Then these classical scholars spoke for themselves. That is news to me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content.
Log in or register now.
Then these classical scholars spoke for themselves. That is news to me.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
Yea I did read. And for me, I never hold a human to be infallible regardless of their status in Knowledge. We are supposed to take from people what is beneficial and they got right, and leave the rest of their mistakes or shortfalls behind. Many learned men lived in their own time and based their opinions on what they lived through as well sometimes.
It is the reason I can read garbage opinion but don't hold grudges agaisnt the sheekh or a scholar.
You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.
A nine-year-old girl with fully developed hips for childbearing and big enough breasts to breastfeeding an infant? Technically not impossible since anomalies occur but that is 0.001%, perhaps EVEN lesser than that, of nine-year-old girls.They could actually. You’re just saying it’s impossible.
You’re a kafir.Just face it, bro, if you take the Sahih narration that he consummated the marriage when she was nine to be irrefutable, then that means he violated a child's body.
@GaloolA nine-year-old girl with fully developed hips for childbearing and big enough breasts to breastfeeding an infant? Technically not impossible since anomalies occur but that is 0.001%, perhaps EVEN lesser than that, of nine-year-old girls.
Just face it, bro, if you take the Sahih narration that he consummated the marriage when she was nine to be irrefutable, then that means he violated a child's body.
It doesn't matter that she was noted to be highly intelligent with the mental maturity of an adult, she physically still would have been a child.
Like, it is what it is. I'm not even looking to slander Prophet Muhammad (SWT) but just following your own logic to its natural conclusion.
Nah I'm not.You’re a kafir.
You slandered Rasul (SAW) marriage. You also slandered his character.Nah I'm not.
You're an idiot who thinks nine-year-old girls from back then could have an adult enough body to tolerate sexual intercourse.
It just isn't true, and I'm calling you out on your weird logic.
So I'm a kafir for thinking a grown man engaging in sexual activity with an underdeveloped girl who most likely would have still had the body of a child since she just started puberty is disgusting?You slandered Rasul (SAW) marriage. You also slandered his character.
Physically mature is a reference menstruation.So I'm a kafir for thinking a grown man engaging in sexual activity with an underdeveloped girl who most likely would have still had the body of a child since she just started puberty is disgusting?
I didn't even slander the Messenger of Allah (SAW) in any way, that's the crazy part.
If you read it again slowly, it was only was a hypothetical to demonstrate that your logic of her being adult enough for marriage makes no rational sense.
Other Muslim brothers here have done a decent job at contextualising the marriage of Aisha but you haven't. Kulaha "physically mature enough to handle marriage"
You're the retard for thinking that a nine-year-old girl would have been ready to experience sex from her first period.Physically mature is a reference menstruation.
“Just face it, bro, if you take the Sahih narration that he consummated the marriage when she was nine to be irrefutable, then that means he violated a child's body.”
1.Sahih is irrefutable retard.
2. “Then that means he violated a child’s body” There’s the slander. The Rasul SAW is no violator, you’ll pay for saying that! If you don’t retake your shahada and deeply repent.
Sahih is 100% factual there is no “if” about it. You said under the circumstances of the hadith that the consummation was a violation of Aisha (RA).You're the retard for thinking that a nine-year-old girl would have been ready to experience sex from her first period.
I don't need to repent for anything because I never actually said that he did violate her, I was just using if-then reasoning to refute what I initially understood to be your idea of "physically mature" before you clarified it to be menstruation which also raises concerns.
Sahih is 100% factual there is no “if” about it. You said under the circumstances of the hadith that the consummation was a violation of Aisha (RA).
“Just face it, bro, if you take the Sahih narration that he consummated the marriage when she was nine to be irrefutable, then that means he violated a child's body.”
Just stumbled across this old thread where they were having this exact same argument about Aisha (RA) back on 2019. Why were there so many gaals on SSpot back then? And straight-up disrespectful ones too, who didn't give a f*ck compared to today's ones?
Refuting the Claim that Prophet ﷺ was a Pedophile
https://ia800702.us.archive.org/21/items/RefutingTheClaimThatProphetMuhammadWasAPedophile/Refuting%20the%20Claim%20that%20Prophet%20Muhammad%20was%20a%20Pedophile.pdfwww.somalispot.com
Even the muslims on that thread were unhinged. Sspot has really calmed down the past few yearsJust stumbled across this old thread where they were having this exact same argument about Aisha (RA) back on 2019. Why were there so many gaals on SSpot back then? And straight-up disrespectful ones too, who didn't give a f*ck compared to today's ones?
Refuting the Claim that Prophet ﷺ was a Pedophile
https://ia800702.us.archive.org/21/items/RefutingTheClaimThatProphetMuhammadWasAPedophile/Refuting%20the%20Claim%20that%20Prophet%20Muhammad%20was%20a%20Pedophile.pdfwww.somalispot.com
Trying so hard to justify the use of “violated ”. The Hadith is 100% the reality hence you claim our beloved Rasul (SAW) violated his wife. That is what you said. How dare you disrespect him like that!You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.