Sabean theory

[Step a side]

We can make a similar argument regarding Zeila being Arab. The Qiblatayn was built by Arabs, the famous landmark tomb is of an Arab Sheikh.

Does this mean Zeila is not Somali anymore? Or we can't claim it?

Somalis in Zeila don’t have 1/3 Yemeni blood nor do they speak a Semitic language.

 

[Aseer]

Somalis in Zeila don’t have 1/3 Yemeni blood nor do they speak a Semitic language.

This guy thinks that the sabaeans who literally colonized the habash and are the ones who made all those structures/left behind mullattos aka. the habeshi is comparable to zeila where a few arabs built one mosque and didnt do anything else

 

[Khaemwaset]

We can make a similar argument regarding Zeila being Arab. The Qiblatayn was built by Arabs, the famous landmark tomb is of an Arab Sheikh.

Does this mean Zeila is not Somali anymore? Or we can't claim it?

Zelia wasn't conquered and built up by Arabians. You can't compare Arab merchants in Somalia with romans and sabeans.

There was Somali merchants in Arabia and a Somali Shiekh who founded a city in Yemen.


"The first Zaylaī of whom al-Sarğī dedicates a complete biography is the famous Abū al'Abbas Ahmad b. 'Umar, known as Sulţän al-'arifin. He left his country on the African coast (barr al'ağam) when he was 17 years old and reached the coastal village of al-Mahmul, in the Wādī Mür region of Yemen.. it was the latter's grandfather, Muhammad, and his brother 'Umar, Ahmad's father, who left "Abyssinia". Having reached the Yemeni shores, the two brothers separated: Muhammad headed north, where his nephew Ali became "sahib" of the village of al-Salāma; 'Umar turned south and his descendants, starting with his son Ahmad, settled in al Luhayya.. It is impossible, in the current state of our knowledge, to determine the exact date of this emigration: in fact the only other useful date known to us is that of the death of Ahmad b. 'Umar, 704 (1304-1305). Assuming, purely conjecturally, that Ahmad lived for about seventy years, we could place his departure from the African coast (which occurred when he was 17 years old) around 650 (1252-1253)."
- According to the Yemeni historian Al-Sergi; Al-Luhayyah was founded by the Somali Sheikh 'Umar Zayla-ī at around 1250AD.

https://www.jstor.org/stable/41881017

 

[Rayaale]

Because these Habesha never build it in the 1st place The D’MT civilisation (precursor to Aksum) was run by South Arabians. These south Arabian colonialists were absorbed and forgotten. The only thing left of their legacy in the Horn of Africa is the script, Semitic tongue and the Arabian paternal lineages and the high to moderate amount of the Yemeni Iron Age component found in the Habesha and neighbouring tribes.

What percentage of Ethiopians have sabean ancestry

 

[Rayaale]

I remember reading about the diffusion of culture from the gash culture across the read sea to Arabia, a lot of trade was happening in antiquity.

Can we say habeshas are foreign to Ethiopia/eritrea

 

[Rayaale]

We can make a similar argument regarding Zeila being Arab. The Qiblatayn was built by Arabs, the famous landmark tomb is of an Arab Sheikh.

Does this mean Zeila is not Somali anymore? Or we can't claim it?

You are contradicting yourself

 

[Rayaale]

This guy thinks that the sabaeans who literally colonized the habash and are the ones who made all those structures/left behind mullattos aka. the habeshi is comparable to zeila where a few arabs built one mosque and didnt do anything else

Somalis are technically mulatto

 

[Aseer]

Somalis are technically mulatto

How

 

[Rayaale]

How

60/40 Sub-Saharan/West Asian

 

[Aseer]

60/40 Sub-Saharan/West Asian

Thats way back compare that to the habeshis

 

[Rayaale]

Thats way back compare that to the habeshis

I know im just joking and it was a back migration

 

[Step a side]

What percentage of Ethiopians have sabean ancestry

It’s the northern once circled in black that can have as high as 20-30% Yemeni blood. So mostly the Semitic speaking Tigre, Tigray and Amhara as well as neighbouring Cushitic speaking tribes like the Afar, Saho etc

 

[NidarNidar]

It’s the northern once circled in black that can have as high as 20-30% Yemeni blood. So mostly the Semitic speaking Tigre, Tigray and Amhara as well as neighbouring Cushitic speaking tribes like the Afar, Saho etc

View attachment 342540

I always laugh when Ethio nationalists point towards Sabean temples on the northern coasts, it has nothing to do with them, they got cucked in the highland, how do you let a group of people you subjugated rule over you?

 

[Step a side]

I always laugh when Ethio nationalists point towards Sabean temples on the northern coasts, it has nothing to do with them, they got cucked in the highland, how do you let a group of people you subjugated rule over you?

The funniest part is when they claim that the Semitic languages started in the horn and that the Sabean culture is indigenous to Africa

 

[NidarNidar]

The funniest part is when they claim that the Semitic languages started in the horn and that the Sabean culture is indigenous to Africa

Archaeology and science dunk on their ass, they need to accept they got xooged.

 

[Aiman12]

this exists only in the heads of ana carabs

 

[NidarNidar]

this exists only in the heads of ana carabs

What exists?

 

[Aiman12]

What exists?

you know exactly what i mean

 

[NidarNidar]

you know exactly what i mean

 

[Zak12]

only regressed in the last few centuries

*laughs in Solomonid mudhuts*

Also, Aksum was over 2000 years ago, that was their peak