Muslim also says she was 6 when married and 9 when consummated, it’s not a weak hadith. Also it’s Aisha narrating her own age, it’s not like a third party is the one saying this
It doesn't make any difference whether it's in Sahih Bukhari, Muslim or any other book of hadith. They're using the same transmission and chain for the same hadith.
What do you mean it's Aisha narrating her own age? That is via the authority of 'Urwa who Imam Malik said his hadiths are not reliable after moving to Iraq due to old age. The experts on his history used the word اختلط meaning he became confused and made many mistakes
Last edited: