Sheikh Yasir Qadhi Supports Same Sex Unions
- Thread starter Duchess
- Start date
- Status
Hafez
VIP
Lmao, Sharia has NEVER been changed and will NEVER be changed. That's only possible if the Qur'an and Sunnah 'changes', we both know that will never happen.
Sharia is not a monolith. That's why its interpretation changes from country to country. Sharia doesn't need to be changed when it already has changed and will continue to change ...
The Sharia law does not change, rather according to the 'urf (customs) of a society some aspects of fiqh may be changed but they are usually trivial matters not fundamental, this is as long the ijtihaad does not contradict the Qur'an and Sunnah. The haraam will never be halal, regardless of which 'country' one resides. This statement of yours shows nothing but how ignorant you are lmao.
Zayd
Habar Magaadle
The Sharia is a unified system, there are so many components of the Shari'a that are missing in every Muslim country, including that joke nation Saudi Arabia. There is Sharia when it comes to economics, and in today's global economy it is anything but halal. There is Sharia when it comes to war and in modernity all war inflicts damage upon the environment, innocent lives and animals. You can't pick and choose what part of the Sharia you want. Wallahi Muslims have to stop dreaming of changing entire nations in the west into Salafi principalities, that's a dream that won't come into fruition.
The best chance you got in seeing a Muslim Utopia at a nationwide level is the Mahdi, and who's to say he won't manifest in the next 50, 100, or even 300 years? Just live in the world as a individual, Allah didn't ask you to overthrow states because they contravene the tenets of Islam.
The best chance you got in seeing a Muslim Utopia at a nationwide level is the Mahdi, and who's to say he won't manifest in the next 50, 100, or even 300 years? Just live in the world as a individual, Allah didn't ask you to overthrow states because they contravene the tenets of Islam.
Zayd
Habar Magaadle
All of what you see was meant to happen anyway, "Nikaah bayn al- mar'i wal-mar, wal-raajal bil-rajal", "Marriage between women and women, and men and men". It's Qadr, it's all part of Allah's plan, I just feel bad for the Muslims who are caught up in the array of emotions of countless same-sex stories, their faces on Yawm Al-Qiyamah.. 
Hafez
VIP
They did not base their ijtihaad on the Qur'an and Sunnah but rather their ijtihaad is literally based on innovations. Shi'ism is believed to have been invented by a Jewish man called Abdullah ibn Saba to cause confusion amongst the Muslims.Are you guys forgetting the existence of the Shia and Ibadi or do you not consider them Muslims?
Hafez
VIP
It is supposed to happen bro, you are right about that. We inevitably commit sins too, does that mean we should not try and avoid them? Come on sxb.All of what you see was meant to happen anyway, "Nikaah bayn al- mar'i wal-mar, wal-raajal bil-rajal", "Marriage between women and women, and men and men". It's Qadr, it's all part of Allah's plan, I just feel bad for the Muslims who are caught up in the array of emotions of countless same-sex stories, their faces on Yawm Al-Qiyamah..
Zayd
Habar Magaadle
If the masses want to commit them and they detest a life of recognizing the oneness of God, then let them do what they want.
They promote their worldview on every medium of communication that they possess, let them live their lives according to their ordeals.
If they don't want to listen then don't force yourself upon them, even if they are Muslims.
Hafez
VIP
This is proof. Their supposed narrations regarding the 'sunnah' are literally fabrications, save some of the ahadith they implement that can be found in kutub Al-Sittah. I know you can't understand what I'm telling you or what the debate in this video is about but oh well.You're sick.
The scholars have authored many books dedicated to this issue, it was even confirmed by some of their most 'knowledgeable' ulama subhanallah.
Kkkkkk
Why is everyone injecting religion into this. Civil marriages are not Islamic marriages. This is what you're denying people. A piece of paper.
On that account we should also be on the side of denying same sex couples hotel rooms etc......
Astagfurullah Shias are muslim. People here speak with such authority on subjects, it's another thing when you speak on islam though.
Why is everyone injecting religion into this. Civil marriages are not Islamic marriages. This is what you're denying people. A piece of paper.
On that account we should also be on the side of denying same sex couples hotel rooms etc......
Astagfurullah Shias are muslim. People here speak with such authority on subjects, it's another thing when you speak on islam though.
I watched the video and it didn't prove anything. It could be argued that not all hadiths Sunnis deem to be Sahih are actually authentic. Didn't Sh Al-Albani class some hadiths from Sahih al-Bukhari as da'eef?
If that is the benchmark you're using to deem Shia non-Muslims, your argument is very weak.
Hafez
VIP
No one said civil marriages are Islamic marriages lmfao. Civil marriages are valid from the perspective of the non-Muslim residents in a secular state. Why should a 'Shaykh' support a cause that does not explicitly concern the Muslims in the first place? The implicit effects are apparent for any Muslim capable of critical thinking (knowledge is required for critical thinking, ones judgement of an issue should be based on the Qur'an and Sunnah).
Besides, no one said all Shia are kuffar abaayo, many of the scholars are of the opinion that the ignorant from amongst them are still Muslims.
There are different types and branches of Shi'ism who vary in their 'aqeedah and practices, some believe that Allah (SWT) accidentally revealed the Qur'an to the prophet (SAW) when it was meant for his cousin Ali. Tell me, is such a person Muslim? In accordance to sahih shia hadith, there were 17000 verses in Quran when there's 6236!
The Qur'an, words of Allah (SWT) proves them to be liars!
Sahih International: Prohibited to you are dead animals, blood, the flesh of swine, and that which has been dedicated to other than Allah , and [those animals] killed by strangling or by a violent blow or by a head-long fall or by the goring of horns, and those from which a wild animal has eaten, except what you [are able to] slaughter [before its death], and those which are sacrificed on stone altars, and [prohibited is] that you seek decision through divining arrows. That is grave disobedience. This day those who disbelieve have despaired of [defeating] your religion; so fear them not, but fear Me. This day I have perfected for you your religion and completed My favor upon you and have approved for you Islam as religion. But whoever is forced by severe hunger with no inclination to sin - then indeed, Allah is Forgiving and Merciful. 5: 3.
Another Ayah to prove that their claims are false regarding 'missing and lost' ayat of the Qur'an.
Indeed, it is We who sent down the Qur'an and indeed, We will be its guardian. 15: 9
This is just one example btw! Only the knowledgeable among them are said to be kuffar because they propagate these ideologies while knowing them to be false! We can't say that the ignorant adherents of Shi'ism are kuffar because it's their scholars that have made these views fair-seeming to them. They are also unable to distinguish between truth and falsehood due to their ignorance.
Nevertheless, they iterate laa ilaaha ila Allah Muhammadu rasuul Allah.
Hafez
VIP
Wallahi Iyo Billahi there is proof in that video and the proof is the defectiveness of their methodology of ilm Al Rijaal. We know the authentic hadiths due to the science of ilm Al-Rijaal. Besides, scholars agree on the authenticity and weakness of MOST of the hadiths besides a few because some Scholars might notice a weakness in a narrator whilst others do not.I watched the video and it didn't prove anything. It could be argued that not all hadiths Sunnis deem to be Sahih are actually authentic. Didn't Sh Al-Albani class some hadiths from Sahih al-Bukhari as da'eef?
You're ignorance knows no bounds.
Not all Shia are Kuffaar. The laymen shia are excused for their distorted beliefs because they are misled by their faasiq imams just like some Sunnis are misled by corrupt Sunni scholars.
S
SOMACOON
Guest
Are you truly a Muslim? Sharia is the word of God, it cannot be changed.
Sharia is not a monolith. That's why its interpretation changes from country to country. Sharia doesn't need to be changed when it already has changed and will continue to change ...
So explain why there are weak and fabricated hadiths in Sahih al-Bukhari according to Sh Al-Albani?
@SOMACOON Sharia is not only based on the Quran, but also on hadiths so how can it be the word of God?
Shia's and Ibadi's have their own hadiths, thus they have their own Sharia. There isn't one form of Sharia and there a several different interpretation of the Sunni Sharia so what did I say that would make me a non-Muslim?
Hafez
VIP
That's according to Albani. Every scholar makes mistakes, scholars have made this reality very clear. The prominent scholars of Hadith (Muhaditheen) disagree on only a few of the ahadiths. This is due to the fact that one scholar might have information about a specific narrator that the other scholar did not come across.
This is what ilm Al-Rijaal exists for, to distinguish between authentic narration and fabrications. When the muhaditheen DO disagree, it's not usually far-fetched. For example one would consider a Hadith to be sahiih whilst another muhaddith considers it hasan, thus it can be acted upon regardless.
The general rule is that the 6 kitaabs and the Sunan of ibn Ahmad, Muwatta of Malik contain the most authentic ahadith.
If you're this ignorant why not ask those who do know? Instead of acting as if you have the answers and debating with people?
S
SOMACOON
Guest
I'm a Suuni, a follower of the prophet and his sunnah. Shias shouldn't be compared to Suunis.So explain why there are weak and fabricated hadiths in Sahih al-Bukhari according to Sh Al-Albani?
@SOMACOON Sharia is not only based on the Quran, but also on hadiths so how can it be the word of God?
Majority of the regulations in Sharia are laws mentioned in the Quraan, as for the Hadiths, no one can change a, "SAXIIX" Hadith;
Meaning any Hadith written in the Sharia code whom were borrowed from companions are "SAXIIX" Hadiths. They've all been reported to be 100% true, written is saxiixul bukhaari, and a saxiix hadith cannot be changed. Just as the word of Allah cannot be changed. (Sharia)
The prophet has told us, Islam is the only protected religion given to humanity. Meaning no one can change the word of God.
As mentioned by the prophet himself, there will be 73 fiqras, all claiming the, "sunnah" component.
He who changes the sunnah has gone astray, diinta waa inaad si ficaan u barto, you support homosexuality and have the audacity to say SHARIA, (the word of God) has been changed. Or could be changed. Isku laabo qofyahay, toobad keen.
- Status
