are you mentally challenged? you want people to be dismembered for the lowest form of crime? stop advocating for sharia for countries you dont live in, i can already tell you are diaspora you doqon. not even taliban have gone this far
Steal what? I don’t think in the entirety of mainstream Islamic legal history that anyone had a hand cut off for petty theft. I also wonder why sharia is always reduced to a set of laws in these discussions? It’s much more than thatare you mentally challenged? you want people to be dismembered for the lowest form of crime? stop advocating for sharia for countries you dont live in, i can already tell you are diaspora you doqon. not even taliban have gone this far
Steal what? I don’t think in the entirety of mainstream Islamic legal history that anyone had a hand cut off for petty theft. I also wonder why sharia is always reduced to a set of laws in these discussions? It’s much more than that
No. I’m advocating for a system where the ulama are independent from government both legally and financially and interpret the Quran and Sunnah and derive rulings that are appropriate for each context and scenario and those rulings are binding to the society.So are you advocating for system in which you pick and choose? I think this is what @World is getting at tbh. People say they want full implementation but when actual views of Madhabs are taken and actually implemented, they’ll bulk. Example, a poster tried to insinuate World must be lying and a gaal, why? Because he can’t stomach that view.
Not all theft is done in secrecy. That’s why we have the phrase daylight robbery.That’s literally all forms of stealing though? Stealth= secretly. Minimum value? Thats very vague. The minimum value could be a bagel? Most thief do have legal capacity ect, hence it is still a lowest form of crime. I don’t know what you’re getting at here.
Minimum value would be in accordance to the social context and situation and is something that the scholars of a society will set guidelines for and decide upon. It will certainly never be bagels though.
If theft has reached a level where a had punishment is specified. It is not petty theft or the lowest form of crime. It is punishable by cutting off the hands.
Fundamentally, whatever the scholars decide is appropriate, I have no qualms with it provided the scholarly class is a decentralised, open-access and independent institution.
Your posts seem to present individual reasons for not implementing Shariah law, but you avoid directly stating that you oppose it. It's like making a list of complaints about children—like them being loud, smelly, or expensive—then acting outraged if someone suggests that you don’t want kids, saying, "That’s not what I said!"Are you scared to @ me or replying to my posts? Calling random people atheists for posting what madhab say?
May Allah guide you.
A good deterrent. Also, it's not only the diaspora who think like this; everyone who calls themselves a Muslim and submits their will to Allah and His legislation does as well. The only mentally challenged is you.are you mentally challenged? you want people to be dismembered for the lowest form of crime? stop advocating for sharia for countries you dont live in, i can already tell you are diaspora you doqon. not even taliban have gone this far
are you even reading what you are saying? you, a diaspora who likely lives in his small dinky apartment in Bristol is advocating for sharia in a country you don't live in. asking for sharia while enjoying the benefits of the "kafir" west absolutely shameless and the height of hypocrisyA good deterrent. Also, it's not only the diaspora who think like this; everyone who calls themselves a Muslim and submits their will to Allah and His legislation does as well. The only mentally challenged is you.
Wdym I would also want Sharia here. Also i'm not from Bristol.are you even reading what you are saying? you, a diaspora who likely lives in his small dinky apartment in Bristol is advocating for sharia in a country you don't live in. asking for sharia while enjoying the benefits of the "kafir" west absolutely shameless and the height of hypocrisy
why bring up the way i type? or can you not argue your negative iq points anymoreAlso, the way you type, are you 12? Who am I even talking to?