A youtuber visits Puntland

[EyiPunter]

Wdym

These people in that entire YouTube video look Somalibantu. Somalibantu are from so called Jubaland and is now prospering and its safe there now. So they should head back.

 

[Eyes-of-Ibad]

They were there over 100 years ago
View attachment 329944

I knew you would reference that source. Their population is extremely small. Even today they are nowhere near the BS number the British author mentioned 100 years ago. They are called Bah Mumiin and live in a few towns like Bandar Beyla

 

[Sigmundd]

Ive seen a recent video similar to this and I was astonished by the amount of them. These people have to take control of the population before they are out numbered. I person would ship them to South Somalia in the juberland region.

Why is president deni or whatever his name is allowing more of them to enter Puntland considering their isn't any job for them? does he want puntland to be replaced by them? don't these people ever think maybe just maybe ethnic Somalis will cease to exist the more you keep them in your territory??

 

[killerxsmoke]

Oh shut up never ever did i say they should be kicked out i said be RELOCATED to a safer area in southern Somalia rather than them being in the camps for nothing since other skillfull people are taking over. And yes they aren't native to Puntland so why should we continue to allow the idp camps running when their region is now safe to return to? Puntland did an amazing thing to accept them and help them out and now since their region is stable they can all sagely return. I will forever speal about Puntland what you going to do stop me through your screen? behave yourself.

And they arent native to jubaland?? They have been living in puntland for over 100 years, same in jubaland and your telling me they should relocate somewhere they arent native to. Just be a brave girl and say that you dont want no bantus living in puntland it's simple

 

[Magan Joseph]

I gotta applaud SSC we might have our differences but at least they dont have non ethnic Somalis in their territory. If they do fully succeed from Somaliland than I think they should request for referendum. @Pastoralist

@Abdixakim how come it’s only the two of us laughing at this

 

[wonyluvr]

These people in that entire YouTube video look Somalibantu. Somalibantu are from so called Jubaland and is now prospering and its safe there now. So they should head back.

not necessarily true.They live in multiple gobals Hirshabelle,Banaadir,SWS and Jubaland they live in mostly riverine areas and in coastal cities Merka,Barva and Xamar.

I don’t know much about how safe it is but they are displaced for a reason I don’t think they have any homes anymore since AS have destroyed the livelihoods of many

 

[EyiPunter]

Why is president deni or whatever his name is allowing more of them to enter Puntland considering their isn't any job for them? does he want puntland to be replaced by them? don't these people ever think maybe just maybe ethnic Somalis will cease to exist the more you keep them in your territory??

Abyo macan Ive have the same sentiment about this points your make. We have to understand that some of these leader don't really look at what on the ground but more of a big picture people. Puntland and all Somali regions should have census of the ethnic makeup of it people. These census that I propose can be taken 3 from one from School another from job and addition from residential. If Puntland does have a handle on this it will be a bigger problem to deal with in the next 5 to 10 years because they will be demanding the rights of ethic Somalis. The only solution is to ship them to Jubaland.

 

[wonyluvr]

Abyo macan Ive have the same sentiment about this points your make. We have to understand that some of these leader don't really look at what on the ground but more of a big picture people. Puntland and all Somali regions should have census of the ethnic makeup of it people. These census that I propose can be taken 3 from one from School another from job and addition from residential. If Puntland does have a handle on this it will be a bigger problem to deal with in the next 5 to 10 years because they will be demanding the rights of ethic Somalis. The only solution is to ship them to Jubaland.

a lot of them aren’t even from Jubaland

 

[Sigmundd]

And they arent native to jubaland?? They have been living in puntland for over 100 years, same in jubaland and your telling me they should relocate somewhere they arent native to. Just be a brave girl and say that you dont want no bantus living in puntland it's simple

They still been in the south for centuries. Besides Puntland don't want to be apart of Somalia anymore, I hope they come to their census and request for a referendum. Puntland is for puntland. You can take them in galmudug your region than.

 

[EyiPunter]

a lot of them aren’t even from Jubaland

close enough if not there Kenya maybe.

 

[wonyluvr]

They still been in the south for centuries. Besides Puntland don't want to be apart of Somalia anymore, I hope they come to their census and request for a referendum. Puntland is for puntland. You can take them in galmudug your region than.

Puntland don’t want to be apart of Somalia???
I think they reject the current government but they still are apart of Somalia regardless.

Mudug is spilt in half between Galmudug and Puntland.

 

[Sigmundd]

Abyo macan Ive have the same sentiment about this points your make. We have to understand that some of these leader don't really look at what on the ground but more of a big picture people. Puntland and all Somali regions should have census of the ethnic makeup of it people. These census that I propose can be taken 3 from one from School another from job and addition from residential. If Puntland does have a handle on this it will be a bigger problem to deal with in the next 5 to 10 years because they will be demanding the rights of ethic Somalis. The only solution is to ship them to Jubaland.

They wont ever demand because if they do they can easily be deported to Somalia since that's where they are from. Is more of the question when will they be relocated permanently? time is ticking, I honestly think Puntland should leave Somalia. Puntland can do much better on its own.

 

[killerxsmoke]

close enough if not there Kenya maybe.

Its Tanzania

 

[wonyluvr]

close enough if not there Kenya maybe.

They aren’t from Kenya either.Most of the IDPS come from farming communities along with rivers which is why once everything stabilises they can come back

 

[Sigmundd]

Puntland don’t want to be apart of Somalia???
I think they reject the current government but they still are apart of Somalia regardless.

Mudug is spilt in half between Galmudug and Puntland.

A lot have been vocal recently in wanting referendum. Well some..

 

[wonyluvr]

A lot have been vocal recently in wanting referendum. Well some..

It’s a known fact some of them are like that but it’s none of my business

 

[killerxsmoke]

They still been in the south for centuries. Besides Puntland don't want to be apart of Somalia anymore, I hope they come to their census and request for a referendum. Puntland is for puntland. You can take them in galmudug your region than.

Ok then they can start leaving Mogadishu and show the bantus an example

 

[wonyluvr]

They wont ever demand because if they do they can easily be deported to Somalia since that's where they are from. Is more of the question when will they be relocated permanently? time is ticking, I honestly think Puntland should leave Somalia. Puntland can do much better on its own.

They are miskiin IDPs who got displaced during the civil war you should be careful with what you say about people who are in that situation because of trauma events abayo mcn

 

[Sigmundd]

Ok then they can start leaving Mogadishu and show the bantus an example

That's up to them if they want to leave. What does that got to do with me? My concern is Puntland, Somaliland

 

[EyiPunter]

Its Tanzania

Tanzania the past few years was letting Somalibantu come back to Tanzania and even offered them citizenship because they are genetical from there. I think Somalia and all its regions should be predominately ethnic Somali.