what do guys think will be the solution to the somaliland-puntland dispute

[Abdalla]

Most of PL and Sland beef is territory. We believe it’s our because of tribal reasons they believe it’s theres because it’s british drawn lines.

Sool is completely landlocked so they can’t form their own state. Economically it’s not long term feasible. That’s why khattumo would be a failure if we didn’t backstab them when they almost formed it.

That’s why you see so many Sool people go between SL and PL. If there smart, they’ll use kismayo port and they have enough political clout as it is in PL so they can get their aid money and develop their region.

@Abdalla @Yonis @Ahmed sheikh Bararsame and Jama siyaad are total Sland lackeys along with the bastard Mahad Cambashe who torments the residents anytime they protest.

Why aren’t we fighting with them? And putting Mohamud garaad as the top dog in LA. What’s with this soft approach towards them? Not one person can answer me that

Naleye Ahmed is the strongest if it's mano y mano. But Naleye Ahmed alone can't hold stance against Jamac Siyad and Bahararsame. So unless one of them changes colour, capturing LA is not sustainable. The Tukraq wars showed that if it comes to military that PL inflicts more harm and damage to SL, but its not for the long term.

However there's a new kid on the block. Cumar Maxamuud is officially in Sool now. Interesting to see how it plays out.

 

[CirJiid]

Your logic doesn't make sense. That's like saying the Brits are taking an L because Zimbabwe rules a minority settler of Brits in Zimbabwe. Also Ogaden has been controlling Issaq in the Hawd and massacred them (It's haram and they'll be judged). You only rule a small section of Darood by paying their rent money to their traidors and Darood ruled you with an iron fist during the kacaan era and your controlled by Ogaden in the Hawd. You should be the last one talking and don't use broad terms like "Darood."

If it didn't make sense or strike nerves these topics wouldnt be so repeating. Darud is darud to us

 

[towerheist]

This was a revolutionary comment and none of you said anything. My high IQ is wasted on you mere mortals. Watch Rick and Morty to gain some IQ

Spoiler

You don't have permission to view the spoiler content. Log in or register now.

 

[Cognitivedissonance]

Exactly.

Kaskiqabbe, GeeseGulle and Liibangashe are also Bah Isaaq right?

If Ciise Madoobe lived next to Bah Majeerteen (Warsangeli, Majeerteen, Dashishe) we may have been in the same predicament. We would have joined Djibouti.

Maternal ties are strong.

Dhisheshe and dhulbhante have the same isaaq mother

 

[shum33]

what claim does SL have? PL is the harti state of somalia, that includes all harti lands

thats not how countries work,somaliland has a defined border cause it consider itself to be a country,doesn't care about harti or whatever
while puntland is a somaliland wannabe which can't be a country and doesn't want to reespect the country its in,what do you consder puntalnd to be a country or a region,i wonder?

 

[shum33]

Dumbass, PL actually captured Las Anod back in 2004. kulaha "SL has always won on the battlefield and "PL can't defeat SL." Your some weirdo if you believe that. SL and PL have been fighting each other in the disputed border and guess who won? SL still doesn't have control of the territory they claim and it's always a stalemate so take your bs somewhere ese. If SL was so tough, they wouldn't even allow PL to take their territories from them in the beginning and later recapture it In a "surprise" attack using significant Dhulo mercenaries.

touchy ain't we,somaliland is still gaining ground in the "disputed area",its in control of the regions it claims,it has defined borders,if it get the recognition its been after and finally get to completely support itself puntland won't be a problem anymore,tell me laas anod belongs to who?
SL are tough the problem is the economy as soon as we get that in order youll see how tough they are

 

[shum33]

For Col.caare case I not will defend him. But the facts says SL try to ambush him near the mountains and failed. Sorry to bring it up to you but the only time PL vs SL on open battle was 2003 and we crash you. After that AY went south with half the army. Since that time we start to hear your voice. Second fact in Sool and Sanaag your army is not present there. You using your money to pay clan rebels like SSC to fight us. Same goes to Sanaag, but after PL terrifies you loses Sanaag and Cayn. Soon Sool.

PL can't terrify SL sahib,area like sanaag are hard to control,millitary expenditures is not a joke. not only that somali states are poor but sanaag has nothing to offer,its just important for SL plan for recognition to control its borders. 2003?bro SL is still consolidating its power,its not going to be tommorow till they have total control sanaag and some parts in sool,but they will

 

[Younes Osman]

If it didn't make sense or strike nerves these topics wouldnt be so repeating. Darud is darud to us

Dhisheshe and dhulbhante have the same isaaq mother

isn't dhulbahante mother the dhulbahante and not issaq because I dont have darod lineage in my family

 

[Galool]

As a neutral observer, I can see Somaliland has done more for this region than Puntland.

Therefore they should stay with the ones benefiting them.

 

[Tukraq]

thats not how countries work,somaliland has a defined border cause it consider itself to be a country,doesn't care about harti or whatever
while puntland is a somaliland wannabe which can't be a country and doesn't want to reespect the country its in,what do you consder puntalnd to be a country or a region,i wonder?

Somaliland has never been a country, and never will be, get that out your head, we’re talking states within Somalia here, and no there’s no defined borders which is why there’s the dispute in the first place

 

[Younes Osman]

Somaliland has never been a country, and never will be, get that out your head, we’re talking states within Somalia here, and no there’s no defined borders which is why there’s the dispute in the first place

It was a country from 1880 to 1960

 

[Tukraq]

It was a country from 1880 to 1960

Nope just a colony, and not an official one at that especially in the disputed regions where they never controlled due to the mad mullah

 

[Tukraq]

 

[Younes Osman]

Somaliland has never been a country, and never will be, get that out your head, we’re talking states within Somalia here, and no there’s no defined borders which is why there’s the dispute in the first place

Somaliland has never been a country, and never will be, get that out your head, we’re talking states within Somalia here, and no there’s no defined borders which is why there’s the dispute in the first place

People voted to leave the union with a high 90 percentile range. People in somaliland can remove themselves out of union if they will after all it was my great grandparents and grandparents and many others choice to form a union with konnfurta somaliyeed.

 

[Younes Osman]

Nope just a colony, and not an official one at that especially in the disputed regions where they never controlled due to the mad mullah

It was a protectorate not a colony

 

[Tukraq]

It was a protectorate not a colony

Check the map I posted, it wasn’t a real thing

British only had power over issaq, no such thing as somaliland historically, more of a new concept post civil war

 

[Younes Osman]

Check the map I posted, it wasn’t a real thingView attachment 80787
British only had power over issaq, no such thing as somaliland historically, more of a new concept post civil war[/QUOTE

British protectorate of somaliland

 

[Younes Osman]

Lol......

 

[Louis Vuitton Don]

It was a protectorate not a colony

Call it what you want. British ran your territory and were calling the shots. You forefathers were so passive that they didn’t even need to force your hand like other Somalis.

 

[CirJiid]

I luvz all the calaacal. Darud so insecure they used kacan to change somalian history in there favour