Puntland waxay ku faanta in gobolo wax lagu qaybsaday, waa sax, degmoyin waa lagu qaybsaday, lakin madaxtoyada waa .3.niyahow, it's not even consistent with the district or region model. The region model is better with presidential seat going to each region once. Bari-Nugal-Mudug-Sanag-Sool, that's cadalad as far as I am concerned. You can't say aan mamul wada yeelano lakin ana madaxtoyada qaadanayo taas ma aha mamul la wada lee yahay sxb and discredits puntland legitmatcy in the wider community inside puntland and also in somalia and the international community. You need to be consistent with your rules.
They did everything right. Federalism vision and not majertenia sultanate vision on 1929 borders. No jabhad or attacking regions to join, no blood spilled, no clan dis-armed, parliament district based not tribe based, the only place they messed up was presidential seat should circulate all the regions one by one so everyone is a stakeholder. The biggest reason siyad did his coup was he felt he couldn't be stakeholder due to the nepotism and puntland will suffer the same fate or security problems for a long time till everyone is stakeholder. This is the last reform it needs puntland to share president along regional lines on the founding states.