Any proof of shewa sultanate and a horn based banu makhzum dynasty

[Garaad Awal]

Harla were Ethio-Semitic speakers who probably lived in close proximity with Somalis and were genetically heavily Somali. They hated ethnic Somalis and had to be separated within the Imam’s army

 

[Zak12]

They hated ethnic Somalis

Kekekek, where is this from?

 

[Idilinaa]

This is rubbish harla are msot likely hararis

Harla were Ethio-Semitic speakers who probably lived in close proximity with Somalis and were genetically heavily Somali. They hated ethnic Somalis and had to be separated within the Imam’s army

Alright show evidence that Harla was Harrari and ethio-semetic. You can claim them to be this and that but at the end of the day, if you don't have anything to back it up it is mute

They was seperated because they were sedentary agro-pastoralists and those clans called "somaal' was mobile pastoralists(bedouins).

It groups them with other Somali tribes in certain passages, in other passages they are grouped with the agro-pastoral clans and seperated, because the bedouin clans are headed by their own independant leaders while Harla along with the other sedentary ones are led by a one leader from Zarba a different clan.

So the speration is between bedouin and agro-pastoral sedentary clans. Not an ethnic one.
It's consistent with the distinction richard burton gives to Somalis in the area 500 years later.



Somebody asked me the same question a previous thread: Have a read to a more detailed answer i gave:
They make occupational distinctions not ethnic ones since they are written as a connected group