali names, speak somali but he wants to convince xamar is an arab city founded by them. Somehow he has not stated any source from arabian peninsula, from people who had recorded their history for more then a millenia. You would think they would boast about creating a city in the horn but nothing.

 

[Zak12]

The Quraish tribe existed way before these inscriptions from the north. Does it mean the Quraish received the Arabic language from the north? If so what language did the people of Makkah speak prior to the arrival of these Arabs from the north? Himyarite kings litterally styled themselves as “kings of Arabs”. There are 40 inscriptions from southern Arabia with the term “Arab” on it. Even the northern inscriptions you are on are from tribes that reached there in the 3rd century from Yemen. Many more followed afterwards. The standard Arabic you hear today is the dialect that people from the central Hejaz spoke. No one lives in the north apart from few bedouins because it’s impossible to have large population in the Syrian desert. Use your brain

Central Arabs like the Quraysh spoke Central Semitic like Dadanitic. Once again, there is no proof that the inscriptions from the north are from Yemen. Himyar was a non-Arabic speaking state.