you cannot erase someone's genetics and ancestry, dumbass.
Are Somalis Ethno religous?
- Thread starter Nafiso Qalanjo
- Start date
The ethnogenesis of Iranians and Arabs didn't happen because of Islam. Those are two different scenarios that you're trying to compare.
Another Somali who cares about what ajnabis think about us.
Have a backbone niyo. Even @Halimo Supremist has more balls than you
They can be the kindest people on the planet and they would still be considered ajnabi/Shiisheye.
You know what the word shiisheye and ajnabi have in common? They both mean someone that is far and distant. Ex-Muslims are just that. They have no connection to Islam which is the bulk of our identity. So how could we possibly ever claim them to be our brethren when they are so distant from us?
Another Somali who cares about what ajnabis think about us.
What do you mean even?
Are you Muslim?
The erasure is self-inflicted. They made their bed now they have to lie in it.
The ethnogenesis of Iranians and Arabs didn't happen because of Islam. Those are two different scenarios that you're trying to compare.
Another Somali who cares about what ajnabis think about us.
They can be the kindest people on the planet and they would still be considered ajnabi/Shiisheye.
You know what the word shiisheye and ajnabi have in common? They both mean someone that is far and distant. Ex-Muslims are just that. They have no connection to Islam which is the bulk of our identity. So how could we possibly ever claim them to be our brethren when they are so distant from us?
Its like talking to an eggplant. So you don't consider the people of Punt or Macrobia (who we directly descend from) Somalis? Or do you think we appeared out of thin air just 1400 years ago?Yes our ancestors existed well before Islam but they weren't Somali. Somalis only began calling themselves Somalis after the Adal-Abysinian war.
If we can call our ancestors before Islam Somalis, then we can also call the proto Nilotic and ancient Natufian ancestors of ours Somalis as well, since they were also our ancestors.
Just give it up buddy. There's no way to separate Islam from Somalinimo.
They are free to assimilate into their fellow non-muslims communities.
Who said the Somali identity was based on genetics? It's based on lineage and religion. Get that through your head.
I’m going to start revoking the mj card
Horta caqli soo yeesho
I dare you to go to an ajnabi Muslim and tell them to reject their non Muslim counterparts.They will laugh at you, dumbass Somalian who can't comprehend one of their own being different. It deeply disturbs me how close mindedness to this extent is so widespread amongst our people. And then ya'll wonder why the country remains the worlds asshole.
How do you know they were not muslims? That was before the Quran was revealed. We don't even know what they believed Allah set knows best. There is no comparison there no one has condemned the people before.
Im a lot smarter and more open minded than you'll ever be
our traditional belief system of course, before it got completely wiped out by assimilationists
You've got bigger balls than that guy. He cares way to much about what ajnabis think about us.What do you mean even?
Why are you so obsessed with what other communities think or do?I dare you to go to an ajnabi Muslim and tell them to reject their non Muslim counterparts.They will laugh at you, dumbass Somalian who can't comprehend one of their own being different. It deeply disturbs me how close mindedness to this extent is so widespread amongst our people. And then ya'll wonder why the country remains the worlds asshole.
You missed the point. There is no comparison and no one was condemning people of the past.
Are you hurt that Somalis chose Islam and it vanished or something?
