”Somali ethnicity is fake”

Idilinaa

(Graduated)
Also non somalis in somali dont have somali paternal lineage which they can't claim somali identity nor somali tribes and clans
Also someone speaking somali language don't make somali and somali language is mixed Arabic English Italia an other languages
I speak foreigner language which don't make me foreign

Whats with the emphasis on paternal lineage. When Somalis also trace descent through their maternal side via ''Bah'' and ''Habar'' . Your maternal side is never ignored or irrelevant it's an important connection.

And at the same time, someone is a Somali through not only their ancestry, but also culture, language and nationality.

Also even if someone is of mixed cultural background. They can be both, they are not mutually exclusive to each-other.

Tbh the only people I’ve seen who think of them like that are people who are lookin to steal their lands/properties 💀

It's tragic thing , so many Somalis lost their land and property to thugs with guns and hooligans.

I remember hearing that during the outbreak of the civil war they would loot and take peoples properties and justify it by saying ''This is Siad Barre's property we are confiscating'' so initially it was just blind hatred towards him, almost like those rioters you see in the UK, Kenya shouting ''Ruto out'' in recent memories or the BLM protesters in Minneapolis some years back.

When the ICU took over, they started to reinstate people's properties back and land. I hope we can see this happen again. There are many abandoned building and houses believe it or not, so that's another potentiality we can encourage more to come back to.

1732998287305.png
 
Last edited:
I think discussions like these can never be civil on Sspot

Any criticism towards Bantus and you'll have a herd of users punishing you and the double standard on this cursed site is ridiculous; a couple of responses in and you've got OP advocated for the term J*reer to be dropped but the equivalent word against Ethnic Somalis 'has a nice ring to it'??

Either way, Somali Bantus and any other minorities incorporated within Somalia are not native and never will be and anyone who pushes this is either a self hater or an outsider with wrong intentions
This popped on Reddit,the responses were heated. https://www.reddit.com/r/Somalia/s/1Lj6j7RORT
 

Attachments

  • IMG_2785.jpeg
    IMG_2785.jpeg
    1.6 MB · Views: 26
They sound like the trolls and posters on this thread. Imagine being this invested in policing other people's identities.

Peak loser behaviour wallahi
It’s mostly Somalis in the diaspora who are obsessed with genetics and dna,the Somalis in East Africa don’t care about this kind of stuff
 
What do you think of the Carabsalax,they were originally Arabs who intermarried with local Somali women
I think the only ppl that have assimilated well into somali society has been carab salax.. probably has alot to do with them intermarrying with the same subclan over centuries to the point that they’re indistinguishable from other mjs.

looks play a bigger role than what ppl are willing to admit.
 
They are not Somali paternally tho,you can’t pick and choose who’s Somali if we go by the rules
They have integrated into our society unlike the cadcads and Bantus who practice their own culture, look different to us and behave in a foreign way.
 
Last edited:

Trending

Top